Bunuel
If P and Q are positive integers, then is (P + 2)(Q - 1) an even number?
(1) \(\frac{P}{3Q}\) is an even integer
(2) \(\frac{Q}{\sqrt{P}-3}\) is a positive odd integer
P+2 is even if P is even and odd if P is odd
Q-1 is even if Q is odd and odd if Q is even
Valid combinations are
1. If P is even then all cases are true --- Eq(1)
2. P and Q are both odd --- Eq(2)
(1) \(\frac{P}{3Q}\) is an even integer
=> \(\frac{P}{3Q}\) = Even
=> P = 3Q * Even
=> P is even
As per Eq(1) this makes this validates that (P + 2)(Q - 1) is an even number always.
Option A is sufficient.
(2) \(\frac{Q}{\sqrt{P}-3}\) is a positive odd integer[/quote]
=> Q = Odd * ( \(\sqrt{P}-3\) )
Two Cases are possible
1. Q is even
Then \(\sqrt{P}-3\) has to be even
=> \(\sqrt{P}-3\) = even
=> \(\sqrt{P}\) = even + 3
=> \(\sqrt{P}\) = odd
=> P = \(odd^2\)
=> P = odd
Hence if Q is even, then P is odd --- This makes (P + 2)(Q - 1) an odd number hence we get a negative conclusion
1. Q is odd
Then \(\sqrt{P}-3\) has to be odd
=> \(\sqrt{P}-3\) = odd
=> \(\sqrt{P}\) = odd+ 3
=> \(\sqrt{P}\) = even
=> P = \(even^2\)
=> P = even
Hence if Q is odd, then P is even --- This makes (P + 2)(Q - 1) an even number hence we get a positive conclusion.
As a result, Option B is insufficient as it gives us valid and invalid conclusions.
IMO Option A