Clarinet reeds often lose their freshness – become less responsive – a

Question

Competition Mode Question

Clarinet reeds often lose their freshness – become less responsive – after a few weeks of intense use. One clarinetist has hypothesized that a buildup of oil, rather than changes in the material properties of the reed, were responsible.

Which of the following investigations is most likely to yield significant information that would help to evaluate the hypothesis?

A. Determining what kind of wood is used to make the reeds used by jazz clarinetists.
B. Determining whether jazz clarinetists make their reeds lose their freshness faster than do classical clarinetists.
C. Determining whether identical lengths of reeds, of the same thickness, lose their freshness at different rates when put onto various brands of clarinets.
D. Determining whether rubbing various substances on the new reed causes them to lose their freshness.
E. Determining whether a fresh reed and one that has lost its freshness produce different qualities of sound

BelalHossain046 · Answer

D is my Answer.

Main evaluating criteria is  what makes Clarinet reeds less responsive or lose their freshness?
(a) a buildup of oil or (b) changes in the material properties of the reed

Option D says the exact same thing: Determining whether rubbing various substances on the new reed causes them to lose their freshness.
Rubbing various substances on the new reed=changes in the material properties of the reed.

If  (YES)  rubbing various substances on the new reed causes them to lose their freshness, change in the material properties of the reed is responsible for the loss of freshness.

If  (NO)  rubbing various substances on the new reed DOES NOT CAUSE them to lose their freshness, a buildup of oil is responsible for the loss of freshness.

BelalHossain046 · Answer

Bunuel , please have a look on Subject Verb mismatch here.

a buildup of oil, rather than changes in the material properties of the reed, were responsible.

sampriya · Answer

Clarinet reeds often lose their freshness – become less responsive – after a few weeks of intense use. One clarinetist has hypothesized that a buildup of oil, rather than changes in the material properties of the reed, were responsible.
 
conclusion: buildup of oil, rather than changes in the material properties of the reed, were responsible. 
 
reason: few weeks of intense use.

underlying assumptions : 1)few weeks of intense use does not change the material properties of the weed
2)intense use causes build up of oil
3) build up of oil doesn't cause any changes in the material of the clarinet

we therefore need an answer choice that connects the underlying assumptions to the conclusion i.e how intense use causes the Clarinet to loose its freshness

answer choice analysis:

A. Determining what kind of wood is used to make the reeds used by jazz clarinetists.
the kind of wood is irrelevant; no information about the link between intense use and changes in the clarinet is mentioned

B. Determining whether jazz clarinetists make their reeds lose their freshness faster than do classical clarinetists.
jazz clarinets vs classical clarinets is out of scope we are concerned about clarinets in general.

C. Determining whether identical lengths of reeds, of the same thickness, lose their freshness at different rates when put onto various brands of clarinets.

we are only evaluating the effect of intense use of a clarinet therefore different characteristics of a clarinet is out of scope.

D. Determining whether rubbing various substances on the new reed causes them to lose their freshness.

this is the correct answer! as this option examines whether changes in the material caused by action of rubbing causes the clarinet to loose any freshness!!

correct option!

E. Determining whether a fresh reed and one that has lost its freshness produce different qualities of sound.

this is irrelevant as per the argument a clarinet that has lost its freshness tends to be unresponsive- we always take the premises of a CR at face value but we always attack the conclusion.
 
therefore D is the correct option

Archit3110 · Answer

conclusion ; 
that a buildup of oil, rather than changes in the material properties of the reed, were responsible.

use variance test on option D: Determining whether rubbing various substances on the new reed causes them to lose their freshness
we get both strengthen and weaken conclusion
IMO D

Clarinet reeds often lose their freshness – become less responsive – after a few weeks of intense use. One clarinetist has hypothesized that a buildup of oil, rather than changes in the material properties of the reed, were responsible.

Which of the following investigations is most likely to yield significant information that would help to evaluate the hypothesis?

A. Determining what kind of wood is used to make the reeds used by jazz clarinetists.
B. Determining whether jazz clarinetists make their reeds lose their freshness faster than do classical clarinetists.
C. Determining whether identical lengths of reeds, of the same thickness, lose their freshness at different rates when put onto various brands of clarinets.
D. Determining whether rubbing various substances on the new reed causes them to lose their freshness.
E. Determining whether a fresh reed and one that has lost its freshness produce different qualities of sound

madgmat2019 · Answer

D. The hypothesis has two parts: first, that intense use does not bring material changes that cause the reed to lose its freshness and, second,that oil causes the phenomenon. The experiment suggested in choice D directly test this hypothesis by contaminating strings that are known to have their originalmaterial properties

OA:D

Posted from my mobile device

OA:D

Posted from my mobile device

chaitralirr · Answer

Clarinet reeds often lose their freshness – become less responsive – after a few weeks of intense use. One clarinetist has hypothesized that a buildup of oil, rather than changes in the material properties of the reed, were responsible.

Which of the following investigations is most likely to yield significant information that would help to evaluate the hypothesis?

A. Determining what kind of wood is used to make the reeds used by jazz clarinetists.
B. Determining whether jazz clarinetists make their reeds lose their freshness faster than do classical clarinetists.
C. Determining whether identical lengths of reeds, of the same thickness, lose their freshness at different rates when put onto various brands of clarinets.
D. Determining whether rubbing various substances on the new reed causes them to lose their freshness.
E. Determining whether a fresh reed and one that has lost its freshness produce different qualities of sound.

Stimulus: the clarinetist says that its not the material properties change in clarinet that makes it less responsive it is the oil build up.

If the material properties are not changing then the sound produced by new clarinet and the one which has lost freshness to clarinet should produce same sound. hence IMO E

Bunuel · Answer

Official Explanation

Correct Answer: D

The best answer is D. The hypothesis has two parts: first, that intense use does not bring material changes that cause the reed to lose its freshness and, second, that oil causes the phenomenon. The experiment suggested in choice D directly test this hypothesis by contaminating strings that are known to have their original material properties.

VerbalBot · Answer

Automated notice from GMAT Club VerbalBot: 

A member just gave Kudos to this thread, showing it’s still useful. I’ve bumped it to the top so more people can benefit. Feel free to add your own questions or solutions.

 This post was generated automatically.

Clarinet reeds often lose their freshness – become less responsive – a

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

GMAT Critical Reasoning (CR) Questions

Clarinet reeds often lose their freshness – become less responsive – a

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards