cheetarah1980
businessschool2015
So I recently was admitted from the waitlist to Booth. I was also admitted to Kellogg with a scholarship ($20k/year).
My goal is to go into private equity, with a backup plan of consulting/corporate strategy. I'm leaning towards Kellogg because I think I'd enjoy my time there more and the scholarship money is a nice boost (Booth wasn't able to offer me anything). I think Booth probably has the edge in academics and rankings which is why I'm considering there instead.
What do you think is a better option for me at this point?
You'll do fine either way. PE recruiting is mostly off-campus anyways so there's not a ton of on campus recruitment at any school and even the firms that do recruit/interview on campus don't hire en mass. If you're really in a conundrum check out the alumni directory of both schools. You can start to get an idea of where alums are working and if that aligns with the industry and jobs you're seeking then that could help you decide. If both schools come out of that exercise still equal then go where you'll get the MBA experience that you want.
good point on that PE recruiting is done off campus and follows a completely different schedule than IB/consulting recruiting.
but i would disagree on making a case for which one to attend based on alums though - you don't know the background of many of them. they could have already gotten a job offer from their previous firms before b-school, etc. too much analysis with bad/imperfect info = no analysis.
for example: let's assume that there are more PE offers at X. many people who want to go into PE are choosing X over Y, so there should be more PE-focused people at X. competition goes up and you're 1 of 200 going for 100 offers. then you consider Y, where less people go for PE. you're then 1 of 50 going for 30 offers. the odds are obviously made up and can be anything - you'll never get that info especially since you don't know what your class looks like.
hell, your classmates' career goals or even yours may change. hakuna matoto.