helpmehelpme
no but thats why i wasadvocating the ranking if scgiiks.. friendof mine last year ranked michigan #2, but didnt get a fellowship from them and then wasawarded #3 scholarship by Kenan Flagler at UNC
[/quote]
I have to stand corrected on the ranking.
I think it goes without saying but the Consortium is REALLY doing a disservice to its applicants by showing the Rankings to Adcoms
before they make their decisions.
Nevermind the fact that every school is worried about Yield, one of the most important things Adcoms are looking for is Fit. If you look at all the supplemental essays, almost every one asks "Why is our school the best for you" . The entire purpose for this supplemental essays is to show the Adcoms you REALLY want to go there. How effective is your essay, if the adcom had just saw you rank them as 2nd, 3rd, or whatever number "not your top choice" is? Every level you rank that school below 1 is a ding against your application.
For an organization thats focused on helping URMs, why does consortium put such a big obstacle for its applicant pool that no other applicant has to face?!
Whats more, CGSM representatives emphatically state (i've heard it at least three different times

) that the ranking do not matter for admissions. I actually convinced myself on this point (see comments above) by assuming that adcoms did not see the rankings

). I mean, I honestly could not see HOW an organization can be
so resolute about this stance unless they kept ranking information protected until AFTER admissions.
Apparently there is just some verbal agreement that adcoms are not
suppose to use the rankings to make an admit decisions.
That's a lot of hoping and dreaming, even for me! Every School says they take a holistic process. All else equal, why would they not consider the fact you put them #1 vs #3 into consideration.
Confounding the situation, most applicants change their minds about their favorite or 2nd favorite school as the process continues. Unfortunately, this absurd ranking process has in essence forced CGSM applicants to announce their decisions many months before any of their peers and, most importantly,
prior to adcom decisions.
I mean, can you imagine going to an interview and an adcom asking you "
So you say you really like our school, then why did you rank us #3?!"

I know they probably wont ask that (not sure if thats even better

), but you know they're thinking about it while you're waxing poetic about their campus, culture, and emphasis on blah blah blah!
For an organization that does so much right (and they do a LOT of good), the CGSM has put a completely unnecessary burden on its applicants. Assuming it can be fixed overnight by two IT guys and some bubble gum, why in the world does this ridiculousness continue?!