S is a set containing a integers, where 0

Question

S is a set containing “a” integers, where 0<a<11. If the arithmetic mean of S is a positive integer “b”, which of the following CANNOT be the median of S?
A. 5a/11
B. -b
C.0
D. b
E. a/5

gmatophobia · Answer

In questions such as this, in which I have no clue on the best possible approach to enter the question, I start by eliminating the options. Using Answer choice elimination We can start with Option B, Option C or Option D. Let's start with Option B. Option B - Can "-b" be the median ? We know the average of the entire set is a positive integer “b”. So let's create a set placing -b at the center. We can add another term (say another value , -2b) to the left of -b. Now, to keep the set balanced at b, we can add a third term 6b to the right of the median. Set A therefore contains the following elements - S = { -2b, \quad -b, \quad +6b } So -b, can be the median of the set A. Eliminate option B. Option D - Can "b" be the median ? We were able to create a set in which the median of the set was -b, hence we can also create a set in which the median is b. We need not necessarily test out this scenario, however it's not a bad idea to do so. Let's start by placing b as the center of the set. We can add another term 2b to the right of b. Now, to keep the set balanced at b, we can add a third term 0 to the left of the median. Set A therefore contains the following elements - S = { 0, \quad +b, \quad +2b } So b, can be the median of the set. Eliminate option D. Option C - Can "0" be the median ? The steps remains the same. We start by placing 0 at the center, and let's add another term say -b to the left of 0. To keep the average at b. we can add a third 4b to the right of the median. Set A therefore contains the following elements - S = { -b, \quad 0, \quad +4b } So 0, can be the median of the set. Eliminate option C. At this stage there is a 50 - 50 chance. If I were running short of time I will select one of the remaining options and move on. 50% is not bad on a question that ends up taking a lot of time. However, if you've come this further, stay along the rest of the explanation

After we have eliminated , B, C and D. Let's pick up E as the option seems less complicated than A. Option E - Can "a/5" be the median ? We are free to choose any value of a as long as the value satisfies the condition 0

Option A

Theprince · Answer

if we consider just option a, we know any integer between 0 and 11 divided by 11 will give recurring numbers and median of any set of integers will have 2 solutions
1. if total no of integers are even then median has to be integer 
2. if total no of integers are odd then it will be a+b/2 and this will never be recurring no.
so option A.

Giallo12 · Answer

Answer A is the right answer, due to the fact that simply the interval of "a" is defined for: 0<a<11, so then 11, being an extreme of such interval is excluded from it and from the possible values of the median too.

bumpbot · Answer

Automated notice from GMAT Club BumpBot: 

A member just gave Kudos to this thread, showing it’s still useful. I’ve bumped it to the top so more people can benefit. Feel free to add your own questions or solutions.

 This post was generated automatically.

S is a set containing a integers, where 0<a<11. If the arithmetic

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

GMAT Problem Solving (PS) Questions