GMAT: 640 (Q:37, V:40, AWA:5.5)
University attended: UVA
Major(s): Finance & Management
GPA / Honors: 3.5
Nationality: African American
Age: (at matriculation): 26
Gender: Male
Work Experience: 5 / IB & PE
Extra-curricular Activities: Many
Community Services: Many
Business Schools (Admitted): Booth, Wharton, Columbia, Stern
Business Schools (Applied but Dinged): None
I gave everything I had in me to prepare for the GMAT. Over the course of a year and a half I tried
Manhattan Prep, Veritas, hired 2 private tutors, took 17 practice exams, etc. but no matter how hard I tried I couldn't break the 650 mark. At a certain point I decided I had to accept my GMAT score and redirect my time and energy towards putting together the best application possible.
I acknowledge that being an African American likely helped my application get a second look. Say what you want, but at the end of the day Admissions wants to create a well-rounded class with different backgrounds and experiences. I think the biggest differentiator for me was my work experience - I started working as a teenager in various "blue collar" jobs, secured finance internships every summer in undergrad, and my IB and PE roles were in smaller teams where I spent a lot of time working with different management teams. I believe those work experiences resulted in stronger letters of recommendation which may have helped make up for my low GMAT.
Bottom line: After you've given your best effort, try not to obsess about your GMAT score and instead focus your time on the parts of the application that can make you stand out as unique.