Addressing a solution to avoid or reduce events such as the recent sho

Question

Addressing a solution to avoid or reduce events such as the recent shooting in a school, the president blathered today to a bunch of congressmen about confining even those people who can be deemed potentially mentally unstable but have not committed a crime yet too in mental asylums.

Each of the following below, if true, weakens the assertion that throwing people who have been deemed mentally ill or are considered as potentials into state owned mental asylums will significantly reduce instances of shootings in schools EXCEPT:

(A) Out of the 133 acts of shooting in schools committed between 2010 and 2015, only one was committed by persons prohibited from owning arms due to severe mental illness.
(B) Fewer than 3 percent of the 133 acts of shooting in schools committed between 2010 and 2015 were committed by individuals against whom there were concerns that they were mentally unstable.
(C) Increasing the minimum age to possess guns is likely to have little effect since most shootings are done using firearms owned by shooter’s parents.
(D) A survey showed that people who are in the process of losing their minds or become mentally unstable are way less likely to hold a firearm, let alone discharge one, than a normal human being.
(E) More than ninety percent of the 133 acts of shooting committed in schools in the recent past have been committed in a well-planned manner by individuals whose psychiatric evaluation reports showed that they score better than an average human being.

wjy18300 · Answer

C must be one that has nothing to do with the weakening.

ravigupta2912 · Answer

Can someone explain this in detail? I absolutely did not get the logic for rejecting quite a few choices here.

Biswadip · Answer

Why not D? seems to be correct.
C is absolutely OFS.

mihirhmehta · Answer

Bunuel  can you please explain why C is the correct answer?

Soiay · Answer

D is clearly weakening the assertion because ac to it mentally unstable people are less likely to carry a firearm than normal human being. (Ac to question each and every mentally unstable person should be confined) 
C is totally out of the passage and it has nothing to do with the weakening hence C will be correct 
Hope it helps.

Posted from my mobile device

georgioskonst · Answer

This is a classic situation where you look for an irrelevant answer !

In this case C , is neither strengthening nor weakening, so is the right answer !

Vijaybrooks08 · Answer

If you review the incorrect options, you'll get the sense that maybe people who are mentally unstable aren't the ones who shoot people. Essentially, that weaken's the argument that these people should be locked up. Reason: Even if they are locked up, the number of shootings will not reduce.

However, C doesn't have any impact on the argument. This is the correct answer.

Shrutiv134 · Answer

could you please explain? I marked answer as D but it does not seem to be the right answer.

EnglishAgast · Answer

Hello  GMATNinja , C appears to be the OA. Pls could you help explain how other options can be eliminated? Thank you!

AnkitNandwani1 · Answer

To find the statement that does not weaken the assertion that confining mentally ill individuals or those considered potential threats to state-owned mental asylums will significantly reduce school shootings, we need to identify the one that either supports this assertion or is irrelevant.

Here is the evaluation of each option:

(A) Out of the 133 acts of shooting in schools committed between 2010 and 2015, only one was committed by persons prohibited from owning arms due to severe mental illness.  
This weakens the assertion because it suggests that very few school shootings are committed by individuals with severe mental illness who are already prohibited from owning firearms.

(B) Fewer than 3 percent of the 133 acts of shooting in schools committed between 2010 and 2015 were committed by individuals against whom there were concerns that they were mentally unstable.  
This weakens the assertion by indicating that concerns about mental instability were present in only a small percentage of cases, suggesting that targeting this group would not significantly reduce school shootings.

(C) Increasing the minimum age to possess guns is likely to have little effect since most shootings are done using firearms owned by shooter’s parents.  
This option is irrelevant to the assertion about confining mentally ill individuals because it addresses gun ownership laws rather than mental health confinement.

(D) A survey showed that people who are in the process of losing their minds or become mentally unstable are way less likely to hold a firearm, let alone discharge one, than a normal human being.  
This weakens the assertion because it indicates that mentally unstable individuals are less likely to use firearms.

(E) More than ninety percent of the 133 acts of shooting committed in schools in the recent past have been committed in a well-planned manner by individuals whose psychiatric evaluation reports showed that they score better than an average human being.  
This weakens the assertion by suggesting that most school shootings are committed by individuals who are not identified as mentally unstable through psychiatric evaluations.

Since (C) does not weaken the assertion about confining mentally ill individuals, it is the correct answer.

Addressing a solution to avoid or reduce events such as the recent sho

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

GMAT Critical Reasoning (CR) Questions

Addressing a solution to avoid or reduce events such as the recent sho

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards