Bunuel
If a and b are positive integers and ab > 13, is a ≠ b?
(1) Exactly three of the numbers ab - 4, ab - 2, ab + 1 and ab + 3 have the same tens digit
(2) ab is divisible by 8, but not divisible by 16.
Are You Up For the Challenge: 700 Level QuestionsProject DS Butler Data Sufficiency (DS3)
For DS butler Questions Click HereIf a=b, then ab will be a SQUARE. So we have to check whether ab is a perfect square.
(1) Exactly three of the numbers ab - 4, ab - 2, ab + 1 and ab + 3 have the same tens digit
Two cases
a) The smallest 3 have same ten’s digit => ab-4, ab-2 and ab+1
Let us take smallest possible values for ab. ab+1<20, that is ab<19, but ab+3>19, that is ab>16.
Value of ab could be 17 or 18. So Tens digit could be anything but units digit will be 7 or 8. But the units digit of squares (\(0^2,1^2,2^2,3^2,4^2,5^2,6^2,7^2,8^2,9^2\)can be only 0,1,4,9,6,5,6,9,4,1.
So 7 or 8 not possible.
b) The largest 3 have same ten’s digit => ab+3, ab-2 and ab+1
Let us take possible values for ab...... ab-2>19, that is ab>21, but ab-4<20, that is ab<24.
Value of ab could be 22 or 23. Again 2 or 3 cannot be units digit of a perfect square.
Hence ab is NOT a square, and a is not equal to b.
(2) ab is divisible by 8, but not divisible by 16.
So ab=2^3x, but not 2^4x.
If you have power of 3, it cannot be a square.
D