A rabbit on a controlled diet is fed daily 300 grams of a

Question

A rabbit on a controlled diet is fed daily 300 grams of a mixture of two foods, food X and food Y. Food X contains 10% protein and food Y contains 15% protein. If the rabbit's diet provides exactly 38 grams of protein daily, how many grams of food X are in the mixture.

A. 100
B. 140
C. 150
D. 160
E. 200

A. 100
B. 140
C. 150
D. 160
E. 200

Himalayan · Accepted Answer

in fact one eq is enough: .1x + .15(300-x) = 38

solve for x, x = 140

shasadou · Answer

30 sec reasoning out: 38/300 - is a bit less than a 13% protein content. Hence 13% is closer to 15%Y than to 10%X - this means that there is just sligthly more Y component because should those 2 be equal the protein content would have been sharply 12.5% which is not the case.

Immediately we kick out 3 answer choices >= 150 and are left with A and B. A is too low for the aboe slight deviation - so B is much closer to truth.

Immediately we kick out 3 answer choices >= 150 and are left with A and B. A is too low for the aboe slight deviation - so B is much closer to truth.

ywilfred · Answer

0.1x + 0.15y = 38

x+y = 300
x = 300-y

so 0.1(300-y) + 0.15y = 38
30-0.1y + 0.15y = 38
0.05y = 8
y = 160 grams

then x = 140 grams.

Ans B

sunilgupta · Answer

Much simpler method is there...
38 gms means approx. 12.66%. Then use the mixture alligation formula to calculate the ratio of X to Y, ie,

X/Y= (15-12.66)/(12.66-10)=2.33/2.66.
Hence amt of X in total mixture is 300*2.33/(2.33+2.66)=139.2~140
Answer B.

Hayabusa · Answer

Set up two equations.

We know that 10%x+15%y=38 grams or .1x+.15y=38

We also know that x+y=300 grams.

2 eq. with 2 variables. Solve them and you should get it.

gnr646 · Answer

MGMAT has a great method that has really helped me to do these problems quickly.

For mixture problems, set up a chart:

the two different mixtures go on the right hand side, the quantities of each go on the top:

Protein Other 
X

Y

The problem says the two mixtures are added together to produce a new mixture totaling 300 grams, so add to the chart:

Protein Other Total
X X

Y Y

X+Y 300

Now add the information about how much protein is in each mixture

Protein Other Total
X .1X X

Y .15Y Y

X+Y 38 300

Now there are two equations with 2 variables:

.1X + .15Y=38 
X + Y = 300

Simple method, but it really helps break down harder questions.

bruiz · Answer

We know that 
1.00x+1.00y=300

and that
0.10x+0.15y=38

so
0.10x+0.15y=38
*10=
1.00x+1.50y=380

Align them under eachother
1.00x+1.50y=380
1.00x+1.00y=300

Means 0.50y=80
80*2=160
y=160
x=300-y
x=300-160
x=140

chetan2u · Answer

Hi,
this weighted approach,if mastered, can actually make a difference in your Quant score..
Good approach and you should try this in almost all Q that asks for an average in a mixture, or for a quantity, when an average is given..
+1 kudos

shasadou · Answer

I am going through word problem types of questions because I think i bombed this type of q in my last gmat both time-wise and accuracy wise. And what i see from OG about 30% of all questions comprise the word problem type.

During these 2 days I solved numerous word problems and here are my observations:

- very time consuming because the intuitive approach is to apply algebra and form equations, on average easy question take almost the same time as hard ones
- given my incline to make silly mistakes in algebraic calculations I should rely more on reasoning out the easy questions
- majority of easy word problems employ weighted average or mean concepts which can be done by reasoning much faster than by doing algebra - ultimately this will save at least 30 secs on each such question
-

mcelroytutoring · Answer

Here is a visual that should help.

padmakasturirangan13 · Answer

10 % of 300 = 30 gms
15% 0f 300 = 45 gms

using allegation
45- 38/ 38- 30

= 7/ 8 
therefore x :y is in the ratio 7: 8

7/ 15 X 300 = 140 gms

ScottTargetTestPrep · Answer

We can create two equations:

x + y = 300

y = 300 - x

and

0.1x + 0.15y = 38

Substituting, we have:

0.1x + 0.15(300 - x) = 38

0.1x + 45 - 0.15x = 38

7 = 0.05x

140 = x

Answer: B

achanak · Answer

Looking at the solutions, it seems pretty straightforward to come up with the 2 equations. But my first attempt at this problem was to derive the following:
1. X + Y = 300

X: 0.1P, Y: 0.15P (from "Food X contains 10% protein and food Y contains 15% protein")

2. 0.1P + 0.15P = 38

.. and just got stuck with 2 equations and 3 unknowns. Is there an approach I could use to immediately see that "10% protein" is referring to 10%(X)?

VeritasKarishma

Thanks in advance.

KarishmaB · Answer

Whenever you use variables, ensure that you know exactly what it stands for. X - Amount of food X in grams Y - Amount of food Y in grams What is P? When you say X has 10% protein, you mean to say that 10% of X is protein. 10% of X + 15% of Y = Total protein = 38 gms Anyway, such questions can be done easily using weighted averages discussed here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_GOAU7moZ2Q https://anaprep.com/arithmetic-weighted-averages/

Hoozan · Answer

KarishmaB

300 grams = x + y

10% of x = protein in X
15% of y = protein in y

Q1) why can we do the following:

10% of 300 = 30gms of protein in X
15% of 300 = 45gms of protein in Y

If we follow the allegation process, we will land up with a ratio of 7:8.

Q2)  why can we do , 7a+8a = 300gms?

KarishmaB · Answer

You can average out the percentage of protein or the amount of protein. Both will give you the same result as long as you ensure that everything else suits the situation you choose.

X has 10% protein. (concentration of protein in X is 10%)
Y has 15% protein. (concentration of protein in Y is 15%)
Avg concentration of protein in Mixture is 38/300 * 100 = 38/3% protein (which is 12.67% but since it is a rounded value, we can keep 38/3 to retain accuracy)

Now use 
 \frac{w1}{ w2} = \frac{(15 - 38/3)}{(38/3 - 10)} = \frac{7}{8}

So X and Y are in the ratio 7:8. 
If there is 300 gms of mixture, X will be 140 gms and Y will be 160 gms.

Alternatively, you are saying that 300 gms of X has 30 gms of protein. (Mind you, 300 gms of X, not 300 gms of mixture)
300 gms of Y has 45 gms of protein. (concentration of protein in X is 30/300 and concentration of protein in Y is 45/300)
300 gms of mixture has 38 gms of protein (avg concentration of protein in mixture is 38/300)

So in what ratio were X and Y mixed to give the mixture?

\frac{w1}{w2} = \frac{(45 - 38)}{(38 - 30)} = \frac{7}{8}

We have the denominator same so that they become comparable. 
Essentially, the second method is the same as

\frac{w1}{w2} = \frac{(45/300 - 38/300)}{(38/300 - 30/300)}

All 300s get cancelled. Note that in both the methods, we are averaging the concentrations.

Just like the first method is the same as 
 \frac{w1}{w2} = \frac{15/100 - (38/3)/100}{(38/3)/100 - 10/100}

ynan456 · Answer

If you plug in options in this question, particularly option d, you match the daily requirement of 38g of protein, why is this option wrong then?

chetan2u · Answer

No, it does not fit in.

X is 10% and Y is 15%.

Be careful, you have to fit in for X. 
Thus 10% of 160 + 15% of 140 = 16+21 = 37. But it should be 38.

10% of 140 + 15% of 160 = 14+24 = 38. So, option B.

I believe you filled up opposite values of X and Y in option D.

Rail · Answer

What others have said is completely fine, i'd avoid equation in this case since there is a proper spread between options.

Knowing that (38/300)*100 is actually more than 12,5% means that you will have an asymmetric weight of components (we are told that X is 10% and Y is 15% so basically 15% is "closer" to the result coming from the formula above that is about 12,7%. So using either the scale/line method to visualize it you can quickly conclude that 140 is the proper answer for X (because Y needs to be more than 150, in this case 160) (since the 12,7% is closer to 15% than it is to 10%, the part at 15% will "weight more" into the final mixture; conversely the part at 10% will "weigth less" into the final mixture)

Of course, in other cases in which you have a narrow margin between options you will have to do the formula.

I think the slight difficulty in this problem is how to start. Once you understand how to start then you need only to pay attention to arithmetic.

A rabbit on a controlled diet is fed daily 300 grams of a

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

GMAT Problem Solving (PS) Questions

A rabbit on a controlled diet is fed daily 300 grams of a

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia