Aaron:
I would shoot for Haas and Stanford. I would make sure to visit them as well. There are several reasons for this, but most of all it is the nature of the application process that ultimately has me recommending these schools.
So let's be real here:
With Haas and GSB, you can visit both schools and kill two birds with one stone.
Both schools are culturally similar. In fact, the essays are similar - albeit the word count makes a direct cut and paste difficult (for the record I never advise cut and paste - I'm just sayin'). Both schools love the touchy-feely and your mission trips/commitment to building up others will play well. Example - GSB starts their essays with "what matters most?" and Haas with "What brings you your greatest joy?" Trust me man, the questions are similar - but the word counts will make your mind play tricks on you like the Ghetto Boys.
Both schools will have access to the same consulting recruiters - for the most part. But we all know that no top company hires all its people from the same school. On that note, I would tap the LDS network to see who can help you out once you graduate.
It is getting late in the application process and you need to hedge. GSB is the world's hardest school to get into and Haas always has availability late in the application season.
With Wharton and Tuck - you are getting 2 schools that are at differing ends of the spectrum. Tuck is a place more similar to Haas. They want to know that you love them, not just like them. You have to visit Tuck and you have to interview on campus. Also, I hope you have signed up for their interview already if you plan to apply ....
Wharton keeps banging the innovation drum. Have you done this as an auditor? The nature of the title tells me you are more likely to catch mistakes than to make them ... as an innovator. Perhaps I am wrong, but this is yet another reason to hedge with GSB and Haas.
I hope this helps. I have a lot of respect for guys like you who take time out of their lives to help others - especially on a 2 year mission trip. It's not an easy thing to do ...
Respectfully,
Paul Lanzillotti
big4mba
Paul,
I very much appreciate such a thoughtful response and advice. As far as career goals, they are to work for one of the top management consulting firms and then branch out into entrepreneurial ventures. That is where my true passion lies but I am interested in gaining the learning available in management consulting. In addition, I am passionate about using the MBA and management skills to be a leader in charitable organizations.
I am currently trying to narrow down a list of four schools to two. The four are Stanford, Wharton, Berkeley and Tuck. I feel like I would be ecstatic to attend any of these schools but want to make sure I am choosing schools that meet my interests and goals as well as having a realistic shot to get in. Any insight you could give on this would be very greatly appreciated.
Aaron