Fareena:
PremiseMost people are, sadly, rather ignorant when it comes to financial planning. As a result, many find themselves destitute in their old age, unable to afford even basic necessities.
The government should mandate that all working individuals invest 20% of their monthly income into a state retirement fund.
ConclusionThis step would take care of the issue of lack of financial planning and thus, solve for good, the cost of living crisis among the elderly.
(Premise)ConclusionThe government should mandate that all working individuals invest 20% of their monthly income into a state retirement fund.
Baselessly presumes that there can be only one solution to the stated problem. --The argument doesnt presume that there can be only one solution, it has given one solution but doesnt deny that there can be any other solution
Reasoning is irrelevant to the stated conclusion.--As far as it goes reasoning is relevant
Fails to consider that a factor contributing to a phenomenon may not be the only factor behind the phenomenon.--So the argument has given one solution to the problem and assumes that it would solve the problem ---this assumption may be wrong if there are multiple factors involved--
CorrectPresumes that a particular factor cannot affect multiple phenomenon.---inverse the logic-not relevant
Fails to interpret the context-specific meaning of an ambiguous term.--not relevant.
Paul:
Conclusion
I think your conclusion is wrong.
Premise
People should be able to spend or save their money as they see fit. In the case of adults, at least, it is the individual’s responsibility to manage their finances, not the government’s.
Baselessly presumes that there can be only one solution to the stated problem.--he is not talking about any solution.
Reasoning is irrelevant to the stated conclusion.----As far as it goes reasoning is relevant
Fails to consider that a factor contributing to a phenomenon may not be the only factor behind the phenomenon.Not relevant for Paul
Presumes that a particular factor cannot affect multiple phenomenon.--Correct It can be be possible that without any govt. intervention people mismanage their finances which can have a snowball effect and may effect economy
.-CorrectFails to interpret the context-specific meaning of an ambiguous term.--not relevant
ANS=CD