Those who condemn the governor for being unsympathetic to the plight

Question

Those who condemn the governor for being unsympathetic to the plight of the automobile industry are merely using that allegation as a smokescreen for their own partisan politics. The citizen who believes their charges fails to realize that a politician may sometimes appear to be lacking compassion for a special interest group when, in reality, she is just trying to implement a public policy that is beneficial to great numbers of people representing diverse interests.

Which of the following, if true, provides the greatest support for the assertion made in the first sentence of the passage?

A) Sometimes it is difficult to distinguish between insensitivity to special interest groups and public-spirited devotion to broader concerns

B) Some of the governor's harshest critics are members of automobile workers' unions and politicians with strong ties to the automotive industry.

C) Many people who accuse the governor of being unsympathetic to the plight of the automobile industry voted for her in the last election.

D) The governor is not a politician who makes a clear distinction between partisan politics and civic responsibility.

E) Sometimes a politician who is insensitive to the concerns of a minority group believes that he or she is acting in the community's best interest.

Those who condemn the governor for being unsympathetic to the plight of the automobile industry are merely using that allegation as a smokescreen for their own partisan politics.The citizen who believes their charges fails to realize that a politician may sometimes appear to be lacking compassion for a special interest group when, in reality, she is just trying to implement a public policy that is beneficial to great   numbers   of people representing diverse interests.

Which of the foll ,if true,provides the greatest support for the assertion?

a) Sometimes,it is difficult to distinguish between insensitivity to special interest grps & public spirited devotion to broader concerns.

b)some of the governor's harshest critics are members of the automobile workers' unions and & politics with strong ties in the automotive industry.

c) Sometimes a politician who is insensitive to the concerns of a minority grp believes that he/she is acting in the community's best interests.

answers ?

source : kaplan GMAT CAT 1

By the way,I feel that 'to great   numbers   of people representing diverse interests' is wrong.Isn't 'numbers of' wrong on GMAT?

Thanks.

regards,

amit2k9 · Answer

Between A and C, C disguises automobile group as a minority group.Also, the argument talks about a citizen and his/her opinion rather than a politician and his deeds.

A prevails.

Injuin · Answer

OA is B though. The assertion was that "Those who condemn the governor for being unsympathetic to the plight of the automobile industry are merely using that allegation as a smokescreen for their own partisan politics". So basically the people condemning the governor are only doing so because of their own politics. The second sentence has nothing to do with the assertion.

Aviral1995 · Answer

VeritasKarishma   GMATNinja   nightblade354  could you please explain how to chose b/w b and c?

Gunika16 · Answer

Hello Aviral1995 , My 2 cents: As mentioned in the question we just need to focus on the first sentence of the question stimulus. And the first sentence asserts that detractors are leveling allegations on the politician for being unsympathetic since they have vested interests. It's like a ploy for them. And the question stem asks us to support this reasoning. Therefore, option B is a better option here because it clarifies why the politician's critiques are behaving that way. Because they belong to an interest group - members of the auto industry. Whereas, option C strays away from why the critics accuse the politicians and instead focuses on who voted for her in the first place, which is not really relevant to the question here. I hope this helps a little. I have just started learning and so thought of sharing what I could make out of it.

Kindly excuse if my explanation has confused you further.

ShankSouljaBoi · Answer

E is a reworded version of the second sentence. No new information provided.

B is the winner. All others are irrelevant.

Posted from my mobile device

Elite097 · Answer

The passage argues that accusations against the governor for being unsympathetic to the automobile industry are a "smokescreen" for partisan politics. The task is to identify the statement that most strongly supports this claim.

Why not C?
C states: "Many people who accuse the governor of being unsympathetic to the plight of the automobile industry voted for her in the last election."
While this information is interesting, it does not directly support the claim that the accusations are a "smokescreen for partisan politics." The fact that these individuals voted for the governor in the past says nothing about whether their current criticism is motivated by partisan politics or genuine concern for the automobile industry. It might even weaken the claim of partisanship because it suggests that the critics were not always opposed to the governor.

Why B is correct:
B states: "Some of the governor's harshest critics are members of automobile workers' unions and politicians with strong ties to the automotive industry."
This directly supports the assertion in the first sentence that the criticism is politically motivated. If the critics have strong ties to the automobile industry, their criticism is likely influenced by self-interest or partisan politics, aligning with the "smokescreen" argument in the passage.

Why the other options are wrong:
A: "Sometimes it is difficult to distinguish between insensitivity to special interest groups and public-spirited devotion to broader concerns."

This is a general observation and does not specifically support the claim about the governor's critics being politically motivated.
D: "The governor is not a politician who makes a clear distinction between partisan politics and civic responsibility."

This weakens the argument by suggesting that the governor herself might be engaging in partisan politics, which is not the focus of the passage.
E: "Sometimes a politician who is insensitive to the concerns of a minority group believes that he or she is acting in the community's best interest."

This is another general observation and does not address whether the governor's critics are motivated by partisan politics.

Those who condemn the governor for being unsympathetic to the plight

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

GMAT Critical Reasoning (CR) Questions

Those who condemn the governor for being unsympathetic to the plight

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards