The 160 students at a certain high school must choose at least one sci

Question

The 160 students at a certain high school must choose at least one science course for the first semester. 110 choose to take chemistry and 70 choose to take physics. At least 15 students choose a different subject entirely—neither chemistry nor physics.

Using the information given, identify the minimum possible number of students who choose to take both chemistry and physics, and the maximum number of students who could take both. Make only two selections, one in each column.

Sajjad1994 · Accepted Answer

Official Explanation

This is an Overlapping Sets question. Initially, it might seem that there are three possible sets (physics chemistry, and some other unnamed subject). Because the problem is presented as choosing physics, chemistry, both, or neither, however, you can use a Double-Set Matrix to solve. You could also try to think through this type of problem logically—if you feel very comfortable with this type of math.

The at least language indicates that you will also have to use Maximize and Minimize principles in order to solve.

Logic

There are 160 students total, but at least 15 choose some other subject entirely, so at most 160 – 15 =145 students choose some combination of chemistry and physics.

The problem indicates that 110 choose chemistry and 70 choose physics, for an apparent total of 180 students. But since 145 is the actual maximum, at least 180 – 145 = 35 students must take both classes. This is the answer for the first column.

The problem states that a total of 70 students choose physics, so it can’t be the case that more than 70 take both chemistry and physics; eliminate answers 85 and 90. Since more students (110) take chemistry, it’s possible that all 70 students who take physics also take chemistry, so the maximum possible number of students who take both is 70. This is the answer for the second column.

Double-Set Matrix
Start by setting up the matrix with the information you are given as well as any additional information you can infer.

P    Not P    Total   
   C       110  
   Not C     ≥ 15  50  
   Total   70  90  160

The center box (neither chemistry nor physics) must have at least 15, but is there a top limit? Since 50 students do not take chemistry, there cannot be more than 50 students who take neither subject. The  “neither”  box, therefore, has a range of 15 to 50.

P    Not P    Total   
   C       110  
   Not C     15-50  50  
   Total   70  90  160

Using each end of that range, find the possible range of students who took both chemistry and physics. For instance, in the middle row (NOT C), take the difference between each end of the range in the middle column and the figure in the Total column. The difference between 15 and 50 is 35, and the difference between 50 and 50 is 0, so the range for the  “P but NOT C”  box is 0 to 35.

P    Not P    Total   
   C   35-70    110  
   Not C   0-35  15-50  50  
   Total   70  90  160

If “P but NOT C is 0 to 35, then “C and P” must have a range of 35 to 70, in order for the Total P box to equal 70.
Therefore, the minimum possible number of students who take both C and P is 35, while the maximum possible number of students who take both is 70.

Note: You can also solve by calculating the range for the  “C but NOT P”  box (that range is 40 to 75) and then finding the range for the  “C and P”  box (which would still be 35 to 70).

Column 1: The correct answer is (B).
Column 2: The correct answer is (D).

Sumi1010 · Answer

The provided information:
160 students take at least one science course .
110 chose to take Chemistry
70 chose to take Physics.
at least 15 took neither.

We can input these details in the table as below and try to vary   value from  15  to  minimum of {maximum  }  i.e. to ensure that sum of the column or row does accommodate the value.

We can't assign   more than 50, the minimum must be 15 as provided in the information.

Hence, we get the results of the field   as :

Minimum possible number of students who take both : 35
Maximum possible number of students who take both : 70

rocky620 · Answer

Total Students = TS = 160
Students who choose Chemistry = C = 110
Students who choose Physics = P = 70
Students who choose Other = Ot = 15 (minimum)
Students who choose Neither = N = 0 (as it is a mandate to choose atleast one subject)
Students who choose Chemistry & Physics = P&C = ?

Maximum Students who could have chosen P&C 
We need to see the minimum number of students who choose one of the two subjects. As that will be the maximum number of students who can choose both Chemistry & Physics.
So, it will be 70

Maximum Students who could have chosen P&C = 70

Minimum Students who could have chosen P&C 
We have to assume that the  Ot , 15 is maximum possible (will be explained below).

TS = C + P + Ot - C&P + N
160 = 110 + 70 + Ot - C&P + 0
C&P = 180 + Ot - 160
C&P = 20 + Ot (to minimize C&P Ot has to be minimized (as the value of Ot will increase the value of C&P will also increase. SO C&P will not be minimun in that case). In this case the minimum value of Ot can be 15.

So, C&P = 20 + 15 = 35

Maximum = 70
Minimum = 35

Deepakjhamb · Answer

Solution : IR Q1 Solution.png minimum possible number of students who choose to take both chemistry and physics from table 2 in attachment is 35 maximum possible number of students who choose to take both chemistry and physics from table 3 in attachment is 70

TarunKumar1234 · Answer

Given, Venn diagram,
n(c)= 110, n(p)=70, neither n or p >=15

We know that, n(cUp)= n(c) + n(p)- n(c⋂p)

For minimum n(c⋂p), when both sets are not overlapping or minimum overlapping 
So, neither n or p= minimum value = 15, n(cUp) = 160-15 = 145, but we have n(c)= 110, so, only n(p)=35 required and, n(c⋂p) =35

For maximum n(c⋂p), when both sets are 100% overlapping or maximum overlapping 
So, n(c⋂p) = n(p)= 70

Sajjad1994 · Answer

Hello Everyone!

This is a hard overlapping sets questions, everyone got it correct. OA is:

Minimum possible number of students who take both: 35
Maximum possible number of students who take both: 70

Excellent work done by  Sumi1010  and  Deepakjhamb

OE will be posted soon.

Thank you

bumpbot · Answer

Hello from the GMAT Club BumpBot!

Thanks to another GMAT Club member, I have just discovered this valuable topic, yet it had no discussion for over a year. I am now bumping it up - doing my job. I think you may find it valuable (esp those replies with Kudos).

Want to see all other topics I dig out? Follow me (click follow button on profile). You will receive a summary of all topics I bump in your profile area as well as via email.

The 160 students at a certain high school must choose at least one sci

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

Minimum possible number of students who take both	Maximum possible number of students who take both	Number
		20
		35
		40
		70
		85
		90

GMAT Two-part Analysis (TPA) Questions

The 160 students at a certain high school must choose at least one sci

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards