Let the number of integers in this interval (x to y, inclusive & assuming x < y) =
N = (y-x) + 1(For instance, if x=0, y=2, there are 2-0+1=3 integers (0,1,2) between x and y, inclusive.)
Assuming N = (1, 2, ... N) & Ann picks a and Bob picks b:
[i] The total possible pairs would be
N^2, as a can be any N integer and so can b.
[ii] The total possible pairs of a>b,
- For a=1, no possible b -> 0 pair
- For a=2, b=1 -> 1 pair
- For a=3, b=1 or 2 -> 2 pairs...
- ...For a=N, b=1 or 2 or ... N-1 -> (N-1) pairs
The total possible pairs would be = 0+1+2+...+(N-1) = (N-1) * (N/2)
So, the probability= ((N-1)*(N/2)) / N^2 =
(N-1) / 2N(1) p = (N-1) / 2N <=> (y-x) / 2(y-x+1)
Substitute (y-x) = -9 <=> p= -9 / 2 (-9+1) = 9/20 => sufficient
(2) y=-20 does not tell anything about x or the y-x to solve for p => insufficient
Answer: Statement (1) alone is sufficient, but statement (2) alone is not sufficient.