Despite forceful legal pleas for the restitution of expropriated cultu

Question

Despite forceful legal pleas for the restitution of expropriated cultural artifacts to the place of their origin, the British Museum continues to rebuff the Greek authorities requesting that it should return the Parthenon marbles removed from the Acro by Lord Elgin in 1806.

(A) requesting that it should

(B) requesting them to

(C) and its request to

(D) who request that it

(E) who request them to

(A) requesting that it should

(B) requesting them to

(C) and its request to

(D) who request that it

(E) who request them to

ChrisLele · Accepted Answer

This question hinges on two things:

1) Who is doing the requesting?
2) What is the idiomatic form of 'requesting'

The answer to 1) is the Greek authorities - they want the British Museum return the Elgin marbles. So we need an answer choice that clearly shows this relationship. Based on this information let's eliminate.

A) requesting that

This answer suggests that the British are doing the requesting. Notice that the subject of the main clause is 'British museum.' The verb phrase "continue to rebuff" refers to British Museum. So when you place the gerund 'requesting' it refers back to British Museum, which is clearly wrong.

B) requesting them

This answer choice makes a similar error with the use of 'requesting.' Also, British Museum, the one who should return the Elgin marbles, is a singular entity and thus requires 'it' not 'them.'

C) its request

Here we are implying that the British museum is doing the requesting

For point 2) we want the construction, "request that..." This is an example of the subjunctive voice, which is a person/thing is desiring something. Typically words in this tense, such as request, require the use of 'that.'

With this knowledge, we can clearly get rid of (E) who request them to.

Notice that (E) also use 'them' when it should be using 'it'.

Therefore the answer is (D) who request that it. Note that the 'who' clearly modifies Greek authorities (remember the touch rule).

Hope that helped

tharunv · Answer

Despite forceful legal pleas for the restitution of expropriated cultural artifacts to the place of their origin, the British Museum continues to rebuff the Greek authorities requesting that it should return the Parthenon marbles removed from the Acro by Lord Elgin in 1806.

(A) requesting that it should

(B) requesting them to

(C) and its request to

(D) who request that it

(E) who request them to

(A) requesting that it should 
 - who does it refer to Greek authorities or British Museum, so wrong 
(B) requesting them to
 - the Greek authorities are requesting, not British Museum  
(C) and its request to 
 - this would have been correct if it had been "and their request to" 
(D) who request that it 
 - this is the most apt, since Greek authorities are requesting and British Museum is the it being referred to here. 
(E) who request them to
 - the British Museum is singular and so can't be referred to as "them"

So the answer is D - what is the OA?

Wwdrok1 · Answer

I am not so sure about this one but here is how I used POE to deduct the answer:

(A) requesting that it should - this sounds weird to me but the best out of all the answer choices.
(B) requesting them to - them is plural and refers back to the museum, which is singular.
(C) and its request to - its is singular and refers back to authorities, which is plural.
(D) who request that it - who can only be used to describe a person.
(E) who request them to - who can only be used to describe a person.

leod · Answer

Meaning: Greek authorities demand that the British Museum (singular) return the Parthenon Marbles.

So, them (plural) cannot refer to a singular noun (the British Museum)- B & E out

Require + That + Subject + Command Subjunctive: The use of the modal "should" is incorrect- A is out

We are left with C & D:
Looking at it more closely, sentence C changes the meaning. According to this answer, Greek authorities intend to return the artefacts to the British Museum.

By POE we are left with D. D properly uses the command subjunctive after Require + That.

Can we use "Who" to refer to Greek authorities? Greek authorities could be referring to a group of scholars. Anyway, if you are unsure about a certain rule, there are many other rules tested in any given SC problems, so apply the ones you are certain about before diving into more complex grammatical issues.

premnath · Answer

Here is my approach.

Despite forceful legal pleas for the restitution of expropriated cultural artifacts to the place of their origin, the British Museum continues to rebuff the Greek authorities requesting that it should return the Parthenon marbles removed from the Acro by Lord Elgin in 1806.

(A) requesting that it should

(B) requesting them to

(C) and its request to

(D) who request that it

(E) who request them to

(A) requesting that it should   >> the problem is use of "should" along with 'requesting'. As per the rule of subjunctive mood we cannot use 'should' after 'request'. Hence, option is wrong

(B) requesting them to  >> 'ing' modifier without ',' before it modifies previous word, in this case "Greek authorities". This is OK. However, the problem is with the use of pronoun 'them'. It refers to singular antecedent 'the British Museum". So, the option is wrong

(C) and its request to  >> Wrong meaning. It shows the British Museum continues to rebuff its own request. Hence, wrong.

(D) who request that it  >> 'who' correctly refers to antecedent "the Greek authorities" also, "it" correctly refers to antecedent "the British Museum". Put on hold

(E) who request them to  >> 'them' wrongly refers to the singular antecedent "the British Museum". Hence, wrong.

Clearly only left out is D. Hence, answer is D.

My Notes:
(1) "ing" modifiers without "," modifies previous word. "ing" modifier with "," modifies previous clause or subject.
(2) Singular pronoun must refer to singular noun. And plural to plural.

chetan2u · Answer

Despite forceful legal pleas for the restitution of expropriated cultural artifacts to the place of their origin, the British Museum continues to rebuff the Greek authorities  requesting that it should  return the Parthenon marbles removed from the Acropolis by Lord Elgin in 1806.
(A) requesting that it should
(B) requesting them to
(C) and its request to
(D) who request that it
(E) who request them to

hi  smartyguy ,
firstly lets look at what this question tests and what likely errors can be there,
1) it is using the subjunctive mood so 'that'(preferrable) and basic form('return' is already in non underlined portion) of verb is required.
2) rebuff requires a noun as a recipient.. that is either the greek authorities was rebuffed or the greek authorities request was rebuffed , so we cannot have an 'ing' form.. Also the construction of sentence is such that requesting refers back to british museum... 
3)pronoun error is very common on GMAT.. british museum requires singular 'it'..
lets look at the choices..
(A)  requesting  that it should
requesting refers here to the british museum and not to intended greek authorities.... had it been ' request  that it should' would have been correct since refers to 'the greek authorities request'...
(B) requesting them to
same as A... plus pronoun error , also absence 
(C) and its request to
this means that the british museum rebuffed 'authorities' and also 'its request', a meaning that is not intended in original ...
(D)  who  request that it
correct... who refers back correctly to greek authorities... 
(E) who request them to
pronoun error..'them' is wrong.. that is preferrable..

Lucky2783 · Answer

Thanks for the very brief explanation. i think not knowing the dictionary meaning of word 'rebuff' took a toll on me. https://dictionary.reference.com/browse/rebuff

aniteshgmat1101 · Answer

Hi Chetan,
Kindly elaborate more on the highlighted portion of your reply. 
I am under an impression that when used without comma, verb+ing modifies the preceding Noun instead of the subject of preceding clause.

Thank you.

chetan2u · Answer

hi  aniteshgmat1101 ,
i dont say the construction of sentence is correct but i am commenting on the point of  requesting

if the sentence reads "  he went around the town requesting for help ... here requesting is modifying he and in no way town ... 
even if i replace town with someone logical who can request say authorities...
 he went to the authorities requesting for help ... i think it is he who is requesting...

but if i write.. he saw the authorities requesting for help ... here it is the authorities who are seen requesting...

so it does matter what the construction of the sentence is and accordingly the -ing form of request will modify..
hope it helped

akashbolster · Answer

Just for the Understanding, why "who" needed here, its making sentence awkward. Can anyone help?

sayantanc2k · Answer

The request is made by the Greek authorities. Usage of "requesting" implies that the request is made by the British museum. (A present participle modifier refers the subject of the previous clause).

The usage of "who" eliminates this error since the relative clause modifier "who request the...." refers to the noun it touchs, i.e., "Greek Authorities".

Bunuel · Answer

KAPLAN OFFICIAL EXPLANATION:

D

This question tests the usage of the subjunctive of requirement. In this formulation, a verb like request is followed by “that”, a subject, and the infinitive form of a verb without the “to”. The answer choice that uses this form correctly is (D). Note that we can ask some- one to do something, but we have to request that someone do something.

sanpreetsingh · Answer

(A) requesting that it should 
Subjunctive does no have should

(B) requesting them to 
The British Museum is singular so "them" is pronoun agreement issue

(C) and its request to 
distort --> It shows that Museum rebuff both the Authorities and its request

(D) who request that it

(E) who request them to
same as B

Hence D, is the answer.

ballest127 · Answer

In the phrase "the British Museum continues to rebuff the Greek authorities requesting that" , why not "requesting" modify authorities, because there is not "comma" before requesting ??

I understand that V.ing modifies the preceding noun if there is no comma before V.ing.

Please correct me if I'am wrong.

Thanks

GMATNinja · Answer

I agree with you: "requesting" seems to modify the "Greek authorities." (A) and (B) both contain other errors, though. In (A) it's illogical to request that someone "should" so something. I can request that you perform an action. I can express the belief that you  should  perform an action. But I wouldn't request the  belief  that you "should" do something. That wouldn't make any sense.

In (B) "them" has no logical antecedent. The request is made of the "museum," which is singular. So we have an agreement error.

I hope that helps!

s170618 · Answer

I have a doubt. 
You said that should cannot be used in choice A.
But look at the choice D, who request that it return. In my opinion 'should' here is just omitted. It is 'who request that it (should) return, or it should be 'who request that it 
returns'
So here we must omit should in the cases of require/demand/stipulate+that?
Hope to your reply, thanks!

MWithrock · Answer

WOW. I didn't even catch the subjunctive tone here.

My 2 cents.

Right away, A, B and E are gone, Requesting and Them are clearly not the words we want. Now, between C and D, its the Greeks who request. C does not work because if the sentence was referring to the greek authorities directly in this manner it would read the greek authorities and THEIR request.

priyanshu14 · Answer

Dear Sir,

I totally agree with your viewpoint. 
Please clarify that the corrected sentence seems to be awkward to read as nothing is there in between it and return?

"Despite forceful legal pleas for the restitution of expropriated cultural artifacts to the place of their origin, the British Museum continues to rebuff the Greek authorities  who request that it  return the Parthenon marbles removed from the Acro by Lord Elgin in 1806.

Kindly suggest. Thanks in advance

AjiteshArun · Answer

After  request that...  we need the plain form of the verb, the one that we use after  to . Putting something like a  should  there would just introduce redundancy.

Despite forceful legal pleas for the restitution of expropriated cultu

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

GMAT Sentence Correction (SC - EA only) Questions

Despite forceful legal pleas for the restitution of expropriated cultu

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards