On a recent trip to the Mediterranean, I made the acquaintance of a young man who warned me against trusting Cretans. “Everything they say is a lie,” he told me, “and I should know because I come from Crete myself.” I thanked the fellow for his advice but told him in light of what he had said I had no intention of believing it.
Which of the following is most nearly analogous to the warning issued by the young man?
(A) An admission by a witness under cross-examination that he has lied.
(B) A sign put up by the Chamber of Commerce of a large city alerting visitors to the dangers of pickpockets.
(C) The command of a military leader to his marching troops to do an about face.
(D) A sentence written in chalk on a blackboard that says, “This sentence is false.”
(E) The advice of a veteran worker to a newly hired person: “You don’t actually have to work hard so long as you look like you’re working hard.”