May 24 10:00 PM PDT  11:00 PM PDT Join a FREE 1day workshop and learn how to ace the GMAT while keeping your fulltime job. Limited for the first 99 registrants. May 25 07:00 AM PDT  09:00 AM PDT Attend this webinar and master GMAT SC in 10 days by learning how meaning and logic can help you tackle 700+ level SC questions with ease. May 27 01:00 AM PDT  11:59 PM PDT All GMAT Club Tests are free and open on May 27th for Memorial Day! May 27 10:00 PM PDT  11:00 PM PDT Special savings are here for Magoosh GMAT Prep! Even better  save 20% on the plan of your choice, now through midnight on Tuesday, 5/27
Author 
Message 
TAGS:

Hide Tags

Manager
Joined: 05 Mar 2010
Posts: 165

The set S of numbers has the following properties
[#permalink]
Show Tags
09 Jun 2010, 06:51
Question Stats:
38% (01:42) correct 62% (01:26) wrong based on 90 sessions
HideShow timer Statistics
The set S of numbers has the following properties: I) If x is in S, then 1/x is in S. II) If both x and y are in S, then so is x + y. Is 3 in S? (1) 1/3 is in S. (2) 1 is in S.
Official Answer and Stats are available only to registered users. Register/ Login.
_________________



Intern
Joined: 02 May 2010
Posts: 46
Schools: IU, UT Dallas, Univ of Georgia, Univ of Arkansas, Miami University
WE 1: 5.5 Yrs IT

Re: The set S of numbers has the following properties
[#permalink]
Show Tags
09 Jun 2010, 06:56
hardnstrong wrote: The set S of numbers has the following properties: I) If x is in S, then 1/x is in S. II) If both x and y are in S, then so is x + y.
Is 3 in S?
(1)1/3 is in S. (2) 1 is in S.
OA will be posted later. 1  Sufficient. If 1/3 is in S, then 3 is in S 2  Insufficient. IMO A



Math Expert
Joined: 02 Sep 2009
Posts: 55228

Re: The set S of numbers has the following properties
[#permalink]
Show Tags
09 Jun 2010, 07:07
hardnstrong wrote: The set S of numbers has the following properties: I) If x is in S, then 1/x is in S. II) If both x and y are in S, then so is x + y.
Is 3 in S?
(1) 1/3 is in S. (2) 1 is in S.
OA will be posted later. The wording is a little bit strange but anyway: (1) 1/3 is in S > according to (i) \(\frac{1}{\frac{1}{3}}=3\) must also be in S. Sufficient. (1) 1 is in S > according to (i) \(\frac{1}{1}=1\) (another 1) must also be in S, then according to (ii) \(1+1=2\) must also be in S > \(1+2=3\) must also be in S. Sufficient. Answer: D.
_________________



Intern
Joined: 02 May 2010
Posts: 46
Schools: IU, UT Dallas, Univ of Georgia, Univ of Arkansas, Miami University
WE 1: 5.5 Yrs IT

Re: The set S of numbers has the following properties
[#permalink]
Show Tags
09 Jun 2010, 07:17
Splendid...+1! Dint look at it that way. Thanks for the explanation. OA Please! (Not that I doubt it is D)



Manager
Joined: 05 Mar 2010
Posts: 165

Re: The set S of numbers has the following properties
[#permalink]
Show Tags
09 Jun 2010, 07:40
Bunuel wrote: hardnstrong wrote: The set S of numbers has the following properties: I) If x is in S, then 1/x is in S. II) If both x and y are in S, then so is x + y.
Is 3 in S?
(1) 1/3 is in S. (2) 1 is in S.
OA will be posted later. The wording is a little bit strange but anyway: (1) 1/3 is in S > according to (i) \(\frac{1}{\frac{1}{3}}=3\) must also be in S. Sufficient. (1) 1 is in S > according to (i) \(\frac{1}{1}=1\) (another 1) must also be in S, then according to (ii) \(1+1=2\) must also be in S > \(1+2=3\) must also be in S. Sufficient. Answer: D. OA is D But my point is (in stmt 2), if 1 is in set then according to (i) we have 1/1 in set, that mean another 1 . so x=1 and y =1 Now acc. to (ii) we have 1+1 =2 (x + y = z) in set Now, can we again take the value of x or y as 2 How can x+y = x or y when neither x nor y is 0 Can we assume having more than one value of x or y? or does it mean x and y are any two values in set? But question dosent say any two values, it just say x and y (two specific values) Please explain?
_________________



Math Expert
Joined: 02 Sep 2009
Posts: 55228

Re: The set S of numbers has the following properties
[#permalink]
Show Tags
09 Jun 2010, 07:57
hardnstrong wrote: Bunuel wrote: hardnstrong wrote: The set S of numbers has the following properties: I) If x is in S, then 1/x is in S. II) If both x and y are in S, then so is x + y.
Is 3 in S?
(1) 1/3 is in S. (2) 1 is in S.
OA will be posted later. The wording is a little bit strange but anyway: (1) 1/3 is in S > according to (i) \(\frac{1}{\frac{1}{3}}=3\) must also be in S. Sufficient. (1) 1 is in S > according to (i) \(\frac{1}{1}=1\) (another 1) must also be in S, then according to (ii) \(1+1=2\) must also be in S > \(1+2=3\) must also be in S. Sufficient. Answer: D. OA is D But my point is (in stmt 2), if 1 is in set then according to (i) we have 1/1 in set, that mean another 1 . so x=1 and y =1 Now acc. to (ii) we have 1+1 =2 (x + y = z) in set Now, can we again take the value of x or y as 2 How can x+y = x or y when neither x nor y is 0 Can we assume having more than one value of x or y? or does it mean x and y are any two values in set? But question dosent say any two values, it just say x and y (two specific values) Please explain? As I said the wording is quite strange, GMAT won't use such language. But as OA given as D, then the stem is meant to be understood as I did in my solution. One note though: x and y are variables not exact values.
_________________



Manager
Joined: 05 Mar 2010
Posts: 165

Re: The set S of numbers has the following properties
[#permalink]
Show Tags
09 Jun 2010, 11:10
Thanks for your explanation It was helpful as always
_________________



Manager
Joined: 24 Jul 2016
Posts: 51

Re: The set S of numbers has the following properties
[#permalink]
Show Tags
13 Jul 2017, 14:36
hardnstrong wrote: The set S of numbers has the following properties:
I) If x is in S, then 1/x is in S. II) If both x and y are in S, then so is x + y.
Is 3 in S?
(1) 1/3 is in S. (2) 1 is in S. i believe this qn is poorly worded



GMAT Tutor
Joined: 24 Jun 2008
Posts: 1520

Re: The set S of numbers has the following properties
[#permalink]
Show Tags
13 Jul 2017, 15:10
Technically in a set you can't have repeated values, which is why GMAT stats questions which permit repeated values always talk about "lists" of numbers, or "data sets" (which can have repeated values). So here, when you use Statement 2, you don't need to use the property that "If x is in S, then 1/x is in S" to prove that you have another '1' in the set  you already know '1' is in the set, and there can only be one '1' in a set. The only question is, reading this, "If both x and y are in S, then so is x + y", whether x and y can represent the exact same value from the set. If so, then when 1 is in the set, so is 1+1 and so is thus 2+1, but if not, the set could just be {1}. Because of the word "both", I'd be inclined to think that x and y need to be different values, but there's no unambiguous answer to that question. So really we're just left to guess what the question writer meant. Bunuel has certainly correctly interpreted the intentions of the question writer, but the wording of the question doesn't convey those intentions properly. There are official questions (rare ones) that test a similar concept that have none of the issues that this question has, and those might be worth looking at, but this question is not.
_________________
GMAT Tutor in Toronto
If you are looking for online GMAT math tutoring, or if you are interested in buying my advanced Quant books and problem sets, please contact me at ianstewartgmat at gmail.com



Intern
Joined: 25 Mar 2016
Posts: 40
Location: India
Concentration: Finance, General Management
WE: Other (Other)

Re: The set S of numbers has the following properties
[#permalink]
Show Tags
14 Jul 2017, 20:04
Bunuel wrote: hardnstrong wrote: The set S of numbers has the following properties: I) If x is in S, then 1/x is in S. II) If both x and y are in S, then so is x + y.
Is 3 in S?
(1) 1/3 is in S. (2) 1 is in S.
OA will be posted later. The wording is a little bit strange but anyway: (1) 1/3 is in S > according to (i) \(\frac{1}{\frac{1}{3}}=3\) must also be in S. Sufficient. (1) 1 is in S > according to (i) \(\frac{1}{1}=1\) (another 1) must also be in S, then according to (ii) \(1+1=2\) must also be in S > \(1+2=3\) must also be in S. Sufficient. Answer: D. Hi Bunuel, If the answer is D then both the condition A & B should answer the question independently but you have use condition A & B together to answer the question. Is it right ? "(1) 1 is in S > according to (i) \(\frac{1}{1}=1\) (another 1) must also be in S, then according to (ii) \(1+1=2\) must also be in S > \(1+2=3\) must also be in S. Sufficient. " as per the condition B only one value is given So we can consider it either as X or as Y.



Math Expert
Joined: 02 Sep 2009
Posts: 55228

The set S of numbers has the following properties
[#permalink]
Show Tags
15 Jul 2017, 02:23
PK32 wrote: Bunuel wrote: hardnstrong wrote: The set S of numbers has the following properties: I) If x is in S, then 1/x is in S. II) If both x and y are in S, then so is x + y.
Is 3 in S?
(1) 1/3 is in S. (2) 1 is in S.
OA will be posted later. The wording is a little bit strange but anyway: (1) 1/3 is in S > according to (i) \(\frac{1}{\frac{1}{3}}=3\) must also be in S. Sufficient. (1) 1 is in S > according to (i) \(\frac{1}{1}=1\) (another 1) must also be in S, then according to (ii) \(1+1=2\) must also be in S > \(1+2=3\) must also be in S. Sufficient. Answer: D. Hi Bunuel, If the answer is D then both the condition A & B should answer the question independently but you have use condition A & B together to answer the question. Is it right ? "(1) 1 is in S > according to (i) \(\frac{1}{1}=1\) (another 1) must also be in S, then according to (ii) \(1+1=2\) must also be in S > \(1+2=3\) must also be in S. Sufficient. " as per the condition B only one value is given So we can consider it either as X or as Y. Highlighted text above is a part of the stem, NOT the statements. The statements are below, (1) and (2).
_________________



Intern
Joined: 15 Apr 2017
Posts: 8

Re: The set S of numbers has the following properties
[#permalink]
Show Tags
15 Jul 2017, 03:15
This helped I had a similar doubt, thanks
Posted from my mobile device



Intern
Joined: 25 Mar 2016
Posts: 40
Location: India
Concentration: Finance, General Management
WE: Other (Other)

Re: The set S of numbers has the following properties
[#permalink]
Show Tags
16 Jul 2017, 04:47
Anandita04 wrote: This helped I had a similar doubt, thanks
Posted from my mobile device @Anindita04: Thanks for the clarification.



NonHuman User
Joined: 09 Sep 2013
Posts: 10981

Re: The set S of numbers has the following properties: I) If x
[#permalink]
Show Tags
27 Nov 2018, 01:20
Hello from the GMAT Club BumpBot! Thanks to another GMAT Club member, I have just discovered this valuable topic, yet it had no discussion for over a year. I am now bumping it up  doing my job. I think you may find it valuable (esp those replies with Kudos). Want to see all other topics I dig out? Follow me (click follow button on profile). You will receive a summary of all topics I bump in your profile area as well as via email.
_________________




Re: The set S of numbers has the following properties: I) If x
[#permalink]
27 Nov 2018, 01:20






