Studies of brain lateralization in animals have purported to

Question

Studies of brain lateralization in animals have purported to show that, whereas most human beings are right-handed, about half of any given group of animals will be “left-handed” (i.e., showing a preference for their left limbs) and half will be “right-handed.” This finding is suspect, however; it has long been noted that dogs will almost always “shake hands” with the right paw.

Which one of the following, if true, is the strongest defense against the counterexample of dogs that “shake hands”?

(A) Dogs are observed to scratch themselves with the left leg as well as with the right leg.

(B) People who observe dogs “shaking hands” are observing a behavior that dogs perform only with a front paw.

(C) Left-handed people sometimes feel inconvenienced or even stigmatized in a “right-handed world,” but dogs face no analogous difficulties.

(D) Dogs that have lost a limb are able to compensate for the loss, regardless of whether the limb was lost from the right or left side.

(E) In learning to perform tricks, dogs are influenced by the behavior of their trainers.

Source: LSAT

CrackverbalGMAT · Accepted Answer

let us see what the argument says -

Studies 
Half the dogs are right handed.

Counter Argument 
Dogs shake hands with right paws --> Most of the dogs are right handed.

We have been asked to weaken the counter example. That means we have to say that indeed half the dogs are right handed.

let us look at the answer options -

Option A - Incorrect.
Does not mean that they do not have a preference for the right paw. After all, we use both our hands for various tasks (including scratching itches). Does not mean that we do not have a preference.

Option B - Incorrect.
this has nothing to do with preference for either the right paw or left paw. Irrelevant.

Option C - Incorrect
If they do not have any "stigma", we cannot consider stigma as a reason for - dogs shake hands with right paws. Hence, we cannot reject - "Most dogs are right handed".

Option D - Incorrect.
If they lost a limb, then they do not have a choice. They cannot then express a preference for right paw over the left. They have to make do with whatever they have.

Option E - Correct Answer.
Since most people are right handed (and considering that "shaking hands" is a trick), it is quite natural that dogs are influenced by their trainers. Hence, most of them use right-paw even though they might not be "right handed".

petrifiedbutstanding · Answer

I'm going with E. This is my analysis:

(A) Dogs are observed to scratch themselves with the left leg as well as with the right leg.
 This choice go against the premise. It remains neutral.

(B) People who observe dogs “shaking hands” are observing a behavior that dogs perform only with a front paw. 
 This does not influence the answer choice at all.

(C) Left-handed people sometimes feel inconvenienced or even stigmatized in a “right-handed world,” but dogs face no analogous difficulties. 
 Nope

(D) Dogs that have lost a limb are able to compensate for the loss, regardless of whether the limb was lost from the right or left side. 
 Does not matter.

(E) In learning to perform tricks, dogs are influenced by the behavior of their trainers.
 Bingo. Since trainers being humans (assuming they're all human beings and not dogs themselves) are mostly right-handed based on the lines in the passage, it is safe to say the dogs imitate their trainers when they learn tricks.

bb61 · Answer

I think E is the correct answer. 
 con:  this finding is suspect. (finding= whereas most human beings are right-handed, about half of any given group of animals will be “left-handed” (i.e., showing a preference for their left limbs) and half will be “right-handed.”)
 premise:  it has long been noted that dogs will almost always “shake hands” with the right paw.
 counter premise:  Studies of brain lateralization in animals have purported to show that, whereas most human beings are right-handed, about half of any given group of animals will be “left-handed” (i.e., showing a preference for their left limbs) and half will be “right-handed.” 
analysis: it is assumed that dogs almost always shake hands with the right paw because they are right- handed. however if we show that their shaking hands is what they've learned from right handed human beings instead of relating to their brain lateralization, then we defend the argument against the counter example of dogs.

Question stem: Which one of the following, if true, is the strongest defense against the counterexample of dogs that “shake hands”?

(A) Dogs are observed to scratch themselves with the  left leg  as well as with the  right leg . the arguments talks about dogs' shaking hands not leg!

(B) People who observe dogs “shaking hands” are observing a behavior that dogs perform only with a  front paw . the argument is discussing about left or right!

(C) Left-handed people sometimes  feel inconvenienced or even stigmatized in a “right-handed world,”  but dogs face no analogous difficulties. feeling convenience or uncomfortable does not justify the reaction of dogs' shaking hands habit.

(D) Dogs that have  lost a limb  are able to compensate for the loss, regardless of whether the limb was lost from the right or left side.  out

(E) In learning to perform tricks, dogs are influenced by the behavior of their trainers.  the correct ans 
if we show that what we observe from dogs shake hands is a learned habit from right handed human beings instead of being left or right handed it means we reject the counter example of dogs.

shubham496 · Answer

Good Explaination :-D

E it is.

kinjiGC · Answer

I marked Option D) and then I realized that I marked D) because I misinterpreted the argument. The Conclusion is "50% of the animals are left handed and 50% of animals are right handed". Both Option A) and D) are indicating that dogs are ambidextrous (Can use both left and right hand) and doesn't strengthen the argument.

Nice question.

Skywalker18 · Answer

Studies of brain lateralization in animals have purported to show that, whereas most human beings are right-handed, about half of any given group of animals will be “left-handed” (i.e., showing a preference for their left limbs) and half will be “right-handed.” This finding is suspect, however; it has long been noted that dogs will almost always “shake hands” with the right paw.

dogs show a preference for shaking with the right paw --> finding that mammal handedness is 50/50 is suspect

Which one of the following, if true, is the strongest defense against the counterexample of dogs that “shake hands”?

(A) Dogs are observed to scratch themselves with the left leg as well as with the right leg. -- Still does not address why dogs almost always shake hands with right paw

(B) People who observe dogs “shaking hands” are observing a behavior that dogs perform only with a front paw. -- Still does not address why dogs almost always shake hands with right paw

(C) Left-handed people sometimes feel inconvenienced or even stigmatized in a “right-handed world,” but dogs face no analogous difficulties. -- Irrelevant

(D) Dogs that have lost a limb are able to compensate for the loss, regardless of whether the limb was lost from the right or left side. -- Still does not address why dogs almost always shake hands with right paw

(E) In learning to perform tricks, dogs are influenced by the behavior of their trainers. --gives us a defense of the counterexample because we're told in the stimulus that most human beings are right handed so that explains why dogs almost always shake with their right hands -- it's because they are influenced by their right handed trainers and not because they have a natural preference for their right hand.

Adelajne · Answer

(A) Dogs are observed to scratch themselves with the left leg as well as with the right leg.
Shows that dogs use BOTH left and right hands but doesn't weaken the fact that they use ONLY left hand and not the right one.

(B) People who observe dogs “shaking hands” are observing a behavior that dogs perform only with a front paw.
out of scope

(C) Left-handed people sometimes feel inconvenienced or even stigmatized in a “right-handed world,” but dogs face no analogous difficulties.
doesnt explain why 1/2 of the animals use left hand

(D) Dogs that have lost a limb are able to compensate for the loss, regardless of whether the limb was lost from the right or left side.
Not talking just the dogs that have lost a limb, we are talking about dogs in general

(E) In learning to perform tricks, dogs are influenced by the behavior of their trainers.
Matches my pre-thenking, that the dogs do what their owner does, so  mimic the behavior  but is not usually right handed, is left handed   CORRECT

Adelajne · Answer

(A) Dogs are observed to scratch themselves with the left leg as well as with the right leg.
Shows that dogs use BOTH left and right hands but doesn't weaken the fact that they use ONLY left hand and not the right one.

(B) People who observe dogs “shaking hands” are observing a behavior that dogs perform only with a front paw.
out of scope

(C) Left-handed people sometimes feel inconvenienced or even stigmatized in a “right-handed world,” but dogs face no analogous difficulties.
doesnt explain why 1/2 of the animals use left hand

(D) Dogs that have lost a limb are able to compensate for the loss, regardless of whether the limb was lost from the right or left side.
Not talking just the dogs that have lost a limb, we are talking about dogs in general

(E) In learning to perform tricks, dogs are influenced by the behavior of their trainers.
Matches my pre-thenking, that the dogs do what their owner does, so  mimic the behavior  but is not usually right handed, is left handed   CORRECT

VerbalBot · Answer

Hello from the GMAT Club VerbalBot!

Thanks to another GMAT Club member, I have just discovered this valuable topic, yet it had no discussion for over a year. I am now bumping it up - doing my job. I think you may find it valuable (esp those replies with Kudos).

Want to see all other topics I dig out? Follow me (click follow button on profile). You will receive a summary of all topics I bump in your profile area as well as via email.

Studies of brain lateralization in animals have purported to

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

GMAT Critical Reasoning (CR) Questions

Studies of brain lateralization in animals have purported to

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards