catcun
egmat please explain why D is incorrect!
catcun Look at what the argument actually says:
"IF these physicists are right, in our universe there are no parallel lines"The argument treats the physicists being right as a conditional - it's exploring what follows IF they're correct.
Now look at what
(D) says:
"The universe IS correctly described by this system IF prominent physicists maintain that it is"(D) reverses the relationship. It makes the physicists' opinion the REASON the system is correct (physicists say so \(\rightarrow\) therefore true).
Why D Isn't Necessary:The argument never needs the physicists' views to be what MAKES the system correct. The system could be correct for completely independent reasons - empirical evidence, mathematical proofs, etc. The argument just says "IF they happen to be right, here's the conclusion."
The argument already conditionalizes on them being right ("if these physicists are right") - it doesn't need an assumption about WHY or HOW their views make it correct.
What IS Needed:The gap in the argument: The physicists say this system describes our universe \(\rightarrow\) Therefore no parallel lines in our universe
Missing link: That specific non-Euclidean system has no parallel lines
(Answer A)
I'd recommend you practice some
free assumption questions here. You should set up a guided quiz by selecting "assumption" in CR- that will help you attempt these questions and then see the explanations right after. These explanations will help you understand how to build clear logical chains from the argument given and have a structured process to eliminate the wrong alternatives.