Five times as many workers may be needed to construct a power plant as

Question

Aristotle RC 99 - Passage 16     
   Five times as many workers may be needed to construct a power plant as to operate it. The numbers may be even more disproportionate for a major pipeline or dam. When the construction ends, a substantial reduction in population is virtually guaranteed. Hence, there may be no justification for providing an infrastructure necessary to maintain adequate levels of service during the construction period. 
 
Money necessary to build water systems, schools and roads and to fund salaries and maintenance costs is mismatched by traditional taxing programs. The construction project is usually not subject to local property tax until it nears completion, which may be five years after the impact has occurred. Alternative sources of tax revenue cannot begin to cover the cost of providing the necessary services. Even if some governments have money, they may not be the right governments. Some entities may suffer the impact of development without being able to tax it. For example, a development may be located in the county just outside the limits of an incorporated city. The county will be entitled to tax the property while the city may receive most of the project population and demand for services. 
 
The 1960s and 1970s witnessed a new boomtown era in the West. The typical contemporary boomtown is fuelled by a quest for energy in the form of a fossil-fuelled electric generating plant, a hydroelectric dam or a new mine. The energy project is typically located near a small community or is forced to start a community from scratch. Often, the boomtown is poorly planned and under-financed. Long-time residents find their community changed for the worse and newcomers find the town an undesirable place to live. 
 
The boomtown is characterized by inadequate public services, undesirable labour conditions, confusion in community structure, and deterioration of the quality of life arising from rapid population growth due to a major economic stimulus. Accelerated growth is the most distinguishing characteristic of a boomtown. 
 
Studies have shown that large-scale development in sparsely populated areas causes major social problems. Housing, street and water systems construction, school development and police and fire protection lag far behind population growth. Rent and property tax increases join with a rise in the general cost of living to harm persons on fixed incomes. Education in the community may suffer. One result of boomtown living is higher incidence of divorce, depression, alcoholism and attempted suicide. Until recently, planners have ignored or understated such problems. While the boomtown promotes an ―us against them‖ mentality — the old timers versus persons brought to the community by the boom — the fact remains that all parties suffer. Newcomers may blame oldtimers for a lack of support just as old-timers may blame them for a deterioration of community life. Consequences of the boomtown also harm the project developer. The undesirable community results in poor worker productivity and frequent worker turnover, factors that delay construction and push projects over budget. Problems of rapid growth in some boomtowns are compounded by the fact that most of the population disappears with the completion of project construction.   1 
 1. It can be inferred from the passage that which of the following are possible ways in which a boomtown is affected by poor planning and under-financing? 
  
I. Unsatisfactory labour conditions 
II. Inadequate police protection 
III. Poor community relations 
 
A. II only 
B. I and III only 
C. II and III only 
D. I, II, and III 
E. I only 
 
 2 
 2. The passage suggests that there is often a lack of services associated with boomtowns. The author claims that all of the following are possible causal factors for the lack of services associated with a boomtown EXCEPT: 
  
A. the expected loss of a substantial number of residents after the completion of a project. 
B. lack of support from long-time residents. 
C. the location of an energy project just outside the limits of an incorporated city. 
D. the time lag between the beginning of project construction and the onset of tax payments for it. 
E. the mismatch between funds needed and traditional taxing programs 
 
 3  
 3. The tone of the author‘s discussion of traditional taxing programs in regard to boomtowns can best be described as: 
  
A. outraged 
B. concerned 
C. disbelieving 
D. complacent 
E. mocking

Project RC Butler 2020  -  Participate and win GMAT Club Tests.   
Passage # 101, Date: 21-May-2020
 This post is a part of Project RC Butler 2020 .  Click here for Details

abhinav770 · Answer

Yes,  archana89 . It is indeed the correct answer choice.

Hey  prashant6923 , as the question asks "It can be   inferred   from the passage that..." I believe we have to consider  unsatisfactory  and  undesired  as words which imply the same thing.

Gmatsaiyan · Answer

Topic and Scope  - Rapid growth and infrastructure problems in 60s and 70s western boomtowns
 Mapping the Passage 
¶1 notes that the population drop after a project is completed makes problems worse.
¶2 describes the reasons that money is scarce for infrastructure.
¶s3 and 4 describe the causes of modern boomtowns and introduce problems caused by the growth.
¶5 describes social problems and their negative impact on the project that caused the problems in the first place.

Gmatsaiyan · Answer

Answers and Explanations OE 
 1) Where are consequences of poor planning mentioned? While the author discusses them throughout the passage, there‘s a particular focus in ¶s3-5. RN I is mentioned explicitly in line 33 and expanded on in ¶5. RN II is mentioned in line 41. Note that at this point, all the answer choices except for (D) are eliminated, so you can save time by not evaluating the last statement! RN III is discussed in the context of the ―us against them‖ mentality described in the second half of ¶5.
(A): Opposite. As described above.
(B): Opposite. As above.
(C): Opposite. As above.
(D): The correct answer
(E): Opposite. As above.
 2)  An ―All...EXCEPT‖ question, so either eliminate or look for an off-scope answer choice. (B) is the only statement not suggested in the passage as a cause for lack of services. Although resentment among "old timers versus persons brought to the community by the boom" (¶5) can occur, there‘s no reason why the lack of support from long-time residents would lead to a shortage of schools, housing, etc.
(A): Opposite. This is the topic of ¶1.
(B): The correct answer
(C): Opposite. An energy project is one of the types of projects the author mentions at the beginning of the passage as causing all the problems listed in the passage.
(D): Opposite. This is discussed throughout ¶2.
(E): Opposite. This is discussed throughout ¶2.
 3)  What does the author think about the traditional systems of taxation as described in ¶2? Predict: The author thinks that it leads to a ―critical problem.‖ (B) is the only choice that reflects that worry about the effects of too few taxes.
(A): Distortion. Though the author thinks that the inefficient taxation is a problem, there‘s no hint of outrage, which is far too extreme.
(B): The correct answer
(C): Out of Scope. There‘s nothing to suggest that the author is at all astonished by the taxation programs.
(D): Opposite. The author thinks that the problem is ―critical,‖ which suggests that
the tone is anything but complacent.
(E): The author does not mock anything in the passage

inesserra · Answer

1. It can be inferred from the passage that which of the following are possible ways in which a boom town is affected by poor planning and under-financing?

I. Unsatisfactory labour conditions → RIGHT. Inferred from paragraph 4, as characteristic of undesirable 
II. Inadequate police protection → RIGHT. Inferred from evidence supported in paragraph 4 of police and fire protection lag
III. Poor community relations → RIGHT: This can be inferred from paragraph 3, of deterioration of quality of life from major economic stimulus.
A. II only
B. I and III only
C. II and III only
 D. I, II, and III
 E. I only

2. The passage suggests that there is often a lack of services associated with boomtowns. The author claims that all of the following are possible causal factors for the lack of services associated with a boomtown EXCEPT:

A. the expected loss of a substantial number of residents after the completion of a project. --> RIGHT. Supported in paragraph 1. "When the construction ends, a substantial reduction in population is virtually guaranteed.”
 B. lack of support from long-time residents.  --> WRONG. It is not from long-time residents. As mentioned in paragraph w, is not subject to local property tax and alternate sources talk about entities (not residents).
C. the location of an energy project just outside the limits of an incorporated city. --> RIGHT. As mentioned in paragraph 1, “a development may be located in the county just outside the limits of an incorporated city. The county will be entitled to tax the property while the city may receive most of the project population and demand for services.” 
D. the time lag between the beginning of project construction and the onset of tax payments for it. --> RIGHT. This is supported by the passage, paragraph 1, the construction project is usually not subject to tax property util it nears complete (may be 5 years after the impact)
E. the mismatch between funds needed and traditional taxing programs --> RIGHT. This can be inferred from overall passage. 
-------------------
3. The tone of the author‘s discussion of traditional taxing programs in regard to boomtowns can best be described as:

For tone questions, discard the ones that are strong emotions and disrespectful with researcher/scientific/person involved in the study. Therefore, we can eliminate A, E right away. C is Out of Scope.
B and D show moderate emotions, but B is more aligned with author's line of reasoning.

A. outraged 
 B. concerned
 C. disbelieving → OOS. This cannot be inferred from the taxation problems described.
D. complacent --> Author is not complacent to taxing programs, moreover is concerned with the importance of the problem.So is not complacent. 
E. mocking

akshayshukla1991 · Answer

What would be the difficulty level for this RC passage?

Sajjad1994 · Answer

Following should be the difficulty level of each question in my opinion.

Question #1: 700
Question #2: 700
Question #3: 550-600

Overall: Hard

Raman109 · Answer

1. It can be inferred from the passage that which of the following are possible ways in which a boomtown is affected by poor planning and under-financing?

I. Unsatisfactory labor conditions - Para 4 discusses, "Undesirable labor conditions characterize the boomtown."
II. Inadequate police protection - Para 5 states that "police and fire protection lag far behind population growth."
III. Poor community relations - Para 5 states, "While the boomtown promotes an ―us against them mentality — the old timers versus persons brought to the community by the boom — the fact remains that all parties suffer."

A. II only
B. I and III only
C. II and III only
D. I, II, and III - Ok
E. I only

VerbalBot · Answer

Hello from the GMAT Club VerbalBot!

Thanks to another GMAT Club member, I have just discovered this valuable topic, yet it had no discussion for over a year. I am now bumping it up - doing my job. I think you may find it valuable (esp those replies with Kudos).

Want to see all other topics I dig out? Follow me (click follow button on profile). You will receive a summary of all topics I bump in your profile area as well as via email.

Five times as many workers may be needed to construct a power plant as

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

GMAT Reading Comprehension (RC) Questions

Five times as many workers may be needed to construct a power plant as

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards