danielpincente wrote:
If n is a positive integer, is n odd?
(1) 3n is odd.
(2) n + 3 is even.
Statement (1) implies that n is odd, for if n were even, any multiple of n would be even. Therefore, the answer must be A or D. Statement (2) also implies that n is odd, since 3 more than any even number is an odd number. Either (1) or (2), taken separately, is sufficient to answer the question.
When I test (1) - I tried 3(4) = 12, which is even, therefore it is not odd / not sufficient.
When I test (2) - I tried 4 + 3 = 7, which is odd, therefore it is not odd / not sufficient.
This contradicts the solution and I am extremely confused.
We know that n is a positive integer
Stmt 1: 3n is odd.
Product of 2 odd numbers is odd, If the product is odd then both the numbers has to be odd.
Hence n is odd.
Statement 1 lone is sufficient.
Stmt 2: n + 3 is even.
o + o = e
e + e = e
Moreover we can consider n+3 = 2k,
So n = 2k - 3
=> n = 2(k-2) + 1
=> n = 2l+1 [If n has to be positive l >0]
Hence n is odd.
Statement 2 alone is also sufficient.
IMO D.