It is conventional among devotees of orchestral music to view the Germ

Question

It is conventional among devotees of orchestral music to view the German composer Ludwig van Beethoven (1770–1827) as the first great Romantic composer. He emerged as a musical luminary during the first fermentation of the Romantic movement, at a time when Goethe, Schiller, and Shelley were introducing new concepts of heroic genius and individuality into the bubbling pot of European culture. Beethoven adapted these themes for his music; indeed, it is difficult to identify a greater musical statement of the Romantic concept of individual genius than Beethoven’s Eroica (1806). Contemporary critics such as Spohr and Hoffman considered Beethoven to be a torchbearer of Romanticism.

Many music fans would be shocked, therefore, to learn that many musicologists view Beethoven as primarily a figure of the late-Classical era, and not really a Romantic at all. This difference of opinion is due in part to the fact that musicologists generally place the beginning of the “Romantic era” at a later date than do scholars of literature and cultural history; while Beethoven was clearly a contemporary of the early Romantic poets, the peak of his career predates by some years the full emergence of Romanticism in music. From a philosophical standpoint, Beethoven’s adherence to the ideals of the Enlightenment connects him with Classicism, an aesthetic movement with which those ideals are inextricably linked.

The most sensible analysis of Beethoven’s musical legacy is that he was a part of both the Classical and Romantic eras in music, and that he was, in fact, the pivotal transitional figure between these periods. Beethoven’s early works, for example his first two symphonies and the early sonatas, show the devotion to order and the intricate development of a theme that we associate with Classical composers such as Mozart or Haydn. His middle and later works, however, demonstrate and in some cases invent many of the hallmarks of Romantic music: the expansion of a symphony from four to five movements; the unification of the movements of a symphony around a motto theme; the addition of a chorus; the adaptation of folk motifs; the innovation of song cycles. The real question is not so much whether Beethoven was a Classical or Romantic composer, but rather what were the factors that changed him from a Classical composer to a Romantic?    1 
 1. From the information presented in the passage, it can most accurately be inferred that the author believes which of the following about Ludwig van Beethoven?

A. Rather than labeling Beethoven as either Classical or Romantic, it would be more accurate to describe him as a product of the Baroque era.
B. The clear references to the works of Goethe in Beethoven’s music prove that he was a Romantic composer.
C. Literary historians generally place the beginning of the Romantic movement at an earlier date than do musicologists.
D. Beethoven was a more prolific composer than either Mozart or Haydn.
E. The term “Romantic” is inadequate to describe the entirety of Beethoven’s career.

2 
 2. Which of the following best describes the structure of the passage?

A. A traditional view is described, an alternative point of view is presented, followed by a synthesis of the two viewpoints.
B. A theory is put forth about a composer, followed by two distinct, alternative theories.
C. A conventional viewpoint is described, an argument against this viewpoint of offered, and additional evidence is offered in support of the second argument.
D. A new hypothesis is put forth, a criticism of that hypothesis is presented, followed by evidence in favor of that hypothesis.
E. A question is posed, followed by opposing answers to that question.

3 
 3. According to the information presented in the passage, the critics Spohr and Hoffman would be most likely to agree with which of the following statements about Beethoven?

A. Beethoven is the primary poetic genius of the Romantic era.
B. Beethoven’s musical work has benefited from his friendship with his fellow German Romantics Goethe and Schiller.
C. One would be hard pressed to find a greater statement of the aesthetic ideals of Romanticism than in the intricate themes of Beethoven’s first symphony.
D. Beethoven’s symphonies provide a symphonic articulation of the Romantic ideals of heroic genius and individuality.
E. Beethoven’s adaptation of folk motifs is his greatest contribution to European music.

4 
 4. Which of the following, if true, would provide the strongest support for those who contend that Beethoven was a Classical, rather than a Romantic, composer?

A. Beethoven’s 9th symphony (1824), his last, includes a chorus in the fifth movement.
B. Beethoven’s 8th symphony (1814), produced late in his career, shows an orderliness that many have compared to the works of his former teacher, Haydn.
C. Beethoven’s 6th symphony, “Pastoral” (1808), is composed of five movements unified around a peaceful motto derived from the sounds of nature.
D. Beethoven’s only opera, Fidelio (1814), is concerned with the role of individual heroism in the struggle for political liberty.
E. The Adagio movement of Beethoven’s piano sonata no. 8, “Pathetique” (1799), ends on one of the composer’s most memorable codas, which contains elements common to both Classical and Romantic music.

GMAT Club's Reading Comprehension (RC) Quiz-I 2023   
   10 Days | 20 Passages | Win Prizes | Get Better at GMAT   
 Passage # 12  |  Date: 06 March 2023 
 Click here for more details and master thread

Oppenheimer1945 · Answer

1. From the information presented in the passage, it can most accurately be inferred that the author believes which of the following about Ludwig van Beethoven?

A. Rather than labeling Beethoven as either Classical or Romantic, it would be more accurate to describe him as a product of the Baroque era.
B. The clear references to the works of Goethe in Beethoven’s music prove that he was a Romantic composer.
 C. Literary historians generally place the beginning of the Romantic movement at an earlier date than do musicologists.(True) 
D. Beethoven was a more prolific composer than either Mozart or Haydn.
E. The term “Romantic” is inadequate to describe the entirety of Beethoven’s career.

The inverse of below statement is required:
The fact that musicologists generally place the beginning of the “Romantic era” at a later date than do scholars of literature and cultural history
The scholars of literature and cultural history place the beginning of the “Romantic era” at an earlier date

2. Which of the following best describes the structure of the passage?

A. A traditional view is described, an alternative point of view is presented, followed by a synthesis of the two viewpoints.
(True. ) 
 P1- states a view of Ludwig van Beethoven (1770–1827) as the first great Romantic composer.
P2- gives alternate view and connects him with Classicism,
P3 -mixes both views : the pivotal transitional figure between these periods -both classical and romantic.)
) 
B. A theory is put forth about a composer, followed by two distinct, alternative theories.
(P3= P1+P3)
C. A conventional viewpoint is described, an argument against this viewpoint of offered, and additional evidence is offered in support of the second argument.
(No additional evidence is stated in P3)
D. A new hypothesis is put forth, a criticism of that hypothesis is presented, followed by evidence in favor of that hypothesis.
(P1- is not a new hypothesis)
E. A question is posed, followed by opposing answers to that question.
(No question is posed in P1)

3. According to the information presented in the passage, the critics Spohr and Hoffman would be most likely to agree with which of the following statements about Beethoven?

A. Beethoven is the primary poetic genius of the Romantic era. (True) 
B. Beethoven’s musical work has benefited from his friendship with his fellow German Romantics Goethe and Schiller.
C. One would be hard pressed to find a greater statement of the aesthetic ideals of Romanticism than in the intricate themes of Beethoven’s first symphony.
D. Beethoven’s symphonies provide a symphonic articulation of the Romantic ideals of heroic genius and individuality.
E. Beethoven’s adaptation of folk motifs is his greatest contribution to European music.

Contemporary critics such as Spohr and Hoffman considered Beethoven to be a torchbearer of Romanticism.
 
4. Which of the following, if true, would provide the strongest support for those who contend that Beethoven was a Classical, rather than a Romantic, composer?

A. Beethoven’s 9th symphony (1824), his last, includes a chorus in the fifth movement. 
(chorus = romantic)
 B. Beethoven’s 8th symphony (1814), produced late in his career, shows an orderliness that many have compared to the works of his former teacher, Haydn. 
 (True: His middle and later works, however, demonstrate and in  some  cases invent many of the hallmarks of Romantic music)
Beethoven’s early works, for example his first two symphonies and the early sonatas, show the devotion to order and the intricate development of a theme that we associate with Classical composers such as Mozart or Haydn
 
C. Beethoven’s 6th symphony, “Pastoral” (1808), is composed of five movements unified around a peaceful motto derived from the sounds of nature.
(not mentioned anywhere in passage)
D. Beethoven’s only opera, Fidelio (1814), is concerned with the role of individual heroism in the struggle for political liberty. (not mentioned anywhere in passage)
E. The Adagio movement of Beethoven’s piano sonata no. 8, “Pathetique” (1799), ends on one of the composer’s most memorable codas, which contains elements common to both Classical and Romantic music.
(codas contain elements common to both Classical and Romantic music)

$!vakumar.m · Answer

1. From the information presented in the passage, it can most accurately be inferred that the author believes which of the following about Ludwig van Beethoven?

A. Rather than labeling Beethoven as either Classical or Romantic, it would be more accurate to describe him as a product of the Baroque era.  
Option A is incorrect because the author has not mentioned anything about Baroque era.

B. The clear references to the works of Goethe in Beethoven’s music prove that he was a Romantic composer.  
The author refers to the works of Goethe in Beethoven’s music to show that LVB was emerging as a musical luminary in romantic music. But subsequently in second and third paragraph he brings out how LVB was a figure of late classical music era. The author believes that LVB was the pivotal transitional figure between these periods. Option B is incorrect.

C. Literary historians generally place the beginning of the Romantic movement at an earlier date than do musicologists.  
Though it is mentioned that musicologists generally place the beginning of the “Romantic era” at a later date than do scholars of literature and cultural history, but this does not brings out – what the author thinks about LVB. Option C is incorrect.

D. Beethoven was a more prolific composer than either Mozart or Haydn.  
No such comparison has been made.

E. The term “Romantic” is inadequate to describe the entirety of Beethoven’s career.  
True. Para 3 - The most sensible analysis of Beethoven’s musical legacy is that he was a part of both the Classical and Romantic eras in music, and that he was, in fact, the pivotal transitional figure between these periods. Also, the author’s concluding remarks clearly says that LVB can’t be only associated with Romantic music.

2. Which of the following best describes the structure of the passage? 
The author first describes the traditional view of how LVB was considered as the first great Romantic composer/ torchbearer of Romanticism by the devotees of orchestral music and Contemporary critics. In the second paragraph, he presents the alternate view of musicologists who regard Beethoven as primarily a figure of the late-Classical era. Lastly, the author presents his own analysis of Beethoven’s musical legacy which synthesizes the two viewpoints. The author considers LVB to be the pivotal transitional figure between these two periods.   Therefore, option A is correct .

4. Which of the following, if true, would provide the strongest support for those who contend that Beethoven was a Classical, rather than a Romantic, composer?

A. Beethoven’s 9th symphony (1824), his last, includes a chorus in the fifth movement.  
Option A is incorrect because chorus and five symphony movements are associated with romantic music.

B. Beethoven’s 8th symphony (1814), produced late in his career, shows an orderliness that many have compared to the works of his former teacher, Haydn.  
It is stated in the third paragraph that Beethoven’s early works, for example his first two symphonies and the early sonatas, show the devotion to order and the intricate development of a theme that we associate with Classical composers such as Mozart or Haydn. If option B is true then it provides the strongest support for Beethoven to be a Classical composer.

C. Beethoven’s 6th symphony, “Pastoral” (1808), is composed of five movements unified around a peaceful motto derived from the sounds of nature.  
Option C is incorrect because five movements and the unification of the movements of a symphony around a motto theme is associated with romantic music.

D. Beethoven’s only opera, Fidelio (1814), is concerned with the role of individual heroism in the struggle for political liberty.  
Option D is incorrect because themes of individual heroism is associated with romantic music.

E. The Adagio movement of Beethoven’s piano sonata no. 8, “Pathetique” (1799), ends on one of the composer’s most memorable codas, which contains elements common to both Classical and Romantic music.  
Option E is incorrect because it provides support for Beethoven to be both Classical and Romantic composer.

Elite097 · Answer

1. From the information presented in the passage, it can most accurately be inferred that the author believes which of the following about Ludwig van Beethoven?

A. Rather than labeling Beethoven as either Classical or Romantic, it would be more accurate to describe him as a product of the Baroque era.
No mention of baoque era is made in the passage

B. The clear references to the works of Goethe in Beethoven’s music prove that he was a Romantic composer.
References to Goethe or composition of Beethoven's work has not been discussed, other than the theme of his work.

C. Literary historians generally place the beginning of the Romantic movement at an earlier date than do musicologists.
This is a true statement however question asks for inference about Beethoven and this is about Romantic movement

D. Beethoven was a more prolific composer than either Mozart or Haydn.
No such comparison has been drawn. Its only mentioned that he followed same theme as Haydn

E. The term “Romantic” is inadequate to describe the entirety of Beethoven’s career.
 True. The 2nd and last paras also link his career to Classic work hence true
 
Ans E

2. Which of the following best describes the structure of the passage?

The first passage is around the theme of Romanticism which is the conventional view: "It is conventional among devotees of orchestral music to view the German composer Ludwig van Beethoven (1770–1827) as the first great Romantic composer"
The second para then justifies as to why it would be surprising for him not be considered a Romantic and another view as Classicism has been intrduced "From a philosophical standpoint, Beethoven’s adherence to the ideals of the Enlightenment connects him with Classicism, "
Last para combines both views and relates his work as a combination of the two views: "The most sensible analysis of Beethoven’s musical legacy is that he was a part of both the Classical and Romantic eras in music"

A. A traditional view is described, an alternative point of view is presented, followed by a synthesis of the two viewpoints
 View - Romanticism, then focus is on relating his work to Classicism, then the viewpoints on romanticism and classicism are combined
 
B. A theory is put forth about a composer, followed by two distinct, alternative theories
There are only 2 distinct theories but they are not alternate to the theory in the first para. Also this does not identify with the structure defined above

C. A conventional viewpoint is described, an argument against this viewpoint of offered, and additional evidence is offered in support of the second argument
Argument against this viewpoint is wrong as only an alternative has been suggested. Additional evidence has not been offered for argument against the viewpoint

D. A new hypothesis is put forth, a criticism of that hypothesis is presented, followed by evidence in favor of that hypothesis.
Criticism of the Romantic viewpoint is not done anywhere. EVidence in favor of Romanticism is presented but that does not give a complete picture of the structure

E. A question is posed, followed by opposing answers to that question.
No question is posed and no opposition has been made.

Ans A

3. According to the information presented in the passage, the critics Spohr and Hoffman would be most likely to agree with which of the following statements about Beethoven?

A. Beethoven is the primary poetic genius of the Romantic era
 Directly stated: "Contemporary critics such as Spohr and Hoffman considered Beethoven to be a torchbearer of Romanticism."
 
B. Beethoven’s musical work has benefited from his friendship with his fellow German Romantics Goethe and Schiller
Nothing has been mentioned about the role of friendship.

C. One would be hard pressed to find a greater statement of the aesthetic ideals of Romanticism than in the intricate themes of Beethoven’s first symphony
This was not mentioned in the context of Hoffman; critics were stated after this statement

D. Beethoven’s symphonies provide a symphonic articulation of the Romantic ideals of heroic genius and individuality.
This has not been mentioned specifically in the context of Hoffman.

E. Beethoven’s adaptation of folk motifs is his greatest contribution to European music.
This has not been mentioned specifically in the context of Hoffman and is brought up in last para as a general description

Ans A

4. Which of the following, if true, would provide the strongest support for those who contend that Beethoven was a Classical, rather than a Romantic, composer?

A. Beethoven’s 9th symphony (1824), his last, includes a chorus in the fifth movement
"demonstrate and in some cases invent many of the hallmarks of Romantic music: the expansion of a symphony from four to five movements" relates this choice to romanticism

B. Beethoven’s 8th symphony (1814), produced late in his career, shows an orderliness that many have compared to the works of his former teacher, Haydn.
 "show the devotion to order and the intricate development of a theme that we associate with Classical composers such as Mozart or Haydn" is associated with Classical
 
C. Beethoven’s 6th symphony, “Pastoral” (1808), is composed of five movements unified around a peaceful motto derived from the sounds of nature
"demonstrate and in some cases invent many of the hallmarks of Romantic music: the expansion of a symphony from four to five movements" relates this choice to romanticism

D. Beethoven’s only opera, Fidelio (1814), is concerned with the role of individual heroism in the struggle for political liberty
"Romantic concept of individual genius" indicates this concept is related to romanticism

E. The Adagio movement of Beethoven’s piano sonata no. 8, “Pathetique” (1799), ends on one of the composer’s most memorable codas, which contains elements common to both Classical and Romantic music
Combines both romantic and classical perspectives

Ans B

pintukr · Answer

1. From the information presented in the passage, it can most accurately be inferred that the author believes which of the following about Ludwig van Beethoven?

A. Rather than labeling Beethoven as either Classical or Romantic, it would be more accurate to describe him as a product of the Baroque era.
Baroque era has not been dealt within the passage

B. The clear references to the works of Goethe in Beethoven’s music prove that he was a Romantic composer.
concepts drawn from works of Goethe,,doesn't ascertain whether beethoven was a Romantic composer

C. Literary historians generally place the beginning of the Romantic movement at an earlier date than do musicologists.
Lines 5 to 8 of paragraph 5 highlighting 'musicologists generally place the beginning of the “Romantic era” at a later date than do scholars of literature and cultural history' lend significant credence to this promt..CORRECT answer

D. Beethoven was a more prolific composer than either Mozart or Haydn.
can't be ascertained using the facts presented in the passage

E. The term “Romantic” is inadequate to describe the entirety of Beethoven’s career.
the author highlights that Beethoven's career primarily revolved around depicting Romanticism in the musical works

2. Which of the following best describes the structure of the passage?

A. A traditional view is described, an alternative point of view is presented, followed by a synthesis of the two viewpoints.
  correctly listed in the order of emphasis presented in paragraphs 1. 2 and 3 , respectively...CORRECT answer

B. A theory is put forth about a composer, followed by two distinct, alternative theories.
 not True, since the 3rd paragraph is mainly a synthesis of the two theories presented in paragraphs 1 & 2

C. A conventional viewpoint is described, an argument against this viewpoint of offered, and additional evidence is offered in support of the second argument.
 the 3rd paragraph doesn't provide additional evidence, rather it is mainly a synthesis of the two theories presented in paragraphs 1 & 2

D. A new hypothesis is put forth, a criticism of that hypothesis is presented, followed by evidence in favour of that hypothesis.
 no criticism of a particular hypothesis is presented in the passage

E. A question is posed, followed by opposing answers to that question.
 There are no opposing answers to Beethoven's nature of works --whether Romantic or Classical. Rather, a synthesis of the two is presented.

3. According to the information presented in the passage, the critics Spohr and Hoffman would be most likely to agree with which of the following statements about Beethoven?

A. Beethoven is the primary poetic genius of the Romantic era.
  Lines 11-12 of paragraph 1 highlight that the Contemporary critics such as Spohr and Hoffman considered Beethoven to be a torchbearer of Romanticism..clearly in line with the prompt...CORRECT answer

B. Beethoven’s musical work has benefited from his friendship with his fellow German Romantics Goethe and Schiller.
 no such conclusions can be drawn

C. One would be hard pressed to find a greater statement of the aesthetic ideals of Romanticism than in the intricate themes of Beethoven’s first symphony.
 While aesthetic ideals of Romanticism may be reflected in Beethoven's later works, the Classicism may be found in the themes of Beethoven’s first symphony.

D. Beethoven’s symphonies provide a symphonic articulation of the Romantic ideals of heroic genius and individuality.
 not the view of the critics Spohr and Hoffman

E. Beethoven’s adaptation of folk motifs is his greatest contribution to European music.
 No such facts have been presented in the passage

4. Which of the following, if true, would provide the strongest support for those who contend that Beethoven was a Classical, rather than a Romantic, composer?

A. Beethoven’s 9th symphony (1824), his last, includes a chorus in the fifth movement.
 chorus in the fifth movement -- Romantic orientation ..doesn't lend credence to the contention that Beethoven was a Classical poet

B. Beethoven’s 8th symphony (1814), produced late in his career, shows an orderliness that many have compared to the works of his former teacher, Haydn.
  If Beethoven’s 8th symphony (1814), produced late in his career, is associated with Haydn, a Classical poet, it will p

C. Beethoven’s 6th symphony, “Pastoral” (1808), is composed of five movements unified around a peaceful motto derived from the sounds of nature.
 no clarity regarding Classical or Romatic can be drawn

D. Beethoven’s only opera, Fidelio (1814), is concerned with the role of individual heroism in the struggle for political liberty.
 Irrelevant prompt, since individual heroism in the struggle for political liberty for the only opera will not provide hints regarding Beethoven's orientation

E. The Adagio movement of Beethoven’s piano sonata no. 8, “Pathetique” (1799), ends on one of the composer’s most memorable codas, which contains elements common to both Classical and Romantic music.
 'elements common to both Classical and Romantic music' -- no clarity regarding Beethoven's orientation

The correct sequence of answers will be CAAB

Catman · Answer

1. From the information presented in the passage, it can most accurately be inferred that the author believes which of the following about Ludwig van Beethoven?

A. Rather than labeling Beethoven as either Classical or Romantic, it would be more accurate to describe him as a product of the Baroque era.  ~ Incorrect, there is no mention of the Baroque era.

B. The clear references to the works of Goethe in Beethoven’s music prove that he was a Romantic composer.  ~ Incorrect, this was mentioned that he adapted their themes and write romantic concept.

C. Literary historians generally place the beginning of the Romantic movement at an earlier date than do musicologists.  ~ InCorrect, refer to the line "This difference of opinion is due in part to the fact that musicologists generally place the beginning of the “Romantic era” at a later date than do scholars of literature and cultural history;" It is the view of musicologist and not neccessarily the view of the author.

D. Beethoven was a more prolific composer than either Mozart or Haydn.  ~ Incorrect, beethoven is not mentioned more prolific than Mozart or Haydn refer to the line "show the devotion to order and the intricate development of a theme that we associate with Classical composers such as Mozart or Haydn".

E. The term “Romantic” is inadequate to describe the entirety of Beethoven’s career.  ~Correct, author describe that it will be inadequate to classify Beethoven as Romantic, he says that "The most sensible analysis of Beethoven’s musical legacy is that he was a part of both the Classical and Romantic eras in music."

2.Which of the following best describes the structure of the passage?

A. A traditional view is described, an alternative point of view is presented, followed by a synthesis of the two viewpoints.  ~ Correct, author agrees that he was part of both the view, refer to the line "The most sensible analysis of Beethoven’s musical legacy is that he was a part of both the Classical and Romantic eras in music, and that he was."

B. A theory is put forth about a composer, followed by two distinct, alternative theories.  ~ Incorrect, no theory is discussed, point of view of is discussed.

C. A conventional viewpoint is described, an argument against this viewpoint of offered, and additional evidence is offered in support of the second argument. ~  Incorrect, author does not agree with the second argument, in-fact author mentions that both exist simultaneously.

D. A new hypothesis is put forth, a criticism of that hypothesis is presented, followed by evidence in favor of that hypothesis.  ~ Incorrect, author is not criticising the hypothesis that is presented.

E. A question is posed, followed by opposing answers to that question.  ~ Incorrect, although question is asked that whether Beethoven is romantic or classist but later these two views are merged.

4. Which of the following, if true, would provide the strongest support for those who contend that Beethoven was a Classical, rather than a Romantic, composer?

A. Beethoven’s 9th symphony (1824), his last, includes a chorus in the fifth movement.  ~ Incorrect, Refer to the line "the expansion of a symphony from four to five movements;" this is related as hallmark of romantic music.

B. Beethoven’s 8th symphony (1814), produced late in his career, shows an orderliness that many have compared to the works of his former teacher, Haydn.  ~ Correct, refer to the line "show the devotion to order and the intricate development of a theme that we associate with Classical composers such as Mozart or Haydn."

C. Beethoven’s 6th symphony, “Pastoral” (1808), is composed of five movements unified around a peaceful motto derived from the sounds of nature.  ~Incorrect , refer to the line "the unification of the movements of a symphony around a motto theme" this is related as hallmark of romantic music.

D. Beethoven’s only opera, Fidelio (1814), is concerned with the role of individual heroism in the struggle for political liberty.  ~ Incorrect, refer to the line "Shelley were introducing new concepts of heroic genius and individuality into the bubbling pot of European culture. Beethoven adapted these themes for his music; indeed, it is difficult to identify a greater musical statement of the Romantic concept."

E. The Adagio movement of Beethoven’s piano sonata no. 8, “Pathetique” (1799), ends on one of the composer’s most memorable codas, which contains elements common to both Classical and Romantic music.  ~ Incorrect, refer to the line " the unification of the movements of a symphony around a motto theme ".

Sajjad1994 · Answer

Hello Everyone!

OAs are revealed

EADB

Competition mode is off now.

Good work done by  sivakumarm786  and Elite097

OE will be posted tomorrow morning.

Good luck with Day 7 passages.

Cheers

Sajjad1994 · Answer

Official Explanation

1. From the information presented in the passage, it can most accurately be inferred that the author believes which of the following about Ludwig van Beethoven?

Explanation

The passage explains that while many view Beethoven as the first great Romantic composer, musicologists often view him primarily as a figure of the late-Classical era. The author suggests that Beethoven's legacy is best understood as a pivotal transitional figure between the two periods, and that he incorporated both Classical and Romantic elements in his music. Therefore, the author believes that the term  "Romantic"  is inadequate to describe the entirety of Beethoven's career. Therefore, the correct answer is  E .

Answer: E

Sajjad1994 · Answer

Explanation

2. Which of the following best describes the structure of the passage?

Explanation

The structure of the passage is best described as:

A. A traditional view is described, an alternative point of view is presented, followed by a synthesis of the two viewpoints.

The passage begins by describing the conventional view that Beethoven is considered the first great Romantic composer, followed by an alternative point of view presented by musicologists who view Beethoven primarily as a figure of the late-Classical era. The passage then presents a synthesis of the two viewpoints, arguing that Beethoven was a part of both the Classical and Romantic eras in music and the pivotal transitional figure between these periods. The passage ends with a question about what factors changed Beethoven from a Classical composer to a Romantic. Therefore, option A is the most appropriate description of the passage's structure.

Answer: A

Sajjad1994 · Answer

Explanation

3. According to the information presented in the passage, the critics Spohr and Hoffman would be most likely to agree with which of the following statements about Beethoven?

Explanation

The passage discusses the different ways in which musicologists and critics view Beethoven's place in musical history. While many critics consider Beethoven a torchbearer of Romanticism, some musicologists view him as primarily a figure of the late-Classical era. However, the passage argues that Beethoven's musical legacy is best understood as a transitional figure between the Classical and Romantic eras. Based on this information, we can infer that Spohr and Hoffman, who are mentioned as contemporary critics who considered Beethoven a torchbearer of Romanticism, would most likely agree with the statement that:

D. Beethoven’s symphonies provide a symphonic articulation of the Romantic ideals of heroic genius and individuality.

This statement aligns with the idea that Beethoven adapted the Romantic concepts of heroic genius and individuality for his music, and that his symphonies reflect these ideals. Therefore,  option D  is the correct answer.

Option A  is incorrect because while Beethoven is considered a great composer of the Romantic era, the passage does not suggest that he is the primary poetic genius of the Romantic era.

Option B  is incorrect because the passage does not mention Beethoven's friendship with Goethe and Schiller.

Option C  is incorrect because the passage does not suggest that Beethoven's first symphony represents the aesthetic ideals of Romanticism.

Option E  is incorrect because while the passage mentions Beethoven's adaptation of folk motifs as one of the hallmarks of Romantic music, it does not suggest that this was his greatest contribution to European music.

Answer: D

Sajjad1994 · Answer

Explanation

4. Which of the following, if true, would provide the strongest support for those who contend that Beethoven was a Classical, rather than a Romantic, composer?

Explanation

The passage argues that while Beethoven is often viewed as a Romantic composer, many musicologists consider him to be primarily a figure of the late-Classical era due to his adherence to the ideals of the Enlightenment. The author suggests that the most sensible analysis is that Beethoven was a transitional figure between the Classical and Romantic eras in music. The question asks which of the following statements would provide the strongest support for the contention that Beethoven was a Classical, rather than a Romantic, composer.

Option A  describes Beethoven's 9th symphony, which includes a chorus in the fifth movement. However, this fact does not clearly support the idea that Beethoven was a Classical composer rather than a Romantic one.

Option B  notes that Beethoven's 8th symphony shows an orderliness that many have compared to the works of his former teacher, Haydn. This suggests that Beethoven's work in his later career maintained some of the characteristics associated with Classical music. Therefore, this statement provides the strongest support for those who contend that Beethoven was a Classical composer rather than a Romantic one.

Option C  describes Beethoven's 6th symphony,  "Pastoral,"  which is composed of five movements unified around a peaceful motto derived from the sounds of nature. This statement suggests that Beethoven was capable of creating works that had elements associated with Romantic music, making it difficult to argue that he was exclusively a Classical composer.

Option D  describes Beethoven's only opera, Fidelio, which is concerned with the role of individual heroism in the struggle for political liberty. This fact does not provide support for either the contention that Beethoven was a Classical or a Romantic composer.

Option E  notes that the Adagio movement of Beethoven's piano sonata no. 8,  "Pathetique,"  ends on a memorable coda that contains elements common to both Classical and Romantic music. This statement suggests that Beethoven's work had characteristics associated with both Classical and Romantic music, making it difficult to argue that he was exclusively a Classical composer.

Answer: B

Elite097 · Answer

Sajjad1994  why not A? It is not clear

Sajjad1994 · Answer

Keep in mind one thing for this question

We have to answer the question with respect to critics Spohr and Hoffman, what they most like agree.

The passage states that contemporary critics such as Spohr and Hoffman considered Beethoven to be a torchbearer of Romanticism.

A  is incorrect because the passage does mention that Beethoven's music reflects the Romantic concept of individual genius, it does not suggest that he is the primary poetic genius of the Romantic era.

C  is incorrect because the passage mentions that Beethoven's first two symphonies and early sonatas show the devotion to order and intricate development of a theme that we associate with Classical composers, not the aesthetic ideals of Romanticism.

Only C seems to the second best after the OA D

Answer: D

nityabhasin · Answer

Hi  Sajjad1994 , The passage mentions Beethoven as the torchbearer then how can we say he was not the primary poet of romanticism?

Sajjad1994 · Answer

Which question you are referring to?

It is conventional among devotees of orchestral music to view the Germ

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

GMAT Reading Comprehension (RC) Questions

It is conventional among devotees of orchestral music to view the Germ

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards