Hi CharlyCH,I can see exactly where the worry comes from, and it's a good instinct to check whether the answer holds for
every possible value. But here the fix is a definition, not a trap.
On the GMAT, "factor" always means a positive integer. When a question says
a and b are factors of 50, it is telling you that a and b each come only from the set every solver above listed:
{1, 2, 5, 10, 25, 50}. Negatives, fractions, and decimals are simply not "factors" in GMAT language. So you do
not need to stretch a and b to any real number - the question has already restricted them for you.
That matters because it means D is not the "least wrong" answer - it is genuinely
must-be-true. Every a and b you can pick is a divisor of
50, and
50 =
2·
52. So:
- a divides
2·
52- b divides
2·
52-
therefore ab divides (
2·
52)(
2·
52) =
22·
54 =
2500The largest ab can ever be is
50 ×
50 =
2500, which is itself a factor of
2500, and every smaller product lands inside
2500's factors too. There is no legal (a, b) pair that breaks it.
On your broader confusion: the GMAT is precise with these words on purpose. "Factor," "divisor," "multiple," and "integer" all carry fixed, positive-integer meanings unless the problem explicitly says otherwise (for example, "x is a number" or "y can be negative"). So the rule of thumb is the reverse of what you feared: only widen your possibilities when the wording invites you to. Here it doesn't, so trust D fully.
Answer: DCharlyCH
Hello.
I think I read that factors can be any number and here, it is not written that A and B are integer or non negative. Thus, can we think that D is the less wrong answer?
I am confused because sometime we see very twisted question and sometime when we think about every single possibility, it is not included in the answer.
Thanks in advance