Shaws defense of a theater of ideas brought him up against both

Question

Shaw’s defense of a theater of ideas brought him up against both his great bugbears—commercialized art on the one hand and Art for Art’s Sake on the other. His teaching is that beauty is a by-product of other activity; that the artist writes out of moral passion (in forms varying from political conviction to religious zeal), not out of love of art; that the pursuit of art for its own sake is a form of self-indulgence as bad as any other sort of sensuality. In the end, the errors of “pure” art and of commercialized art are identical: they both appeal primarily to the senses. True art, on the other hand, is not merely a matter of pleasure. It may be unpleasant. A favorite Shavian metaphor for the function of the arts is that of tooth-pulling. Even if the patient is under laughing gas, the tooth is still pulled.

The history of aesthetics affords more examples of a didactic than of a hedonist view. But Shaw’s didacticism takes an unusual turn in its application to the history of arts. If, as Shaw holds, ideas are a most important part of a work of art, and if, as he also holds, ideas go out of date, it follows that even the best works of art go out of date in some important respects and that the generally held view that great works are in all respects eternal is not shared by Shaw. In the preface to Three Plays for Puritans, he maintains that renewal in the arts means renewal in philosophy, that the first great artist who comes along after a renewal gives to the new philosophy full and final form, that subsequent artists, though even more gifted, can do nothing but refine upon the master without matching him. Shaw, whose essential modesty is as disarming as his pose of vanity is disconcerting, assigns to himself the role, not of the master, but of the pioneer, the role of a Marlowe rather than of a Shakespeare. “The whirligig of time will soon bring my audiences to my own point of view,” he writes, “and then the next Shakespeare that comes along will turn these petty tentatives of mine into masterpieces final for their epoch.”

“Final for their epoch”—even Shakespearean masterpieces are not final beyond that. No one, says Shaw, will ever write a better tragedy than Lear or a better opera than Don Giovanni or a better music drama than Der Ring des Nibelungen; but just as essential to a play as this aesthetic merit is moral relevance which, if we take a naturalistic and historical view of morals, it loses, or partly loses, in time. Shaw, who has the courage of his historicism, consistently withstands the view that moral problems do not change, and argues therefore that for us modern literature and music form a Bible surpassing in significance the Hebrew Bible. That is Shaw’s anticipatory challenge to the neo-orthodoxy of today.   1 
 1. The primary purpose of the passage is to discuss

(A) the unorthodoxy of Shaw’s views on the Bible
(B) the aesthetic merit of Shaw’s plays
(C) Shaw’s theory of art
(D) Shavian examples of the theater of ideas
(E) Shaw’s naturalistic and historical view of morals

2 
 2. The author sets off the word “pure” (line 9) with quotation marks in order to

(A) contrast it with the word “true,” which appears later (line 10)
(B) suggest that, in this context, it is synonymous with “commercialized” (line 9)
(C) underscore its importance
(D) strip away its negative connotations
(E) emphasize its positive connotations

3 
 3. According to the author, Shaw compares art to tooth-pulling (lines 12-14) in order to show that

(A) the moral relevance of a work of art must be extracted from the epoch in which it was created
(B) true art is painful to the senses
(C) even the best works of art go out of date
(D) pleasure is not the sole purpose of art
(E) all art has a lasting effect on its audience

4 
 4. According to the author, Shaw’s didacticism was unusual in that it was characterized by

(A) idealism
(B) historicism
(C) hedonism
(D) moralism
(E) religious zeal

5 
 5. It can be inferred from the passage that Shaw would probably agree with all of the following statements about Shakespeare EXCEPT:

(A) He wrote out of a moral passion.
(B) All of his plays are out of date in some important respect.
(C) He was the most profound and original thinker of his epoch.
(D) He was a greater artist than Marlowe.
(E) His Lear gives full and final form to the philosophy of his age.

6 
 6. Which of the following does the author cite as a contradiction in Shaw?

(A) Whereas he pretended to be vain, he was actually modest.
(B) He questioned the significance of the Hebrew Bible, and yet he believed that a great artist could be motivated by religious zeal.
(C) Although he insisted that true art springs from moral passion, he rejected the notion that morals do not change.
(D) He considered himself to be the pioneer of a new philosophy, but he hoped his audiences would eventually adopt his point of view.
(E) On the one hand, he held that ideas are a most important part of a work of art; on the other hand, he believed that ideas go out of date.

7 
 7. The ideas attributed to Shaw in the passage suggest that he would most likely agree with which of the following statements?

(A) Every great poet digs down to a level where human nature is always and everywhere alike.
(B) A play cannot be comprehended fully without some knowledge and imaginative understanding of its context.
(C) A great music drama like Der Ring des Nibelungen springs from a love of beauty, not from a love of art.
(D) Morality is immutable; it is not something to be discussed and worked out.
(E) Don Giovanni is a masterpiece because it is as relevant today as it was when it was created.

8 
 8. The passage contains information that answers which of the following questions?

I. According to Shaw, what is the most important part of a work of art?
II. In Shaw’s view, what does the Hebrew Bible have in common with Don Giovanni?
III. According to the author, what was Shaw’s assessment of himself as a playwright?

(A) I only
(B) III only
(C) I and II only
(D) II and III only
(E) I, II, and III

9 
 9. As it is revealed in the passage, the author’s attitude toward Shaw can best be described as

(A) condescending
(B) completely neutral
(C) approving
(D) envious
(E) adulatory

arirux92 · Accepted Answer

Hi,

This may seem like a hard passage due to all the hard words in it, but if you slow down and read, you'll easily find the way. 9 Question implies that you have at least 9 X 1.5 = 13.5 minutes to create a map for it.

Since people are asking for 5,6,7,8,9 I will be focusing on only those, you can ask me if you have doubts on the ones before :

5. It can be inferred from the passage that Shaw would probably agree with all of the following statements about Shakespeare EXCEPT:
(A) He wrote out of a moral passion.
(B) All of his plays are out of date in some important respect.
(C) He was the most profound and original thinker of his epoch.
(D) He was a greater artist than Marlowe.
(E) His Lear gives full and final form to the philosophy of his age.
 C

a) Shaw considers Shakespeare as a great artist. So hence his view points on Morality must apply.
b) As pointed in the last paragraph, all works of art are out of date.
c) Even though Shaw consideres Shakespeare's work of art as greatest, there's no explicit mention of thinker ( Let's hold on to this for the moment)
d) As mentioned, past artist are greater; present ones are pioneers. As the author compares in his notes.
e) Last paragraph. No one will write a tragedy better than Lear. Implies that Shaw considers this the ultimate form of art.

So out of these options, C is the least likely.

6. Which of the following does the author cite as a contradiction in Shaw?
(A) Whereas he pretended to be vain, he was actually modest.
(B) He questioned the significance of the Hebrew Bible, and yet he believed that a great artist could be motivated by religious zeal.
(C) Although he insisted that true art springs from moral passion, he rejected the notion that morals do not change.
(D) He considered himself to be the pioneer of a new philosophy, but he hoped his audiences would eventually adopt his point of view.
(E) On the one hand, he held that ideas are a most important part of a work of art; on the other hand, he believed that ideas go out of date.
 A

Only C and E are mentioned in the passage. But if you read between the lines, in the last paragraph the author explains the theory that E is not contradictory. Difficult to comprehend, but not contradictory ( Since he provides an explanation for it)

7. The ideas attributed to Shaw in the passage suggest that he would most likely agree with which of the following statements?
(A) Every great poet digs down to a level where human nature is always and everywhere alike.
(B) A play cannot be comprehended fully without some knowledge and imaginative understanding of its context.
(C) A great music drama like Der Ring des Nibelungen springs from a love of beauty, not from a love of art.
(D) Morality is immutable; it is not something to be discussed and worked out.
(E) Don Giovanni is a masterpiece because it is as relevant today as it was when it was created.
 B

As Shaw writes that ideas evolve with time, you can't grasp the idea behind an art without having the context behind the idea during the time the play was written. 
Clear winner B

8.

8. The passage contains information that answers which of the following questions?
I. According to Shaw, what is the most important part of a work of art?
II. In Shaw’s view, what does the Hebrew Bible have in common with Don Giovanni?
III. According to the author, what was Shaw’s assessment of himself as a playwright?
(A) I only
(B) III only
(C) I and II only
(D) II and III only
(E) I, II, and III
 D

Classic GMAT trap.
 #1 rule of GMAT RC is avoid options that are too extreme unless specifically written in the passage.

The passage talks about Shaw's view of art, of the position of morality in art, so it must be very important to him. But is it written anywhere that it's the most important? No!

Always!! I can't stress this enough! Always avoid options with too strong keywords like : most important, not important at all, the highest, etc. Always leave some space for exceptions.

9. As it is revealed in the passage, the author’s attitude toward Shaw can best be described as
(A) condescending
(B) completely neutral
(C) approving
(D) envious
(E) adulatory
 C

People here are confused between A and E. So Lets dissect.

Condescending implies superiority. A tone of arrogance. Looking down on somebody. But...

Shaw, whose essential modesty is as disarming as his pose of vanity is disconcerting,assigns to himself the role, not of the master, but of the pioneer, the role of a Marlowe rather than of a Shakespeare.

Shaw, who has the courage of his historicism, consistently withstands the view that moral problems do not change, and argues therefore that for us modern literature and music form a Bible surpassing in significance the Hebrew Bible.

Here the author is not looking down at Shaw. He approves of Shaw's stand on art. He says Shaw has the courage to stand for his point of view. You can't call someone a pioneer and look down upon them can you?

Hope it helped.

utopian25 · Answer

Some important takeaways from this passage (vocab and expressions)

1. Theater of ideas--> it simply means all the ideas of a particular type.

2. Bugbear --> a cause of obsessive fear , irritation or loathing ( I should face my bugbear of public speaking). simply put , it means fear.

3. Didactic-->intended to teach, instructive (A didactic novel)

4. Hedonistic --> pursuit of pleasure, self indulgence (Hedonistic existence of drink, drug and parties)

5. Disarming --> manner or effect of allaying suspicion or hostility, especially through charm. Simply put, to reduce hostility or suspicion using your charm.

6. Disconcerting --> causing one to feel unsettled (Tom's disconcerting habit of inviting people home, irked his wife).

7. Vanity---> a) pride, self admiration b) it also means the quality of being worthless, futile.(vanity of human wishes)

From the passage:
Shaw, whose essential modesty is as disarming as his pose of vanity is disconcerting. ( Shaw is so modest that he can allay hostility through his charm and at the same time, he pretends (pose) to show self admiration/love which unsettles people).

8. Whirlgig of time: A thing regarded as hectic or constantly changing ., like with changing time, things change.

9. Historicism: The theory that social and cultural phenomena are determined by history.

In the 1st para, it mentions, that Shaw's didactic and hedonistic style, and in the last para, it mentions he believes in historicism, so his didactic style follows the patterns of history.

10. Adulatory vs approving--> adulatory is excessive praise or admiring. Where as approving is mildly agreeing and not going over the board. 
So author was approving of Shaw and not adulatory.

mayank760 · Answer

6. Which of the following does the author cite as a contradiction in Shaw?
(A) Whereas he pretended to be vain, he was actually modest.
(B) He questioned the significance of the Hebrew Bible, and yet he believed that a great artist could be motivated by religious zeal.
(C) Although he insisted that true art springs from moral passion, he rejected the notion that morals do not change.
(D) He considered himself to be the pioneer of a new philosophy, but he hoped his audiences would eventually adopt his point of view.
(E) On the one hand, he held that ideas are a most important part of a work of art; on the other hand, he believed that ideas go out of date.
  Spoiler:
A

why not "E". Passage clearly states that Shaw believed in the idea of "idea" influencing art ? I could not find a relation in A

7. The ideas attributed to Shaw in the passage suggest that he would most likely agree with which of the following statements?
(A) Every great poet digs down to a level where human nature is always and everywhere alike.
(B) A play cannot be comprehended fully without some knowledge and imaginative understanding of its context.
(C) A great music drama like Der Ring des Nibelungen springs from a love of beauty, not from a love of art.
(D) Morality is immutable; it is not something to be discussed and worked out.
(E) Don Giovanni is a masterpiece because it is as relevant today as it was when it was created.
  Spoiler:
B
 I could not infer this particular line from any of the options.

8. The passage contains information that answers which of the following questions?
I. According to Shaw, what is the most important part of a work of art?
II. In Shaw’s view, what does the Hebrew Bible have in common with Don Giovanni?
III. According to the author, what was Shaw’s assessment of himself as a playwright?
(A) I only
(B) III only
(C) I and II only
(D) II and III only
(E) I, II, and III
  Spoiler:
D

"I" is clearly stated in the lines " If, as Shaw holds, ideas are a most important part of a work of art, and if, as he also holds, ".....

RahulSingh13 · Answer

4. According to the author, Shaw’s didacticism was unusual in that it was characterized by

(A) idealism
(B) historicism
(C) hedonism
(D) moralism
(E) religious zeal

This was my thinking to get to the answer- Didacticism refers to teaching or instruction especially on morality. Even if we don't know the meaning of this word. we can infer the meaning to a certain extent based on these lines from the passage " His teaching is that beauty is a by-product of other activity; that the artist writes out of moral passion (in forms varying from political conviction to religious zeal), not out of love of art". Now the question asks us what is unusual about Shaw's Didacticism, we can straightaway eliminate moralism and religious zeal because these are synonymous with Didacticism and not unusual characterizations of it.

Now, the lines which help us to find the answer are the following:

The history of aesthetics affords more examples of a didactic than of a hedonist view. But  Shaw’s didacticism takes an unusual turn in its application to the history of arts .

We can safely eliminate Hedonism from the answer choices and the second highlighted line clearly tells us that it's the application to the HISTORY of arts that is unusual to Shaw's take on Didacticism.

Hope i made some sense.

Thank you

abrakadabra21 · Answer

2. The author sets off the word “pure” (line 9) with quotation marks in order to
(A) contrast it with the word “true,” which appears later (line 10)
(B) suggest that, in this context, it is synonymous with “commercialized” (line 9)

quotation mark are used to say "so called". Confused between A &B. May be author wants to say that so-called distinction between pure art & commercial art is not actually a valid distinction.

5. It can be inferred from the passage that Shaw would probably agree with all of the following statements about Shakespeare EXCEPT:
(A) He wrote out of a moral passion.
(B) All of his plays are out of date in some important respect.
(C) He was the most profound and original thinker of his epoch.
(D) He was a greater artist than Marlowe.
(E) His Lear gives full and final form to the philosophy of his age.

Lost

7. The ideas attributed to Shaw in the passage suggest that he would most likely agree with which of the following statements?
(A)  Every great poet digs down to a level where human nature is always and everywhere alike. 
(B) A play cannot be comprehended fully without some knowledge and imaginative understanding of its context.
(C) A great music drama like Der Ring des Nibelungen springs  from a love of beauty, not from a love of art. 
(D) Morality is immutable;  it is not something to be discussed and worked out. 
(E) Don Giovanni is a masterpiece because it is as relevant today as it was when it was created. :  No one, says Shaw, will ever write a better tragedy than Lear or a better opera than Don Giovanni or a better music drama than Der Ring des Nibelungen; but just as essential to a play as this aesthetic merit is moral relevance which, if we take a naturalistic and historical view of morals, it loses, or partly loses, in time.   so even if Don Giovanni is a masterpiece, with time everything loses its value, its relevancy.

Correct : B

8. The passage contains information that answers which of the following questions?
I. According to Shaw, what is the most important part of a work of art?
II. In Shaw’s view, what does the Hebrew Bible have in common with Don Giovanni?
III. According to the author, what was Shaw’s assessment of himself as a playwright?
(A) I only
(B) III only
(C) I and II only
(D) II and III only
(E) I, II, and III

According to Shaw, what is the most important part of a work of art? If, as Shaw holds,  ideas are a most important part of a work of art,  and if,  as he also holds, ideas go out of date,  it follows that even the best works of art go out of date in some important respects and that the generally held view that great works are in all respects eternal is not shared by Shaw.

According to the author, what was Shaw’s assessment of himself as a playwright?
Shaw, whose essential modesty is as disarming as his pose of vanity is disconcerting, assigns to himself the role, not of the master,  but of the pioneer ,

II. In Shaw’s view, what does the Hebrew Bible have in common with Don Giovanni?  That both are irrelevant today (modern literature and music form a Bible surpassing in significance the Hebrew Bible.will ever write a better tragedy than Lear or a better opera than Don Giovanni or a better music drama than Der Ring des Nibelungen; but just as essential to a play as this aesthetic merit is moral relevance which, if we take a naturalistic and historical view of morals, it loses, or partly loses, in time.)

I dont understand why it is D?

dhairya18 · Answer

To solve a Primary Purpose question, we must look for the option that covers the entire passage, from the definition of art in the first paragraph to the historical "expiry date" in the final paragraph.
(A) ~~the unorthodoxy of Shaw’s views on the Bible~~
The Flaw: This is a Detail Trap. Shaw’s view on the Bible is only mentioned in the very last paragraph to illustrate his larger point. It doesn't cover the first two paragraphs.
(B) ~~the aesthetic merit of Shaw’s plays~~
The Flaw: The passage is about Shaw's philosophy, not a review of how good his plays are. In fact, Shaw downplays his own merit, calling himself a "pioneer" with "petty tentatives."
(C) Shaw’s theory of art
The Match: This is the "Umbrella" that covers everything.
Paragraph 1: What art is (a tool for moral passion).
Paragraph 2: How art evolves (it goes out of date).
Paragraph 3: Why we need new art (moral relevance vs. aesthetic merit).
All three parts are components of one unified "Theory of Art."
(D) ~~Shavian examples of the theater of ideas~~
The Flaw: While the passage mentions the "theater of ideas," it spends more time explaining the logic behind it than listing "examples" of plays.
(E) ~~Shaw’s naturalistic and historical view of morals~~
The Flaw: This is another Detail Trap. His view of morals is used to support his theory of art, but the passage is fundamentally about the Arts, not a treatise on moral philosophy itself.

nikchopra · Answer

How is the answer for 8th E here? 
The passage contains information that answers which of the following questions?

I. According to Shaw, what is the most important part of a work of art? - This is answered as the passage says "ideas are a most important part of a work of art." That's a direct, explicit answer.

II. In Shaw’s view, what does the Hebrew Bible have in common with Don Giovanni?

III. According to the author, what was Shaw’s assessment of himself as a playwright? - This is also answered as

Shaw cast himself as a pioneer rather than a master, a Marlowe rather than a Shakespeare and then later auth also suggests duality between his modesty and vanity

(A) I only
(B) III only
(C) I and II only
(D) II and III only
(E) I, II, and III

It should be I and III then

guddo · Answer

8. The passage contains information that answers which of the following questions?

The passage explains Shaw’s view that true art is driven by moral purpose and ideas, not by pure beauty or commercial appeal. It also explains that Shaw believed even great works can lose moral relevance over time as ideas and moral problems change. Finally, the passage states how Shaw viewed his own role as a playwright.

I. According to Shaw, what is the most important part of a work of art?

The passage does not clearly answer this.

It says that, according to Shaw, ideas are “a most important part” of a work of art. But “a most important part” means a very important part, not necessarily the single most important part.

So I is not answered.

II. In Shaw’s view, what does the Hebrew Bible have in common with Don Giovanni?

The passage answers this.

Shaw believed that even great works can lose moral relevance over time because moral problems change. Don Giovanni is mentioned as a great work, but one whose moral relevance can partly fade. The Hebrew Bible is also treated as a work whose significance is surpassed, for modern people, by modern literature and music.

So II is answered.

III. According to the author, what was Shaw’s assessment of himself as a playwright?

The passage answers this directly.

The author says Shaw assigned himself the role of the pioneer, not the master. He saw himself as more like Marlowe than Shakespeare, someone preparing the way for a later master.

So III is answered.

Therefore, the passage answers II and III only.

Answer: (D)

Shaws defense of a theater of ideas brought him up against both

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

GMAT Reading Comprehension (RC) Questions

Shaws defense of a theater of ideas brought him up against both

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards