I’m not sure whether GMAC has considered this type of writing as “unidiomatic.” However, within the realm of professional writing, “which”, generally, is used in two restrictive modifier situations of which I am aware. (I just used one 😄)
“Let it be noted that there are two exceptions to the use of “THAT” to introduce a defining clause.
One is a situation when the demonstrative THAT and the relative THAT come together, as in this sentence:
The latent opposition to rearming Germany is as strong as THAT THAT has found public expression.
Idiomatically, the expression should be changed to THAT WHICH.”
In other words, the construction “that which” may not necessarily be a grammatical error in this sentence correction problem.
“The second exception is the situation in which the relative pronoun follows a Preposition:
of which
for which
about which
etc.”
The bottom line:
“that which” isn’t necessarily a “wrong” construction.
In this sentence correction problem, it seems as if it is another construction thrown in to distract the unwary test taker from the easier errors present in the sentence.
If I were to see “that which” used in a similar manner to how the author used the construction in this problem, I would not immediately use the construction as a basis to eliminate the answer choice.
Unless the OE has specifically stated “that which” is “clumsy” or “awkward” or one of the other adjectives GMAC enjoys using………
Teitsuya
chetan2u
Samcom
After weeks of uncertainty about the course the country would pursue to stabilize its troubled economy, officials reached a revised agreement with the International
Monetary Fund, pledging the enforcement of substantially greater budget discipline as that which was originally promised and to keep inflation below ten percent.
(A) the enforcement of substantially greater budget discipline as that which was originally promised and to keep inflation below ten percent
(B) the enforcement of substantially greater budget discipline than originally promised and keeping inflation below the ten percent figure
(C) to enforce substantially greater budget discipline than originally promised and to keep inflation below ten percent
(D) to enforce substantially greater budget discipline than that which was originally promised and keeping inflation less than the ten percent figure
(E) to enforce substantially greater budget discipline as that which was originally promised and to keep inflation less than ten percent
Two flaws..
1) THAT WHICH is unidiomatic A,D and E are out
2) the modifier starts with pledging and then has two parallel activities -- to enforce and to keep..
Only C follows both
Hi
chetan2u"1) THAT WHICH is unidiomatic"
Is it an absolute rule? I meant it's already 100% incorrect?
Posted from my mobile device