Author 
Message 
TAGS:

Hide Tags

Manager
Joined: 02 Jun 2015
Posts: 192
Location: Ghana

If y and z are factors of x^2, is x divisible by y? (1) y is a prim
[#permalink]
Show Tags
24 Aug 2016, 12:24
Question Stats:
53% (02:10) correct 47% (01:39) wrong based on 118 sessions
HideShow timer Statistics
If y and z are factors of x^2, is x divisible by y? (1) y is a prime number. (2) z = y^2
Official Answer and Stats are available only to registered users. Register/ Login.
_________________
Kindly press kudos if you find my post helpful



LBS Thread Master
Joined: 13 Jan 2015
Posts: 111
Location: United Kingdom
Concentration: Other, General Management

Re: If y and z are factors of x^2, is x divisible by y? (1) y is a prim
[#permalink]
Show Tags
24 Aug 2016, 14:01
would be interesting to see the responses to this question



Intern
Joined: 24 Aug 2016
Posts: 29

Re: If y and z are factors of x^2, is x divisible by y? (1) y is a prim
[#permalink]
Show Tags
24 Aug 2016, 22:24
1. SUFFICIENT: Any prime number that is a factor of x^2 must also be a factor of x. If x=y*z, x^2 = (y^2)*(z^2) OR (yz)^2. 2. SUFFICIENT: z = y*y. x is divisible by z, therefor x is divisible by (y*y).
Answer D, both sufficient separately.



Intern
Joined: 27 Dec 2010
Posts: 4

Re: If y and z are factors of x^2, is x divisible by y? (1) y is a prim
[#permalink]
Show Tags
25 Aug 2016, 16:50
Question is asking if \(\frac{x}{y}\) is an integer.
We could pick numbers
S1) \(x=2\). Hence \(x^{2}=4\). Factors of \(x^{2}\) are 1, 2, and 4. Since S1 says that \(y\) is prime, \(y\) could only be 2. Hence \(\frac{x}{y}\)=\(\frac{2}{2}=integer\) YES.
Lets pick another number to see if we can get a NO.
\(x=6.\) Hence \(x^{2}=36\). Factors of \(x^{2}\) are 1,2,3,4,6,9,12,18,and 36. Since S1 says that \(y\) is prime, \(y\) could now be 2 or 3 only. Hence in both the cases \(\frac{x}{y}=integer\). YES.
So we have tried a prime number and a composite number for \(x\) and in both the cases the answer is YES. So Statement 1 is sufficient. Answer Choices could be A or D.
S2) Since we are at A or D, we could verify if statement 2 is definitely true using information from Statement 1, and if proved answer would be D.(Because Statement 1 returned a definite YES and it cannot be contradicted)
Statement 2 says \(z=y^{2}\).
If we look into the first plugin that we did in S1, \(z\) could only be 4 meeting the condition of S1 that \(y\)=Prime=2. There was no other possible value. And it can be seen that \(z =4\) is a factor of \(x^{2}= 4\) meeting the condition in question stem also. So statement 2 is proved using statement 1.
We could try for the second plugin we did in statement 1 also. Here \(z\) could only be 4 or 9 meeting the condition of S1 that\(y=prime=2\) or \(3\). There was no other possible value. And it can be seen that \(z=4\) or \(9\) is a factor of \(x^{2}=36\), meeting the condition in question stem also. So statement 2 is proved using statement 1.
Hence answer is D.



Intern
Joined: 10 Jul 2016
Posts: 12

Re: If y and z are factors of x^2, is x divisible by y? (1) y is a prim
[#permalink]
Show Tags
30 Aug 2016, 03:48
harsha1034 wrote: Question is asking if \(\frac{x}{y}\) is an integer.
We could pick numbers
S1) \(x=2\). Hence \(x^{2}=4\). Factors of \(x^{2}\) are 1, 2, and 4. Since S1 says that \(y\) is prime, \(y\) could only be 2. Hence \(\frac{x}{y}\)=\(\frac{2}{2}=integer\) YES.
Lets pick another number to see if we can get a NO.
\(x=6.\) Hence \(x^{2}=36\). Factors of \(x^{2}\) are 1,2,3,4,6,9,12,18,and 36. Since S1 says that \(y\) is prime, \(y\) could now be 2 or 3 only. Hence in both the cases \(\frac{x}{y}=integer\). YES.
So we have tried a prime number and a composite number for \(x\) and in both the cases the answer is YES. So Statement 1 is sufficient. Answer Choices could be A or D.
S2) Since we are at A or D, we could verify if statement 2 is definitely true using information from Statement 1, and if proved answer would be D.(Because Statement 1 returned a definite YES and it cannot be contradicted)
Statement 2 says \(z=y^{2}\).
If we look into the first plugin that we did in S1, \(z\) could only be 4 meeting the condition of S1 that \(y\)=Prime=2. There was no other possible value. And it can be seen that \(z =4\) is a factor of \(x^{2}= 4\) meeting the condition in question stem also. So statement 2 is proved using statement 1.
We could try for the second plugin we did in statement 1 also. Here \(z\) could only be 4 or 9 meeting the condition of S1 that\(y=prime=2\) or \(3\). There was no other possible value. And it can be seen that \(z=4\) or \(9\) is a factor of \(x^{2}=36\), meeting the condition in question stem also. So statement 2 is proved using statement 1.
Hence answer is D. Hi Harsha What if the value of x is sqt(2)? i.e x is not integer. Would it still be true for statement 1? x=sqt(2)> x^2=2> Factore 1,2 y could be 2 as y is prime and z could be 1 but in this case x wouldn't be divisible by y. hence, statement one is not suffice. Please correct me if I'm missing something.



Intern
Joined: 19 Jan 2017
Posts: 5

Re: If y and z are factors of x^2, is x divisible by y? (1) y is a prim
[#permalink]
Show Tags
05 Aug 2017, 03:40
duahsolo wrote: If y and z are factors of x^2, is x divisible by y? (1) y is a prime number. (2) z = y^2 We've taken the assumption that x is an integer, and in this case both statements are individually sufficient. But the problem is that the question states that x^2 is an integer, not x. What if x is an irrational number? Let's assume \(x = \sqrt{18}.\) (1) y is a prime number. y = 3 is a factor of x^2 = 18 but not a factor of x, because it's not an integer. Insufficient. (2) z = y^2 z = 9 which is a factor of x^2 but again not a factor of x. Insufficient. Bot statements taken together are giving y=3 and z=9 are factors of x^2 but not factors of x. Again insufficient. Answer should be E.



Manager
Joined: 12 Sep 2016
Posts: 75
Location: India
GPA: 3.15

Re: If y and z are factors of x^2, is x divisible by y? (1) y is a prim
[#permalink]
Show Tags
05 Aug 2017, 10:51
you cant assume x is an integer unless mentioned in the question stem. Therefore I believe the answer should be E. Experts, please comment.



Manager
Joined: 02 Nov 2015
Posts: 169

Re: If y and z are factors of x^2, is x divisible by y? (1) y is a prim
[#permalink]
Show Tags
05 Aug 2017, 11:14
goodie wrote: duahsolo wrote: If y and z are factors of x^2, is x divisible by y? (1) y is a prime number. (2) z = y^2 We've taken the assumption that x is an integer, and in this case both statements are individually sufficient. But the problem is that the question states that x^2 is an integer, not x. What if x is an irrational number? Let's assume \(x = \sqrt{18}.\) (1) y is a prime number. y = 3 is a factor of x^2 = 18 but not a factor of x, because it's not an integer. Insufficient. (2) z = y^2 z = 9 which is a factor of x^2 but again not a factor of x. Insufficient. Bot statements taken together are giving y=3 and z=9 are factors of x^2 but not factors of x. Again insufficient. Answer should be E. Agreed totally. I also believe the same. Expert's responses will further clarify if I am really missing something. Sent from my Lenovo TAB S850LC using GMAT Club Forum mobile app



GMAT Tutor
Joined: 24 Jun 2008
Posts: 1345

If y and z are factors of x^2, is x divisible by y? (1) y is a prim
[#permalink]
Show Tags
05 Aug 2017, 11:31
The question is carelessly worded, and if this were a real GMAT question, it would always tell you that x is a positive integer. As the question is written, it allows the possibility that x is some square root of an integer, say √2 or √3. But the concept of "divisibility" that is tested on the GMAT only makes sense when you're discussing integers. It's only in math far beyond GMATlevel that you'd learn what a question like "is √2 divisible by 2?" even means. Using GMAT concepts only, the question is like asking "is √2 orange?" The GMAT can't ask you questions that don't make sense, so the GMAT will always rule out the possibility that something is a noninteger in a divisibility problem. If the question states that x is a positive integer, then it's a more realistic question, and the answer is D.
_________________
GMAT Tutor in Toronto
If you are looking for online GMAT math tutoring, or if you are interested in buying my advanced Quant books and problem sets, please contact me at ianstewartgmat at gmail.com



Senior Manager
Joined: 06 Jul 2016
Posts: 415
Location: Singapore
Concentration: Strategy, Finance

Re: If y and z are factors of x^2, is x divisible by y? (1) y is a prim
[#permalink]
Show Tags
05 Aug 2017, 11:49
I agree as well. It does not mention that x is an integer so x can very well be a noninteger. Sent from my iPhone using GMAT Club Forum
_________________
Put in the work, and that dream score is yours!




Re: If y and z are factors of x^2, is x divisible by y? (1) y is a prim &nbs
[#permalink]
05 Aug 2017, 11:49






