Hi All,
First of all, I would like thank all of you for appreciating this article and showering Kudos. Such overwhelming responses keep us motivated to write more articles.
Here is the detailed explanation for both the exercise questions.
EXERCISE QUESTION: 1
Since digital recording offers essentially perfect reproduction - on compact discs, digital audiotapes, or digital videodiscs - audiophiles can accumulate
music, transferring them from one format to another, copying it, and digitally altering it with little effort and not damaging the sound quality. (GMAT Prep)
A. music, transferring them from one format to another, copying it, and digitally altering it with little effort and not damaging
B. music, transferring it from one format to another, copying it, and digitally altering it with little effort and no damage to
C. music, transfer it from one format to another, copy it, and digitally alter it with little effort and no damage to
D. music and transfer it from one format to another, copy it, and then digitally altering it with little effort and not damaging
E. music and transfer it from one format to another, copying it, and digitally alter it with little effort and no damage to
MEANING ANAYSIS: Let us first understand the meaning of the sentence. This step is extremely necessary to understand what the LOGICAL intended meaning of the sentence is.
The sentence says that because digital recording offers perfect reproduction, audiophiles can collect music by doing three things:
a. transferring them from one format to another,
b. copying it, and
c. digitally altering it with little effort and not damaging the sound quality.
ERROR ANALYSIS: • There is a list of three things through which audiophiles can accumulate music. All three are the part of the process that completes the process of accumulation of music in audiophiles. All the entities are correctly written in verb-ing modifier form, meaning they all provide information as to how the music is accumulated in audiophiles.
• There is another list in the third entity of the first list – altering it with:
a. little effort, and
b. not damaging the sound quality.
The first entity of this sub-list is a noun phrase made up of adjective + noun. The second entity is also a noun phrase. However, the grammatical structure of this entity is different from the other. Here we have an adverb (not) followed by a gerund – a noun that denotes action. This entity can very well be written in the form of the first entity as “no damage”.
• Plural pronoun “them” does not agree in number with its singular antecedent “music”.
PoE: A. music, transferring them from one format to another, copying it, and digitally altering it with little effort and not damaging:
Incorrect for the reasons mentioned above.
B. music, transferring it from one format to another, copying it, and digitally altering it with little effort and no damage to:
Correct. This choice not only maintains the grammatical parallelism of both the main list and the sub list but also maintains the logical parallelism, conveying the logical meaning.
C. music, transfer it from one format to another, copy it, and digitally alter it with little effort and no damage to:
Incorrect. Grammatically, this choice is correct. The list per this choice is - audiophiles can:
a. accumulate music,
b. transfer it…
c. copy it, and
d. alter it…
Grammatically, all the entities are parallel here, but now they convey a very different meaning. The last three entities in the list are no more the three steps of accumulating music in audiophiles. All these entities are independent entities now. This choice clearly stands INCORRECT despite being grammatically parallel because it violates the LOGICAL intended meaning of the sentence.
D. music and transfer it from one format to another, copy it, and then digitally altering it with little effort and not damaging:
Incorrect. 1. Use of “and” after music is incorrect.
2. “not damaging” is not parallel to “little effort”.
E. music and transfer it from one format to another, copying it, and digitally alter it with little effort and no damage to:
Incorrect. Use of “and” after music is incorrect as it creates an unintended list which is not even parallel.
EXERCISE QUESTION: 2
As the etched lines on computer memory chips have become thinner and the chips’ circuits more complex, both the power of the chips and the electronic devices they drive have vastly increased. (GMAT Prep)
A. the chips’ circuits more complex, both the power of the chips and the electronic devices they drive have
B. the chips’ circuits more complex, the power of both the chips and the electronic devices they drive has
C. the chips’ circuits are more complex, both the power of the chips and the electronic devices they drive has
D. their circuits are more complex, the power of both the chips and the electronic devices they drive have
E. their circuits more complex, both the power of the chips and the electronic devices they drive have
MEANING ANAYSIS: • The etched lines on computer memory chips have become thinner, and the chips’ circuits have become more complex. These have resulted into two things:
1. the power of the chips have increased, and
2. the electronic devices they derive have increased.
ERROR ANALYSIS: • From the meaning analysis, we can logically say that the two changes in the memory chips have resulted in increase in the power of the chips. But it is not logical to say that these changes have led to increase in the devices they drive. Increase in the number of devices these chips drive depend on many other factors. Hence, despite being GRAMMATICALLY correct, this choice stands LOGICALLY incorrect.
PoE:A. the chips’ circuits more complex, both the power of the chips and the electronic devices they drive have:
Incorrect for the reason stated above.
B. the chips’ circuits more complex, the power of both the chips and the electronic devices they drive has:
Correct. This choice is grammatically as well as logically correct. The changes in the memory chips have resulted in increase in power of the chips as well as the devices they drive.
C. the chips’ circuits are more complex, both the power of the chips and the electronic devices they drive has:
Incorrect. 1. Use of “are” is incorrect. The effect of the changes can still be felt in the present.
2. Repeats the logical parallelism error as in choice A.
3. Singular “has” does not agree in number with its plural subject.
D. their circuits are more complex, the power of both the chips and the electronic devices they drive have:
Incorrect. 1. Same verb tense error as in choice C.
2. Plural verb “have” does not agree in number with its singular subject “the power”.
E. their circuits more complex, both the power of the chips and the electronic devices they drive have:
Incorrect. Same logical parallelism error as in choice A.
Thanks.
I'm having some confusion over the 2nd qs. answer...!! Need your help for clarification guys...
As you've mentioned that 'B' is the correct answer and Use of “are” is incorrect (and The effect of the changes can still be felt in the present.), then the the second clause (or if we remove the part "the etched lines on computer memory chips have become thinner" from the clause starting with 'As') following 'and' in the 1st part of the sentence (i.e. the part starting with 'As') is as follows:
"As the chips’ circuits more complex"...It doesn't contain any conjugated verb(rather, any verb) so it's basically a fragment.How it can be a fragment NOT a clause..? Would you please help me understand it..?
Highly appreciate your reply on this.
Nov 20
Nov 22
Nov 25
13 Dec 2012, 09:32
