In the United States, trade unions encountered far more intense opposi

Question

In the United States, trade unions encountered far more intense opposition  against their struggle for social legitimacy than  the organized labor movements of most other democratic nations.

(A) against their struggle for social legitimacy than
(B) in their struggle for social legitimacy than did
(C) against their struggle for social legitimacy as
(D) in their struggle for social legitimacy as did
(E) when they struggled for social legitimacy than has

Project SC Butler: Day 32: Sentence Correction (SC1) 
 For SC butler Questions  Click Here

EncounterGMAT · Accepted Answer

A: “against” is redundant with “opposition”.
 B:  “did” correctly replaces “encountered”.  Answer! 
C: Same as A
D: “more…as” is not idiomatic that is usage of wrong modifier.
E: “encountered far more than has” is incorrect as “has” can’t replace “encountered” plus it's wordy and awkward.

parijit · Answer

(A) against their struggle for social legitimacy than- comparing struggle with union 
(B) in their struggle for social legitimacy than did- correct answer 
(C) against their struggle for social legitimacy as- as is used when two things happening at the same time or to give reason.This is not correct use of as. 
(D) in their struggle for social legitimacy as did- than has to be added after more 
(E) when they struggled for social legitimacy than has - wrong use of when

lary301254M7 · Answer

In the United States, trade unions  encountered  far  more  intense opposition against their struggle for social legitimacy than the organized labor movements of most other democratic nations.

(A) against their struggle for social legitimacy  than 
(B) in their struggle for social legitimacy than  did 
(C) against their struggle for social legitimacy  as 
(D) in their struggle for social legitimacy  as   did 
(E) when they struggled for social legitimacy  than   has

"far more" requires the word "than" to complete the comparison We can eliminate (C) and (D)

trade unions "encountered" more than the organized labor movements ... "encountered" 
The word that can substitute for "encountered" is "did" or an omitted "encountered. (E) is out, also "has" does not pair with "movement s "

(A) and (B) are left. I think (B) is better when I rephrase this sentence.
In their struggle for social legitimacy, trade unions encountered far more intense opposition than did the organized labor movements of most other democratic nations.

Ans: (B)

aragonn · Answer

Official Explanation: 
In A and C, against is awkward and redundant because the idea of the resistance met by the trade unions is already established by the phrase encountered ... opposition. Additionally, the failure in A and C to include did makes the I comparisons in those choices incomplete, allowing the misreading that trade unions in the United States encountered the organized labor movements of other nations. Choices C and D both incorrectly use more ... as to make a comparison; the idiomatic form of this expression is "more x than y." Choice B is best, both idiomatic and unambiguous. Choice E is awkward, and the singular verb has does not agree with the plural subject of the clause, labor movements.

Mike03 · Answer

POE:

"Against" becomes redundant when used with the word - "opposition". Also, since we are doing the comparison, then "than" is preferred.

eabhgoy · Answer

Based on meaning:
Trade unions are not struggling against social legitimacy.
They are struggling for social legitimacy.
Based on the above A & C can be eliminated.

Choice E is wordy and awkward. Eliminated.

Now we are left with B & D.
Than did vs as did: than did correctly compares the trade unions of one country to another.

Hence B is the correct answer.

Posted from my mobile device

RohitSaluja · Answer

Hi  KarishmaB   AndrewN  hope you are doing well! Although I selected the correct answer choice, I want to make sure that my reasoning3 was correct. It will be immensely helpful if you can review my analysis and provide your comments on it.

(A) against their struggle for social legitimacy than   The opposition that the trade unions encountered was not against their struggle but in their struggle, and also opposition and against are redundant  
(B) in their struggle for social legitimacy than did   This is the correct answer choice, however, I want to understand that can we literally remove did with encountered or did just acts as a reference for the verb ?  
(C) against their struggle for social legitimacy as   We need more... than not more... as  
(D) in their struggle for social legitimacy as did   Same as C  
(E) when they struggled for social legitimacy than has   When is not correct, also has is incorrect

Your response will be much appreciated.

AndrewN · Answer

Hello,  RohitSaluja . Your analysis looks sound. In answer choice (B),  did  is acting as a substitute verb for the earlier  encountered , since the comparison is between the degree of opposition  faced  by one group,  trade unions  in the United States, and another,  the organized labor movements of most other democratic nations . Such usage is quite common on the GMAT™. In fact, I just wrote  a post  the other day on the matter and linked to several official questions in which some form of  to do  appears in this manner. It is worth checking out to see how GMAC™ likes to test this type of comparison.

Well done on your analysis. Thank you for thinking to ask for my input.

- Andrew

KarishmaB · Answer

'did' substitutes 'encountered'

Correct usages:

X is more A than Y. (comparing X with Y in a particular characteristic: X is bigger than Y. X is more intelligent than Y. etc)

X encountered more A than did Y. (comparing the amount of A encountered by the two. X encountered more opposition than did Y. We need a substitute verb here with Y. We are not comparing X with Y. We are comparing the amount of A encountered by each.)
We can also write this as "X encountered more A than Y encountered" but we rarely repeat the verb since it sounds clumsy. We use just the substitute 'did' for it.

A of X is greater than that of Y. (comparing the A's of both)
The neck of X is longer than that of Y (comparing the necks of both)

EducationAisle · Answer

Hi Rohit,  AndrewN  and  KarishmaB  have already answered your query.

I would like to add that while in this question,  did  is in the past tense and so is "encountered",  do/did/does  can in fact substitute for almost any action verb in any tense.

For example, following is correct:

Michael has never run as fast as his father did.

Notice that "did" is substituting for the simple past "ran", even though the first half of the sentence is in present perfect ("has run").

p.s. Our book    EducationAisle Sentence Correction Nirvana    discusses  this aspect of "to do" verbs . Have attached the corresponding section of the book, for your reference.

gmatimothy · Answer

VerbalBot · Answer

Automated notice from GMAT Club VerbalBot: 

A member just gave Kudos to this thread, showing it’s still useful. I’ve bumped it to the top so more people can benefit. Feel free to add your own questions or solutions.

 This post was generated automatically.

In the United States, trade unions encountered far more intense opposi

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

GMAT Sentence Correction (SC - EA only) Questions

In the United States, trade unions encountered far more intense opposi

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards