The set of integers Ann and Bob can pick from is:
\{x, x+1, \dots, y\}
• Total number of choices = y - x + 1
• Ann and Bob choose independently from this same set.
• We are asked:
What is the probability that Ann’s number > Bob’s number?
Note: Since choices are random and uniform, we want to compute the probability that Ann’s pick is strictly greater than Bob’s.
⸻
Now let’s examine each statement.
⸻
Statement (1): y - x = 9
This tells us the size of the interval:
y - x + 1 = 10 \text{ integers}
So, Ann and Bob are each choosing uniformly from a set of 10 consecutive integers.
Let’s compute the probability that Ann’s number is greater than Bob’s when both pick uniformly from a set of 10 integers.
Let the values be from 1 to 10 (without loss of generality, since the distribution shape doesn’t change based on x/y, only the size of the set matters here).
There are 10 \times 10 = 100 possible (Ann, Bob) pairs.
Let’s count how many times Ann > Bob:
• If Bob picks 1: Ann can pick 2 through 10 → 9 options
• If Bob picks 2: Ann can pick 3 through 10 → 8 options
• ...
• If Bob picks 9: Ann can pick 10 → 1 option
• If Bob picks 10: Ann can’t pick anything > 10 → 0 options
Total favorable outcomes:
9 + 8 + 7 + 6 + 5 + 4 + 3 + 2 + 1 + 0 = \frac{9 \cdot (9+1)}{2} = 45
So:
\text{Probability} = \frac{45}{100} = 0.45
✅ We can compute the exact probability from this statement alone.
Statement (1) is sufficient.
⸻
Statement (2): y = -20
This tells us the upper bound, but nothing about x, the lower bound.
So we don’t know the number of integers in the interval, or whether Ann has more higher numbers to pick than Bob.
For example:
• If x = -29, then range is from -29 to -20 → 10 numbers → same as before.
• If x = -50, then range is much larger → result changes.
So without knowing x, we cannot determine the probability.
🚫 Statement (2) is not sufficient.