manish8242
Hi,sajjad
How can we determine that Branches doesn't take part in food production? In the passage it is just said that food is Produced MAINLY in Stem and not Leaves. So it might be possible leaves play a minor role in that. Also nothing is said about Branches. The option 3 in Q1 doesn't include the word 'LIKELY' it directly says a bold line so how can we say its right
Read the text which is relevant to
III"Most plants have small leaves, modified leaves (spines), or no leaves at all. The main food-producing organ is not the leaf but the stem, which is often green and non-woody."
and
"Spines and thorns (modified branches) protect against predators and also minimize water loss."
The passage says: the main food-producing organ is the stem, not the leaf.
If the main organ is the stem, that means leaves are not the main site so leaves (and hence spines, which are modified leaves) do not play the main role, but could they still participate directly in food production?
For spines: since they are modified leaves, they typically lack chlorophyll and do not perform photosynthesis so they indeed do not participate directly in food production.
For thorns (modified branches): branches in many plants can be photosynthetic if green, but the passage says the stem is the main food-producing organ, and these thorns are likely not green/photosynthetic (implied by their protective role and minimization of water loss). The passage does not explicitly say thorns are photosynthetic, so we can infer they do not participate directly in food production.
If you think maybe green branches could photosynthesize, so modified branches (thorns) might still do a bit of photosynthesis, then III might seem not necessarily true. But the passage’s wording suggests that in these desert plants, the stem is the primary photosynthetic organ, and spines/thorns are specialized for protection/water reduction, not food production.
Spines = modified leaves, hence not main food production (and since they’re spines, not green, no photosynthesis).
Thorns = modified branches, hence protective, water loss reduction, no mention of photosynthesis.
III can be inferred.