Quote:
2) Which of the following statements, if true, would most seriously undermine the author’s arguments against expensive assistance programs?
Quote:
Assistance programs, with their concern for visibility, frequently include ill-adapted showpieces such as large hospitals, advanced technical apparatus, and specialized training in clinical medicine and surgery. In promoting complicated and expensive projects, outside aid programs dissipate local resources and skilled manpower and perpetuate dependency of poorer nations on the advanced nations. Developing countries need to improve their sanitary systems, provide for adequate nutrition, and immunize their people against communicable diseases. Experience has shown that even programs only partially meeting these needs result in a dramatic reduction of infant mortality and an increase in life expectancy.
Author says that assistance program by developed countries include some ill- adapted items that would make dependency on developing nations on developed nations because of skilled man power and specialized resources needed to run these items.
So instead of these assistance program, developing countries need to focus on basic things first: sanitation , nutrition and immunization.
In summary , author claim tends to say that :
these assistance program are not much helpful for developing countries, Question: Weaken the author claim
Pre-thinking: Assistance programs are actually bringing value to developing countries
Quote:
A) People in developing countries have illnesses that are different from those that people in advanced countries have.
Irrelevant: Different illness different discussion; no effect on conclusion
Quote:
B) Advanced countries contribute to a more equal distribution of wealth when they donate medical facilities to other countries.
Out of scope: No effect on conclusion
Quote:
C) Expensive assistance programs provide useful technical knowledge for use in developing countries.
But it may still bring dependency on developed nations. So not weakening
Quote:
D) Expensive assistance programs train highly qualified doctors and technicians from both developing countries and advanced countries.
But how does it add value to developing countries in terms of improving heat.
Quote:
E) Expensive assistance programs improve all medical services available in developing countries.
-
correctThis option hits the conclusion directly, so these assistance program would be helpful for common people. It would add value to improve basic things: sanitation , nutrition and immunization.
( its given “all” in the option. It sounds too extreme but that’s what we need accept as true)