Author 
Message 
TAGS:

Hide Tags

Retired Moderator
Joined: 16 Nov 2010
Posts: 1162
Location: United States (IN)
Concentration: Strategy, Technology

A group of 8 friends sit together in a circle. Alice, Betty
[#permalink]
Show Tags
26 Dec 2010, 08:47
Question Stats:
33% (00:38) correct 67% (01:21) wrong based on 60 sessions
HideShow timer Statistics
A group of 8 friends sit together in a circle. Alice, Betty and Candy are three members of the group of friends. (i) If Alice refuses to sit beside Betty unless Candy sits on the other side of Alice as well, how many possible seating arrangements can there be? (ii) 2 latecomers then come to join the group, and they have to sit apart from each other. How many possible seating arrangements can there be, bearing in mind the condition from (i)? Answer (i)  3840
Answer (ii)  212160
_________________
Formula of Life > Achievement/Potential = k * Happiness (where k is a constant) GMAT Club Premium Membership  big benefits and savings




Math Expert
Joined: 02 Sep 2009
Posts: 65764

Re: Another tricky Circular Permutation Problem
[#permalink]
Show Tags
26 Dec 2010, 10:03
subhashghosh wrote: Hi I am a bit perplexed by this another tricky Circular Permutation problem : A group of 8 friends sit together in a circle. Alice, Betty and Candy are three members of the group of friends. (i) If Alice refuses to sit beside Betty unless Candy sits on the other side of Alice as well, how many possible seating arrangements can there be? (ii) 2 latecomers then come to join the group, and they have to sit apart from each other. How many possible seating arrangements can there be, bearing in mind the condition from (i)? Answer (i)  3840 Answer (ii)  212160 The phrase "sit apart from each other" is confusing me a lot Regards, Subhash Note that this is not the GMAT type question and it's beyond the GMAT scope. A group of 8 friends sit together in a circle. Alice, Betty and Candy are three members of the group of friends.(i) If Alice refuses to sit beside Betty unless Candy sits on the other side of Alice as well, how many possible seating arrangements can there be? Total ways to arrange 8 people around the table is (81)!=7!; Arrangement when Betty and Candy do sit together is (71)!*2=6!*2 ({1}, {2}, {3}, {4}, {5}, {6}, {AB} these 7 units can be arranged around the table in (71)!=6! and A and B can be arranged within the unit in 2 ways). Now, these arrangements will also include arrangements when Candy sits on the other side of Alice as well, # of these arrangement is (61)!*2=5!*2 ({1}, {2}, {3}, {4}, {5}, {CAB} these 6 units can be arranged around the table in (61)!=5! and {CAB} can be arranged within the unit in 2 ways: {CAB} and {BAC}); So we'll have 7!(6!*25!*2)=3,840. (ii) 2 latecomers then come to join the group, and they have to sit apart from each other. How many possible seating arrangements can there be, bearing in mind the condition from (i)? When A and B does not sit together: (7!6!*2)*8*7; When A sits between C and B: one latecomer sits between A and B: (5!*2)*2*7; latecomers don't sit between these 3: (5!*2)*6*5; Total: (7!6!*2)*8*7+(5!*2)*2*7+(5!*2)*6*5=211,160
_________________




Intern
Joined: 24 Jun 2012
Posts: 41
Location: India
Concentration: Strategy, General Management

A group of 8 friends sit together in a circle. Alice, Betty
[#permalink]
Show Tags
01 May 2016, 00:02
Hi Bunuel  Can you please explain (ii) in more detail:
When A and B does not sit together: (7!6!*2)*8*7; (I didn't understand why you multiply by 8 and 7 here?)
When A sits between C and B: one latecomer sits between A and B: (5!*2)*2*7; latecomers don't sit between these 3: (5!*2)*6*5;
Total: (7!6!*2)*8*7+(5!*2)*2*7+(5!*2)*6*5=211,160
Thanks for your help!



Current Student
Joined: 03 Apr 2013
Posts: 258
Location: India
Concentration: Marketing, Finance
GMAT 1: 740 Q50 V41
GPA: 3

Re: A group of 8 friends sit together in a circle. Alice, Betty
[#permalink]
Show Tags
23 Jun 2017, 03:50
Bunuel wrote: subhashghosh wrote: Hi I am a bit perplexed by this another tricky Circular Permutation problem : A group of 8 friends sit together in a circle. Alice, Betty and Candy are three members of the group of friends. (i) If Alice refuses to sit beside Betty unless Candy sits on the other side of Alice as well, how many possible seating arrangements can there be? (ii) 2 latecomers then come to join the group, and they have to sit apart from each other. How many possible seating arrangements can there be, bearing in mind the condition from (i)? Answer (i)  3840 Answer (ii)  212160 The phrase "sit apart from each other" is confusing me a lot Regards, Subhash Note that this is not the GMAT type question and it's beyond the GMAT scope. A group of 8 friends sit together in a circle. Alice, Betty and Candy are three members of the group of friends.(i) If Alice refuses to sit beside Betty unless Candy sits on the other side of Alice as well, how many possible seating arrangements can there be? Total ways to arrange 8 people around the table is (81)!=7!; Arrangement when Betty and Candy do sit together is (71)!*2=6!*2 ({1}, {2}, {3}, {4}, {5}, {6}, {AB} these 7 units can be arranged around the table in (71)!=6! and A and B can be arranged within the unit in 2 ways). Now, these arrangements will also include arrangements when Candy sits on the other side of Alice as well, # of these arrangement is (61)!*2=5!*2 ({1}, {2}, {3}, {4}, {5}, {CAB} these 6 units can be arranged around the table in (61)!=5! and {CAB} can be arranged within the unit in 2 ways: {CAB} and {BAC}); So we'll have 7!(6!*25!*2)=3,840. (ii) 2 latecomers then come to join the group, and they have to sit apart from each other. How many possible seating arrangements can there be, bearing in mind the condition from (i)? When A and B does not sit together: (7!6!*2)*8*7; When A sits between C and B: one latecomer sits between A and B: (5!*2)*2*7; latecomers don't sit between these 3: (5!*2)*6*5; Total: (7!6!*2)*8*7+(5!*2)*2*7+(5!*2)*6*5=211,160 BunuelI could solve the problem, I have a question about the interpretation of language. The condition is that Alice refuses to sit beside Betty unless Candy sits on the other side of Alice as well. So this means that Alice will sit with Betty only if Candy is also there, but Alice can sit with Candy even if Betty is not there. Now this translation took me a while, can you please suggest somewhere to read about how to translate this logic language into something understandable? it will be great help. And if GMAT were to write this question..will it use the same language to express this situation?



Math Expert
Joined: 02 Sep 2009
Posts: 65764

Re: A group of 8 friends sit together in a circle. Alice, Betty
[#permalink]
Show Tags
23 Jun 2017, 05:22
ShashankDave wrote: Bunuel wrote: subhashghosh wrote: Hi I am a bit perplexed by this another tricky Circular Permutation problem : A group of 8 friends sit together in a circle. Alice, Betty and Candy are three members of the group of friends. (i) If Alice refuses to sit beside Betty unless Candy sits on the other side of Alice as well, how many possible seating arrangements can there be? (ii) 2 latecomers then come to join the group, and they have to sit apart from each other. How many possible seating arrangements can there be, bearing in mind the condition from (i)? Answer (i)  3840 Answer (ii)  212160 The phrase "sit apart from each other" is confusing me a lot Regards, Subhash Note that this is not the GMAT type question and it's beyond the GMAT scope. A group of 8 friends sit together in a circle. Alice, Betty and Candy are three members of the group of friends.(i) If Alice refuses to sit beside Betty unless Candy sits on the other side of Alice as well, how many possible seating arrangements can there be? Total ways to arrange 8 people around the table is (81)!=7!; Arrangement when Betty and Candy do sit together is (71)!*2=6!*2 ({1}, {2}, {3}, {4}, {5}, {6}, {AB} these 7 units can be arranged around the table in (71)!=6! and A and B can be arranged within the unit in 2 ways). Now, these arrangements will also include arrangements when Candy sits on the other side of Alice as well, # of these arrangement is (61)!*2=5!*2 ({1}, {2}, {3}, {4}, {5}, {CAB} these 6 units can be arranged around the table in (61)!=5! and {CAB} can be arranged within the unit in 2 ways: {CAB} and {BAC}); So we'll have 7!(6!*25!*2)=3,840. (ii) 2 latecomers then come to join the group, and they have to sit apart from each other. How many possible seating arrangements can there be, bearing in mind the condition from (i)? When A and B does not sit together: (7!6!*2)*8*7; When A sits between C and B: one latecomer sits between A and B: (5!*2)*2*7; latecomers don't sit between these 3: (5!*2)*6*5; Total: (7!6!*2)*8*7+(5!*2)*2*7+(5!*2)*6*5=211,160 BunuelI could solve the problem, I have a question about the interpretation of language. The condition is that Alice refuses to sit beside Betty unless Candy sits on the other side of Alice as well. So this means that Alice will sit with Betty only if Candy is also there, but Alice can sit with Candy even if Betty is not there. Now this translation took me a while, can you please suggest somewhere to read about how to translate this logic language into something understandable? it will be great help. And if GMAT were to write this question..will it use the same language to express this situation?This is not a GMAT question, hence the tag Out of scope/Too hard. You can ignore it altogether and move on.
_________________




Re: A group of 8 friends sit together in a circle. Alice, Betty
[#permalink]
23 Jun 2017, 05:22




