capsguy2018
Hello!
In option E is there an issue with with the two "and". Is a comma not required?
Also, in a case with two separate ands do we need to check for parallelism?
Thanks
Hey
capsguy2018Happy to help you with this.
Such questions test the Core Skill of being able to visualize the Structure of Sentences, particularly complex sentences such as choice E. This skill, if mastered, can help you identify grammatical and structural errors with ease. Allow me to demonstrate:
E: The newspaper story accurately recounted the history of the colonial mansion and said that the mansion contained thirteen rooms and had the reputation of being haunted.
Sentence Structure:
o The newspaper story accurately
o recounted the history of the colonial mansion and
o contained thirteen rooms and
o had the reputation of being haunted.
Now, as you can see from the above, there are two separate lists in this sentence. The first list contains the two verbs of the subject "
story": "
recounted" and "
said". The second list contains the two verb of the subject "
mansion": "
contained" and "
had".
So, each of these lists contain only two entities.
Now, as per the Oxford Comma Rule, we need to place a comma before "and" in lists of three entities or more, and not in a list of only two entities.
This is why choice E does not have a comma error.
Coming to your second question:
Parallelism needs to be maintained between entities within one list. For instance, in Choice E, the verbs "recounted" and "said" are parallel because they are part of the same list. On the other hand, the verbs "contained" and "had" are parallel because they are part of the same list. But, the verbs "recounted" and "said" are not parallel to the verbs "contained" and "had". This is because they are not part of the same list.
I hope this response helps you understand parallelism and the core skill of identifying the structure of complex sentences.
Happy Learning!
Abhishek