I am admitted to both NYU Stern and Dartmouth Tuck and have to make a decision ahead of NYU Stern's April 22nd deposit deadline.
A little background on myself: I have 4 years of Federal strategy consulting experience at a top "tier 2" consulting firm and am looking to switch over to commercial-- hopefully at a similar or stronger firm (read: M/B/B) in a NY/CT/NJ office. I currently live with my longtime girlfriend in Manhattan so we'd be moving down the street for NYU. Going to Tuck would necessitate a long-distance relationship for the ~21 months as she finishes grad school and likely accepts a job at a BB bank in the city.
Tuck is transparent with their consulting placement statistics and the CDO publishes updates. However, NYU Stern doesn't publish their placement statistics beyond giving asterisks to companies that hire 3 or more students (M/B/B all have asterisks), so it's hard to gauge how strong they are for consulting. GMAT Club has been an awesome resource throughout the business school application process so I am hoping to get some constructive feedback to help me make this decision (read: not WSO

).
Additionally, I am happy to provide more background about myself if it'll help guide responses. Thanks!