machichi
Hmmmm, so many ways to think about this!
I'm interested in hearing more what your pros and cons are for each school. Perhaps we could help by eliminating some of your cons at Ross and/or Yale so that you felt more confident about one or the other?
I'm really familiar with Yale's education focus, but not as much on its energy and sustainability stuff. I am obsessed with Yale, and much of it has to do with the education club and
impact culture at the school. Students, professors, alums, etc. are really supportive of social impact goals.
The doubts that I'm having are about these schools' resources with regard to technology. I'd say you're better off at Haas, but I guess it's too late for that. That said, there's an amazing entrepreneur club at Yale that might be in line with your goals.
The thing about Ross is that since it's bigger it may have more general resources to support your goals. However, fewer of these resources may end up assigned to your area of interest. I think your best bet is to ask the schools to connect you with current students and alumni in your target industry. They were instrumental in helping me make my final decision. It's creepy how aligned the alums' trajectories were with my goals.
One final thing--if you are interested in doing international development, you should look at Yale's international experiences and Advanced Network for Global Management. Ted Snyder is super invested in globalizing the SOM coursework and reach. It's pretty inspiring and it might be worth learning more about in your case.
Good luck!
Hi Machichi,
Thanks for your input. Also, thanks for the reassuring comment you left for me on beatthegmat back in February when I was stressing about not being invited for an interview. Turns out, they did indeed use my interview from last year.
Here are my pros and cons:
Michigan+ Big alumni base with a strong rep.
+ Erb Institute, great resources for sustainability
+ Generally seems to have a lot of resources and courses that align with my interests
+ I have a friend in hist 1st year at Ross. He can help get me onto the Social Venture Fund, show me the ropes, and ... be a friend
+ Action Learning / Multidisciplinary Action Project seems like a great way to supplement classroom learning with real-world experience
+ I hear Ann Arbor is great
- I think Michigan's brand is less strong among people not in-the-know about business schools. Especially abroad.
- Impression (could be wrong) that Michigan's network and job placement is heavily focused on the Midwest
- While a big alumni base is good, I prefer small classes/programs. Not sure Ross would offer as intimate of an MBA experience as I'd ideally want.
- I get the impression that there's a lot of social attention on the Michigan football program. I'm not really into spending my Saturdays drinking and getting hyped up for a football game.
- This might seem like a small detail, but I'm finding the web portal for admitted students to be really confusing and difficult to use. It's hard enough making plans and decisions from overseas without having to struggle for basic information on their website. Not super material to the MBA program, but I'm wondering why they can't do better.
Yale+ Great general brand name, especially for working overseas
+ Small, intimate program
+ Love the do-good focus
+ East coast location is closer to home for me, and I'm much more likely to want to work on the coast than in the Midwest
- Less established program --> less established alumni network
You can probably tell from my +/- list that I'm leaning toward Yale. They got me on the MBA train in the first place (applied to SOM and only SOM last year in R3, got wait-listed) and I think I've had sort of a general school crush on Yale for a really long time. Before I make a final decision, I just want to make sure I've thought it through, done my diligence, etc. Since I can't attend any of the admitted student events, input from the forum community can offer at least some additional insights.
I am in touch with current students in both programs, and will be speaking with them + recent alumni in the coming weeks.
Thanks, and maybe see you in the fall!