In a 200 member association consisting of men and women, exactly 20%

Question

In a 200 member association consisting of men and women, exactly 20% of men and exactly 25 % women are homeowners. What is the least number of members who are homeowners?

A. 49
B. 47
C. 45
D. 43
E. 41

Bunuel · Accepted Answer

Let the # of women be  w , then # of men will be  200-w . We want to minimize  0.25w+0.2(200-w)  -->  0.25w+0.2(200-w)=0.05w+40=\frac{w}{20}+40 , so we should minimize  w , but also we should make sure that  \frac{w}{20}+40  remains an integer (as it represent # of people). Min value of  w  for which w/20 is an integer is for  w=20  -->  \frac{w}{20}+40=1+40=41 .

Answer: E.

Or: as there are bigger percentage of homeowner women then we should minimize # of women, but we should ensure that  \frac{1}{4}*w  and  \frac{1}{5}*(200-w)  are integers. So  w  should be min multiple of 4 for which  200-w  is a multiple of 5 (basically w should be min positive multiple of 20), which turns out to be for  w=20 .

Hope it's clear.

SVaidyaraman · Answer

1. The percentage of women who are homemakers is higher than the percentage of men who are homemakers. So the least number of homemakers would be, when the number of women is the lowest possible
2. The number of women should be a multiple of 4 and the number of men should be a multiple of 5
3. Given our objective in (1) and the constraint in (2), the minimum number of women is 20 and the corresponding number of men is 180
4. So 25% of 20 is 5 and 20% of 180 is 36. The least number of homemakers is 5+36= 41.

Therefore the answer is choice E.

nades09 · Answer

Great! Thanks for the quick reply. Did not think it would be so straightforward

You rock!
NAD

walkerme13 · Answer

awesome explanation. thanks!

tfincham86 · Answer

Great explanation.

prashantbacchewar · Answer

Nice Question and Great explaination by Bunuel .. Thanks a lot

superpus07 · Answer

Could you explain this one;  =0.05w+40=\frac{w}{20}+40  ? How did you get  \frac{w}{20}  ?

Bunuel · Answer

0.05w=\frac{5}{100}*w=\frac{1}{20}*w=\frac{w}{20} .

Hope it's clear.

prasannajeet · Answer

Hi Bunuel

I have reached to the answer but the solution is little weird after I saw yours.
Please guide me whether we can go by this
 
Question
In a 200 member association consisting of men and women, exactly 20% of men and exactly 25 % women are homeowners. What is the least number of members who are homeowners?

A. 49
B. 47
C. 45
D. 43
E. 41

Solution simple

Out of 200 20% are male i.e 40 and 25% are female i.e 50 , so total homeowner is 90.

Now min number homeowner is 40 and max is 90 so question ask us to find least and 41 has least value among all option.

So ans is 41.

Rgds
Prasannajeet

Bunuel · Answer

We are told that exactly  20% of men  and exactly  25 % women  are homeowners, not that 20% of 200 are males (homeowners)...

If there are 40 males and 50 females who are the remaining 200-(90)=110 people?

sabxu1 · Answer

I have a question about this method
i notice if i put w = 200 -m
i get
-m/20 + 50

then it would be completely different and il get min/max wrong way around?

chetan2u · Answer

Hi,
no you will still get the correct answer...
 Two cases--
1) we maximize m, as the % of m is lower
2) If the answer is in w, we minimize w..

here you have taken your answer in m and you get it as  50 - \frac{m}{20} ..
 so you have to maximize m..
m has to be a multiple of 20 to get an integer value for m/20..
m cannot be 200, as there are some w...

Next can be 200-20=180..
substitue m as 180, So number = 50 - \frac{180}{20} = 50 - 9 = 41

sabxu1 · Answer

Hi,
no you will still get the correct answer...
 Two cases--
1) we maximize m, as the % of m is lower
2) If the answer is in w, we minimize w..

here you have taken your answer in m and you get it as  50 - \frac{m}{20} ..
 so you have to maximize m..
m has to be a multiple of 20 to get an integer value for m/20..
m cannot be 200, as there are some w...

Next can be 200-20=180..
substitue m as 180, So number = 50 - \frac{180}{20} = 50 - 9 = 41

Thanks for replying to me I apologise for asking another question about it. WHy is it maximum m as % is lower? Sorry I'm kind of confused now is there a reason. I'm trying to understand this concept.

chetan2u · Answer

Thanks for replying to me I apologise for asking another question about it. WHy is it maximum m as % is lower? Sorry I'm kind of confused now is there a reason. I'm trying to understand this concept.

Hi,
 the Q gives us few details which cannot be changed.. 
1) total = m + w= 200
2) exactly 20% of men are homeowners =  \frac{20}{100}* m = \frac{m}{5} 
3) exactly 25 % women are homeowners =  \frac{25}{100}* w = \frac{w}{4} 
4) homeowners = H = \frac{m}{5}+\frac{w}{4}

Q is  " What is the least number of members who are homeowners?" or "least H"

Now H depends on m and w, as these two numbers can be played around with, that is no fixed value is given..
Rest there is nothing we can do with 200 , 20% and 25%...

If you look at the Equation - H = \frac{m}{5}+\frac{w}{4} 
 w/4 which means every 4th women is home owners and m/5 means every 5th men is a homeowner...
so for H to be least, we have to maximize people who are least likely to possess HOME and here it is 'm', so we try to maximize 'm'..

JeffTargetTestPrep · Answer

Letting m = the number of men in the association and w = the number of women in the association, we know that:

m + w = 200

m = 200 - w

Thus:

0.2(200 - w) + 0.25w = homeowners

40 - 0.2w + 0.25w = homeowners

40 + 0.05w = homeowners

40 + w/20 = homeowners

We see that w must be a multiple of 20 and since we want the least number of homeowners, w = 20. So the least number of homeowners is 40 + 20/20 = 40 + 1 = 41.

Answer: E

GMATGuruNY · Answer

We can PLUG IN THE ANSWERS, which represent the least number of homeowners.
Since the correct answer must be the least possible option, start with the smallest answer choice.
To test the answers, use ALLIGATION.

E: 41, implying that the percentage who are homeowners  = \frac{41}{200} = \frac{20.5}{100} = 20.5 %

Step 1: Plot the 3 percentages on a number line, with the percentages for M and W on the ends and the percentage for the mixture in the middle. 
M 20------------20.5------------25 W

Step 2: Calculate the distances between the values on the number line. 
M 20---- 0.5 ----20.5---- 4.5 ----25 W

Step 3: Determine the ratio of men to women. 
The ratio of M to W is equal to the RECIPROCAL of the distances in red.
 \frac{M}{W} = \frac{4.5}{0.5} = \frac{9}{1} = \frac{90}{10} =    \frac{180}{20}

The ratio in green indicates that the percentage of homeowners will be 20.5% -- yielding a total of 41 homeowners -- if M=180 and W=20, for a total of 200 people.

E

BrentGMATPrepNow · Answer

In order to minimize the number of homeowners, we must MAXIMIZE the number of men in the group, since the proportion of male homeowners (20%) is less than the proportion of female homeowners (25%)
So, let's see what happens if there are 199 men and 1 woman. 
Well, if 20% (aka 1/ 5 ) of the men are homeowners, then the number of male homeowners = 20% of 199 = 39.8. This makes no sense, since we can't have 39.8 men. 
Likewise, if 25% (aka 1/ 4 ) of the women are homeowners, then the number of female homeowners = 25% of 1 = 0.25. This makes no sense either.

Let's now focus on the women. We know that, in order to have an INTEGER number of female homeowners, the number of females must be divisible by  4 . 
Likewise, in order to have an INTEGER number of male homeowners, the number of females must be divisible by  5 .

So, the first pair of values that meet the above conditions are: 180 men and 20 women. 
20% of 180 = 36, so there are 36 male homeowners. 
25% of 20 = 5, so there are 5 female homeowners. 
MINIMUM number of homeowners = 36 + 5 = 41

Answer: E

Cheers,
Brent

fskilnik · Answer

Excellent opportunity for  the grid  (aka double-matrix)!

Important: we have chosen the blue expression wisely and the others follow from it. (Justify all of them!)

https://i.ibb.co/m5vT1CG/06-Dec18-7k.gif

? = {\left( {50 - M} \right)_{\min }}

\left( {50 - M} \right)\,\,{\mathop{\rm int}} \,\,\,\, \Rightarrow \,\,\,\,\,M\,\,{\mathop{\rm int}}

\left( {10 - M} \right) \ge 1\,\,{\mathop{\rm int}} \,\,\,\, \Rightarrow \,\,\,M \le 9\,\,{\mathop{\rm int}}

? = {\left( {50 - M} \right)_{\min }}\,\,\, = 41\,\,\,\,\left( {M = 9} \right)

This solution follows the notations and rationale taught in the GMATH method.

Regards, 
Fabio.

EMPOWERgmatRichC · Answer

Hi All,

We're told that in a 200 member association consisting of men and women, exactly 20% of men and exactly 25 % women are homeowners. We're asked for the LEAST number of members who are homeowners. This question is built around a couple of Number Properties - and to MINIMIZE the number of people who are homeowners, we have to MAXIMIZE the number of men in the group (since a smaller percentage of men are homeowners).

To start, since 20% of men are homeowners, we know that the number of men MUST be a multiple of 5. In that same way, since 25% of women are homeowners, we know that the number of women MUST be a multiple of 4. Thus, we need to add the largest possible multiple of 5 to a multiple of 4 and get a total of 200, while accounting for the fact that there MUST be some men and some women. Logically, we can 'work down' from 200 to find those numbers.

IF there were... 
4 women, then there'd be 196 men (not valid; number of men needs to be a multiple of 5) 
8 women, then there'd be 192 men (not valid; number of men needs to be a multiple of 5) 
Etc.

With a little more work, you'll find that 20 women and 180 men is situation that is needed. From there the LEAST possible number of homeowners would be... 
(.25)(20) + (.2)(180) = 
5 + 36 = 
41 homeowners

Final Answer:  E

GMAT assassins aren't born, they're made, 
Rich

In a 200 member association consisting of men and women, exactly 20%

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

GMAT Problem Solving (PS) Questions

In a 200 member association consisting of men and women, exactly 20%

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards