Joseph: Health insurance premiums are growing at an alarming rate.

Question

Joseph:  Health insurance premiums are growing at an alarming rate. This is, in part, because many hospitals and clinics bill for unnecessary diagnostics and tests that inflate the subsequent amount that insurers payout to them. These expenses are then passed on to consumers in the form of increased insurance premiums. Therefore, reducing the number of unnecessary tests performed by health care providers will be effective in controlling growing health insurance premiums.

Ronald:  Oftentimes, the unnecessary diagnostics that you speak of are the result of decisions made by doctors on behalf of their patients. Doctors will often choose the diagnostics that will allow them to bill insurers for more money but may not necessarily benefit the patient in a meaningful way or influence the course of treatment chosen. As a result, in order to succeed in reducing the number of unnecessary tests, we should allow the patients to decide which course of diagnostics they would like to undergo.

In the table below, identify the assumptions upon which each person’s argument depends. Make only one selection in each column, one for Joseph and one for Ronald.

zhanbo · Answer

Joseph and Ronald are generally in agreement over the exorbitant health care cost. (The state of healthcare in US is indeed in turmoil. Insurances and practitioners are driven by avarice. )

For  Joseph , its assumption is:  Tests and diagnostic procedures do not make up an insignificant portion of the bills that are sent to insurers.

From "unnecessary diagnostics and tests are partially responsible for uncontrollable premium growth", we cannot confidently conclude that "reducing the number of unnecessary tests performed by health care providers will be effective in controlling growing health insurance premiums" unless "tests and diagnostic procedures do not make up an insignificant portion of the bills that are sent to insurers."

"Doctors are generally able to determine, with great reliability, which diagnostic procedures and tests would yield the most effective results" is attractive but not essential. Joseph's conclusion does not suggest that doctors will be tasked to determine the unnecessary tests. Maybe insurance can decide, or patients, or AI (artificial intelligence). Negating this statement won't render the conclusion wrong.

For "Ronald", the assumption is " Patients are not just as likely as doctors to choose the most expensive diagnostics and tests. " This is relatively straightforward.

The key to assumption question is to identify the conclusion. For Ronald, the conclusion is "in order to succeed in reducing the number of unnecessary tests, we should allow the patients to decide which course of diagnostics they would like to undergo". If patients are just as likely to choose the most expensive tests, the conclusion thoroughly collapses.

false9 · Answer

Joseph - Insurance companies in other industries, such as auto and home, have been able to reduce costs by reducing the 
 number of unnecessary repairs and replacements on claims for automobiles and homes.

Ronald - Patients are not just as likely as doctors to choose the most expensive diagnostics and tests.

Sr1994 · Answer

Since we have to identify the assumptions, let's find out the conclusions of the arguments. If we look at Joseph's argument, we can see that there is a conclusion marker "Therefore" in the last sentence. Joseph's conclusion: Reducing the number of unnecessary tests performed by health care providers will be effective in controlling growing health insurance premiums. If we look at Ronald's argument, we can see that there is a conclusion marker "As a result" in the last sentence. Ronald's conclusion: we should allow the patients to decide which course of diagnostics they would like to undergo. Option 1: Doctors are generally able to determine, with great reliability, which diagnostic procedures and tests would yield the most effective results. This statement has no effect on Joseph's argument. Doctors are generally capable of determining which test would yield the most effective result. This does not mean that doctors are going to not suggest unnecessary tests. We don't know. (Any Docs reading this, I love you, you are the best

) This statement straight away weakens Ronald's conclusion. If the doctors are able to determine the procedures and tests with great reliability, then why should the patient decide. Option 2: Tests and diagnostic procedures do not make up an insignificant portion of the bills that are sent to insurers. This is an assumption that Joseph has to make. If we negate this statement, the statement would be "Tests and diagnostic procedures do make up an insignificant portion of the bills that are sent to insurers." If they are an insignificant portion of the bills, then even if they are included (or not included), there is no value. So, it is important to assume that tests and diagnostic procedures make up a significant portion of the bills. (do not make up an insignificant portion = make up a significant portion) Option 3: Insurance companies in other industries, such as auto and home, have been able to reduce costs by reducing the number of unnecessary repairs and replacements on claims for automobiles and homes. This statement does not affect both options. What happens in Insurance companies cannot be compared with what happens with doctors. When we are comparing 2 items, we have to make sure that the differences between those 2 items are very very minimal. If the differences are huge, n number of items can go right or wrong. Option 4: Patients are not just as likely as doctors to choose the most expensive diagnostics and tests. This is an assumption that Ronald has to make. If we negate this statement, the statement would be "Patients are just as likely as doctors to choose the most expensive diagnostics and tests." This is weakening Ronald's argument. If the patients are also deciding like doctors, then there is no point in allowing patients to decide the course of diagnostics. So, it is important for Ronald to assume that the patients do not decide as to how doctors decide. Option 5 Health insurance premiums have increased twice as fast in the past five years than they have over an average of the past 25 years. This does not have any effect on both statements. Whatever happened in the past five years is not giving any valid information. Answer Joseph: Option 2 Ronald: Option 4

sshwetima · Answer

1. Doctors are generally able to determine, with great reliability, which diagnostic procedures and tests would yield the most effective results.
 2. Tests and diagnostic procedures do not make up an insignificant portion of the bills that are sent to insurers.  - Joseph's Assumption
3. Insurance companies in other industries, such as auto and home, have been able to reduce costs by reducing the number of unnecessary repairs and replacements on claims for automobiles and homes.
 4. Patients are not just as likely as doctors to choose the most expensive diagnostics and tests.  - Ronald's Assumption
5. Health insurance premiums have increased twice as fast in the past five years than they have over an average of the past 25 years.

Sajjad1994 · Answer

Competition mode on this question is off now!

OA is posted, It is:

Joseph:  Tests and diagnostic procedures do not make up an insignificant portion of the bills that are sent to insurers.
 Ronald:  Patients are not just as likely as doctors to choose the most expensive diagnostics and tests.

Good job is done by both  zhanbo  and  Sr1994

No explanation is provided by  sshwetima

Thank you!

bumpbot · Answer

Hello from the GMAT Club BumpBot!

Thanks to another GMAT Club member, I have just discovered this valuable topic, yet it had no discussion for over a year. I am now bumping it up - doing my job. I think you may find it valuable (esp those replies with Kudos).

Want to see all other topics I dig out? Follow me (click follow button on profile). You will receive a summary of all topics I bump in your profile area as well as via email.

Joseph: Health insurance premiums are growing at an alarming rate.

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

Joseph	Ronald:	Assumptions
		Doctors are generally able to determine, with great reliability, which diagnostic procedures and tests would yield the most effective results.
		Tests and diagnostic procedures do not make up an insignificant portion of the bills that are sent to insurers.
		Insurance companies in other industries, such as auto and home, have been able to reduce costs by reducing the number of unnecessary repairs and replacements on claims for automobiles and homes.
		Patients are not just as likely as doctors to choose the most expensive diagnostics and tests.
		Health insurance premiums have increased twice as fast in the past five years than they have over an average of the past 25 years.

GMAT Two-part Analysis (TPA) Questions

Joseph: Health insurance premiums are growing at an alarming rate.

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards