Last visit was: 13 Dec 2024, 16:54 It is currently 13 Dec 2024, 16:54
Close
GMAT Club Daily Prep
Thank you for using the timer - this advanced tool can estimate your performance and suggest more practice questions. We have subscribed you to Daily Prep Questions via email.

Customized
for You

we will pick new questions that match your level based on your Timer History

Track
Your Progress

every week, we’ll send you an estimated GMAT score based on your performance

Practice
Pays

we will pick new questions that match your level based on your Timer History
Not interested in getting valuable practice questions and articles delivered to your email? No problem, unsubscribe here.
Close
Request Expert Reply
Confirm Cancel
avatar
Othasollala
avatar
Current Student
Joined: 30 Jan 2019
Last visit: 15 Mar 2022
Posts: 11
Own Kudos:
Given Kudos: 19
Location: India
GMAT 1: 740 Q50 V41
Products:
GMAT 1: 740 Q50 V41
Posts: 11
Kudos: 7
Kudos
Add Kudos
Bookmarks
Bookmark this Post
User avatar
MBADecoder
Joined: 16 Jan 2012
Last visit: 13 Dec 2024
Posts: 2,769
Own Kudos:
661
 []
Given Kudos: 192
Expert reply
Posts: 2,769
Kudos: 661
 []
1
Kudos
Add Kudos
Bookmarks
Bookmark this Post
User avatar
SiaAdmissions
User avatar
Sia Admissions Representative
Joined: 04 Jan 2018
Last visit: 12 Dec 2022
Posts: 681
Own Kudos:
Given Kudos: 67
Affiliations: NYU, Yale
Location: United States (NY)
Expert reply
Posts: 681
Kudos: 145
Kudos
Add Kudos
Bookmarks
Bookmark this Post
User avatar
MG4MBACrystalBall
Joined: 29 Aug 2010
Last visit: 11 Dec 2024
Posts: 926
Own Kudos:
152
 []
Given Kudos: 1
Posts: 926
Kudos: 152
 []
1
Kudos
Add Kudos
Bookmarks
Bookmark this Post
Echoing a bit and a few more perspectives for you Othasollala:

  1. The academic arc, as noted already, looks to have had a pretty great trajectory. If it was undiagnosed, it might always be a bit of suspect, but given that you have 'proof' of stellar record later, would lend credibility to your claims. That being said, undergrad GPA will still come into play and schools would have to look at it as an exception - it's an important metric in most bschool rankings after all.
  2. I am assuming you have listed your work in reverse chronological order. Engineering work after undergrad could actually be good (assuming not IT/tech). Assuming you are from India (?), the fact that you've been able to break into those areas in EU is quite rare and remarkable - make sure you leverage that story well. Ecommerce is great; however, auto is not a well represented industry in most top bschools. While that can make differentiation easy, it also can make adcoms a bit jittery about your skills and employability - so think carefully on that front.
  3. The post-MBA goal, as noted above, will need clarity, research and a compelling narrative. It is not clear if those are in a continuum or distinct options (hope it is the latter). a and c can be tough - check on the feasibility aspect.
  4. LBS actually has a fantastic entrepreneurship program; tends to be a hub for FinTech. Recruitment however is a completely different story. HEC/INSEAD would be better choices in that regard. In the US, might be worth exploring a few more programs known for Tech MBA. Always a good idea to hedge the bets some.
  5. The ECs arc looks good; recency effect is crucial however - is any of that ongoing?

Hope this gives you a bit more direction and help.

Cheers,
User avatar
MBADecoder
Joined: 16 Jan 2012
Last visit: 13 Dec 2024
Posts: 2,769
Own Kudos:
661
 []
Given Kudos: 192
Expert reply
Posts: 2,769
Kudos: 661
 []
1
Kudos
Add Kudos
Bookmarks
Bookmark this Post
Othasollala

I read this article and was immediately reminded of you. Its very relevant to your views about a b-school having the right ecosystem for you. This one is about Haas:

https://news.berkeley.edu/2019/07/10/lyons-named-berkeleys-first-chief-innovation-entrepreneurship-officer/
avatar
Othasollala
avatar
Current Student
Joined: 30 Jan 2019
Last visit: 15 Mar 2022
Posts: 11
Own Kudos:
Given Kudos: 19
Location: India
GMAT 1: 740 Q50 V41
Products:
GMAT 1: 740 Q50 V41
Posts: 11
Kudos: 7
Kudos
Add Kudos
Bookmarks
Bookmark this Post
MBADecoder
Othasollala
Hello,

I am kind of in a dillemna with my Target school selection process. I would like your thoughts on my selection process as well as if you think I should add any schools to my list.

I have finished my undergrad in Engineering with a really mediocre GPA. Worked for 3 years in Europe and 1 year in India.

My profile is as follows.

a. Undergrad GPA : 2.8/4 ( I was last in my class of those who passed, but i did have an undiagnosed thyroid condition that kinda messed me up)
b. Masters in Management GPA : 4/4 (Edhec Business School, France, Graduated top 10% of the promo)
c. Work ex :
2 Years in Automotive in Product Management and Strategy (Gates + Valeo + Nissan)
1 Year in E-Commerce in Pricing and category Management (Rocket Internet + Flipkart)
1 year in Engineering post undergrad


GMAT : 750 (Q51, V40)


Extras :
a. Speak French
b. Undertook Probono strategy Consulting Projects to gain valuable experience to break into consulting post MBA
c. President : Entrepreneurship Department at Entreprenuership club at Undergrad
d. Member United nations Club at EDHEC


Post MBA goals

I woud like to return to Asia after 5 years of working abroad, my ideal career paths would look like this :

a. Entreprenueship Tech (Eigher start own firm or exciting opportunity in fast growth startup)
b. Consulting for 3 years and then move to Entreprenuership with valuable experience (Most likely scenario)
c. Work in promoting intra country trade (work with commerce chambers of France for ex in India to promote investments)

I know its super competitive for a person from my demographic and Background to get into an M7/top 10 Schools. I have chosen my target schools not because of the names or ranking but really because of the programs/opportunities they offer. My Target schools at the moment are .

Dream Schools

a. Haas (Dream school because of location, Exposure to Tech and MBB Placements). Also has a double degree with EDHEC (Masters) hence hoping they atleast know my Masters School. Though I also know that its more selective then most of the M7 and my undergrad GPA kind of might kill my chances . Will my Masters GPA make a difference here ?
b. Kellogg (MMM) Combines Design, Innovation courses and an MBA into an incredible program that I think would give me the most intellectual satisfaction and also Kellogg has a Great MBB trackrecord

Schools I may have a good shot at :

a. Cornell Johnson School of Business : Well known brand in Asia, though MBB Placements are not noteworthy. Also not hearing the best things about Cornell in Gmat Club Reviews
b. HEC/NYU Stern : Targeting HEC since it has a double degree with Stern, Hence it would minimise Visa issues if i were to get into H1b Hell in the USA. Though Stern is a Finance School and not really known for Tech/Entreprenuership. Neither is HEC.

European Schools that would allow me to go back to Asia with good employment prospects :
(Though I really am not leaning toward European programs as an MBA is really an American product, with the best ecosystems for post MBA sucess wrt Entreprenuership. For Ex , All top 10 schools have incubation centres in Collaboration with Design, Engineering, Medical departments of Parent University. This is something that is simply lacking In european Programs. Also the kind of work that for Example MBB do here or Amazon offices would undertake would be less strategic since most companies hiring MBAs are MNCs for their Satellite offices. Though these schools would open up good opportunities in Asia for me. So the list is )

a. LBS : Alumni told me not the best school for placements for asians expecially with Brexit coming up. Also it is a pure B-School which does not work with Engineering/Tech Departments of any university.
b. Insead : went to an admissions event . Really impressed with program, not so impressed with lack of opportunities to leverage other departments Strengths like at a True university

What do you think ? Should I add some other schools to the List ? i have not added any safety schools as a school maybe good in Target Market but might not be any good for going back to India with good career opportunities. I also am not looking at Indian programs since the class lacks diversity of Nationalities and that is something I value a lot.

Thanks for your input

If your low undergrad GPA is solely because of your medical condition, you should let the adcoms know, via the optional essay. A case in point to argue for your academic ability could be the perfect MIM score and the high GMAT score. You can also have your recommenders attest your intellectual abilities.

In my opinion, your beliefs about MBAs in Europe are misplaced. They offer some of the best MBAs in the world, and you should do some more research on them to find exactly what you need, rather than making generic statements. For example, explore their courses and electives for the ones that make most sense for you. Even if they have an affiliation with the medical college, and that's not a path you are going to follow, it would be meaningless for you. Just because interdiscilpinary courses are offered by schools does not mean that you will also require to study them. So know your needs specifically otherwise you may miss out on MBA programs that have very strong curriculum in your desired area of study. Also, MBBs do strategic work whether in USA or Europe or Asia, and they cater to their clients within the region, with geographic mobility to bring in experts on specific projects.

What you need to do immediately is introspect on your career goals and figure out a single path. You've mentioned three different paths here and that won't go down too well with the adcoms.

Its a highly competitive process out there and the reality is that b-schools are more selective of the applicants than the other way around. Focus on researching these programs deeply and getting your story right.

Hello Namita,

Thank you for taking the time to comment on my post. The Key takeaways I believe are

a. Getting my Target Career Path right : I maybe mistaken in my thought process that giving multiple career scenarios was a plus, given if one does not work out, the other would still be worth a shot. I hear this also from other people who have applied to MBAs. I shall present a clear singuar forward path in my application then which is "Consulting with a shift later to Tech".

b. European MBA Programs : You mention that there are some fantastic ones in EU, I agree with you. Its just that to me, it is very important that a university has an ecosystem because what wakes me up in the morning each day is exploring new possibilities of applying Tech and Tech advancements to solving real problems across different industries. Hence Iam looking for specific programs where the parent uni has a strong Tech background .

Hope you are having a good weekend :).
avatar
Othasollala
avatar
Current Student
Joined: 30 Jan 2019
Last visit: 15 Mar 2022
Posts: 11
Own Kudos:
Given Kudos: 19
Location: India
GMAT 1: 740 Q50 V41
Products:
GMAT 1: 740 Q50 V41
Posts: 11
Kudos: 7
Kudos
Add Kudos
Bookmarks
Bookmark this Post
SiaAdmissions
Hi ,

Thank you for your post and for sharing your profile. A few things to note:

Academics: The admissions committee will view your profile holistically, which means they will look beyond your undergraduate performance. Your master's GPA and your GMAT also speaks to your caliber, so when you address your undergraduate performance, be sure to talk about how you have overcome.

Professional experience: Your work experience seems interesting, but you have changed industries multiple time. Since this may be perceived as a red flag, it is vital you outline your goals and address how your previous experiences will help you reach them. It is also pivotal that you have a clear goal (multiple goals will not do for a successful admission); otherwise, the adcom may view your candidacy as not ready for an MBA.

Community Engagement: Are the engagement's you've done in university or post-MiM?

As to your school concerns, I recommend you speak to multiple students/alumni per university to get a better sense of the experiences you may have should you be accepted. It is important to note that while some universities offer the opportunity to take courses in other schools/departments, be mindful of the number of classes they allow (typically no more than 3 electives). Dual degrees are an alternative and give you an additional year (3 years total) to fulfill the requirements of both degrees. That said, universities that do offer a dual degree program also require you apply to and be accepted by both programs to attend.


I also think you need to be introspective and ask yourself why do you require an MBA? A clearer understanding of what you are trying to gain from the program will help you along this process of discovery. Any program you choose will have the mandatory core curriculum, and some will offer electives that allow you to "customize" your degree on your second year. Of course, less than two-year programs will have more restrictions on the electives they offer just because of time.

Political make matter complicated, especially for international students; however, the 2019 GMAC Corporate Recruiters Survey shows that 71% of European business either plan or are willing to hire internationals in 2019, up from 50% in 2018. I recommend further research on your objections so you do not miss out on some wonderful universities.

If you would like to continue the conversation, please to coordinate a call.

Good luck!


Othasollala
Hello,

I am kind of in a dillemna with my Target school selection process. I would like your thoughts on my selection process as well as if you think I should add any schools to my list.

I have finished my undergrad in Engineering with a really mediocre GPA. Worked for 3 years in Europe and 1 year in India.

My profile is as follows.

a. Undergrad GPA : 2.8/4 ( I was last in my class of those who passed, but i did have an undiagnosed thyroid condition that kinda messed me up)
b. Masters in Management GPA : 4/4 (Edhec Business School, France, Graduated top 10% of the promo)
c. Work ex :
2 Years in Automotive in Product Management and Strategy (Gates + Valeo + Nissan)
1 Year in E-Commerce in Pricing and category Management (Rocket Internet + Flipkart)
1 year in Engineering post undergrad


GMAT : 750 (Q51, V40)


Extras :
a. Speak French
b. Undertook Probono strategy Consulting Projects to gain valuable experience to break into consulting post MBA
c. President : Entrepreneurship Department at Entreprenuership club at Undergrad
d. Member United nations Club at EDHEC


Post MBA goals

I woud like to return to Asia after 5 years of working abroad, my ideal career paths would look like this :

a. Entreprenueship Tech (Eigher start own firm or exciting opportunity in fast growth startup)
b. Consulting for 3 years and then move to Entreprenuership with valuable experience (Most likely scenario)
c. Work in promoting intra country trade (work with commerce chambers of France for ex in India to promote investments)

I know its super competitive for a person from my demographic and Background to get into an M7/top 10 Schools. I have chosen my target schools not because of the names or ranking but really because of the programs/opportunities they offer. My Target schools at the moment are .

Dream Schools

a. Haas (Dream school because of location, Exposure to Tech and MBB Placements). Also has a double degree with EDHEC (Masters) hence hoping they atleast know my Masters School. Though I also know that its more selective then most of the M7 and my undergrad GPA kind of might kill my chances . Will my Masters GPA make a difference here ?
b. Kellogg (MMM) Combines Design, Innovation courses and an MBA into an incredible program that I think would give me the most intellectual satisfaction and also Kellogg has a Great MBB trackrecord

Schools I may have a good shot at :

a. Cornell Johnson School of Business : Well known brand in Asia, though MBB Placements are not noteworthy. Also not hearing the best things about Cornell in Gmat Club Reviews
b. HEC/NYU Stern : Targeting HEC since it has a double degree with Stern, Hence it would minimise Visa issues if i were to get into H1b Hell in the USA. Though Stern is a Finance School and not really known for Tech/Entreprenuership. Neither is HEC.

European Schools that would allow me to go back to Asia with good employment prospects :
(Though I really am not leaning toward European programs as an MBA is really an American product, with the best ecosystems for post MBA sucess wrt Entreprenuership. For Ex , All top 10 schools have incubation centres in Collaboration with Design, Engineering, Medical departments of Parent University. This is something that is simply lacking In european Programs. Also the kind of work that for Example MBB do here or Amazon offices would undertake would be less strategic since most companies hiring MBAs are MNCs for their Satellite offices. Though these schools would open up good opportunities in Asia for me. So the list is )

a. LBS : Alumni told me not the best school for placements for asians expecially with Brexit coming up. Also it is a pure B-School which does not work with Engineering/Tech Departments of any university.
b. Insead : went to an admissions event . Really impressed with program, not so impressed with lack of opportunities to leverage other departments Strengths like at a True university

What do you think ? Should I add some other schools to the List ? i have not added any safety schools as a school maybe good in Target Market but might not be any good for going back to India with good career opportunities. I also am not looking at Indian programs since the class lacks diversity of Nationalities and that is something I value a lot.

Thanks for your input

Hello Susan,

Thank you for taking the time to comment on my post. The Key takeaways I believe are

a. Explaining the multiple career shifts : I am sorry I was not clear in my original post. My MIM program mandates that I undertake 3 internships (6 months each) hopefully in 3 different industries and profiles for maximum exposure. My target industry is though very clear in my mind, I will take the time to explain my Work ex , Target industry/Function and how and MBA will help me get there.


b. European MBA Programs : You mention that there are some fantastic ones in EU, I agree with you. Its just that to me, it is very important that a university has an ecosystem because what wakes me up in the morning each day is exploring new possibilities of applying Tech and Tech advancements to solving real problems across different industries. The other thing that is very much frowned upon in europe is Interdisciplicary leadership. It is very rare for a European to move from for example supply chain to Finance even though a lot of the work may need common analytical skills with forecasting. In the USA, they actually encourage cross departmental skill sharing and learning. the reason i say this is I work for a US firm now in Europe. This would translate also into post MBA roles for people in European companies. A business School Grad is just that , a business school grad with an Emphasis on Marketing, or finance or Supply chain. These are my observations and can ofcourse be very wrong, but thats the sense I get.

Hope you are having a good weekend :).
avatar
Othasollala
avatar
Current Student
Joined: 30 Jan 2019
Last visit: 15 Mar 2022
Posts: 11
Own Kudos:
Given Kudos: 19
Location: India
GMAT 1: 740 Q50 V41
Products:
GMAT 1: 740 Q50 V41
Posts: 11
Kudos: 7
Kudos
Add Kudos
Bookmarks
Bookmark this Post
MG4MBACrystalBall
Echoing a bit and a few more perspectives for you

  1. The academic arc, as noted already, looks to have had a pretty great trajectory. If it was undiagnosed, it might always be a bit of suspect, but given that you have 'proof' of stellar record later, would lend credibility to your claims. That being said, undergrad GPA will still come into play and schools would have to look at it as an exception - it's an important metric in most bschool rankings after all.
  2. I am assuming you have listed your work in reverse chronological order. Engineering work after undergrad could actually be good (assuming not IT/tech). Assuming you are from India (?), the fact that you've been able to break into those areas in EU is quite rare and remarkable - make sure you leverage that story well. Ecommerce is great; however, auto is not a well represented industry in most top bschools. While that can make differentiation easy, it also can make adcoms a bit jittery about your skills and employability - so think carefully on that front.
  3. The post-MBA goal, as noted above, will need clarity, research and a compelling narrative. It is not clear if those are in a continuum or distinct options (hope it is the latter). a and c can be tough - check on the feasibility aspect.
  4. LBS actually has a fantastic entrepreneurship program; tends to be a hub for FinTech. Recruitment however is a completely different story. HEC/INSEAD would be better choices in that regard. In the US, might be worth exploring a few more programs known for [u]Tech MBA. Always a good idea to hedge the bets some.
  5. The ECs arc looks good; recency effect is crucial however - is any of that ongoing?

Hope this gives you a bit more direction and help.

Cheers,

Hello Manish,

Thank you for taking the time to comment on my post. I enjoy reading MBA crystal Ball Articles, there are a lot of good topics covered.

a. Explaining career path better : Indeed, a lot of people I have spoken with have also mentioned that having one clear target career path is better. I will cut down ambiguity when I make my essays.


b. European MBA Programs : Indeed you point regarding LBS is true, its a fantastic school Wrt finance and there is an incredibly support system when it comes to Startups in that space and Fintech. Though its just not my field. That is also the same reason NYU stern does not rock my boat. And you are completely right, there are some programs in EU like the ESMT, MDI, HEC which a lot of people consider a notch below LBS/Insead but in reality, get incredible/comparable exit opportunities due to smaller class size, location and perception in local market.

c. Extra-Ciriculars : I am not really part of any community or taking part in anything except for French studies which are aimed at better integration and understanding of EU Culture. Is this something that is important and needs to be worked on ?


Hope you are having a good weekend :)

Thanks,
avatar
JDF
Joined: 20 Apr 2019
Last visit: 30 Apr 2020
Posts: 73
Own Kudos:
Given Kudos: 5
GPA: 3.11
Products:
Posts: 73
Kudos: 24
Kudos
Add Kudos
Bookmarks
Bookmark this Post
I don’t think your GPA is as much of a worry as it is for some because of your GMAT and your grad degree. It’s also a hard major. Are you an international who went to a US undergrad?

I’d correct one thing about NYU not being a tech school. I think Amazon was their #1 employer last year. They place people in tech.

Posted from my mobile device
User avatar
MG4MBACrystalBall
Joined: 29 Aug 2010
Last visit: 11 Dec 2024
Posts: 926
Own Kudos:
Given Kudos: 1
Posts: 926
Kudos: 152
Kudos
Add Kudos
Bookmarks
Bookmark this Post
Othasollala
Hello Manish,

Thank you for taking the time to comment on my post. I enjoy reading MBA crystal Ball Articles, there are a lot of good topics covered.

<<snip>>

c. Extra-Ciriculars : I am not really part of any community or taking part in anything except for French studies which are aimed at better integration and understanding of EU Culture. Is this something that is important and needs to be worked on ?

Hope you are having a good weekend :)

Thanks,


Othasollala, ECs definitely matter. In the limited time, not a lot you can do but be aware, in case that's a potential blind spot.

Cheers,