If x, y and z are positive integers and x

Question

If x, y and z are positive integers and x < y, what are the number of common factors between x and z?

(1)  z = y! + 1  
(2)  x = 11  and  y = 12

self made : challenge Q
Kudos for first few correct solutions

deepudiscover · Answer

Answer is A
 as x,y,z all are positive and x<y, least value of y is 2 and x is 1

I did the following hit and trial
if y=2
Z=3 and x=1...Common factor..1

if y=3
Z=7 and x=1,2...Common factor 1

if y=4
z=25, x=1,2,3..common factor 1

if y=5 z=121..x=1,2,3,4..

if y=6 z=721..x=1,2,3,4,5....CF=1.

Seeing this pattern it is A... I am not able to deduce an algebraic solution but saw this pattern

septwibowo · Answer

Just trying to answer based on my understanding : - Statement (1) and (2) IMO not sufficient because just talks only about z&m (1) and x&y (2). - So, basically this is C and E split. Combine the statement : - x=11, y=12, so z=(12!)+1. - x just have 2 factor - this is prime number. - So, the question is simply : do z has 11 as a factor? - If they HAVE, so the common factors are 2 (1 and 11) - If they DON'T HAVE, so the common factor just 1 (only 1). - So, just analyze these things we can conclude that the answer is C . Whatever the answer, we CAN get how many common factors they have. By the way, z does not have 11 as a factor. (12!) has the 11 as a factor, but when you add 1 into (12!) so you cannot get 11 as a factor. Am I right?

TheMechanic · Answer

Correction:
The answer should be  A .

Given that x < y.

Statement 1: since z = y!+1. There is no common factor between z and x beside 1. This statement is  sufficient .
Statement 2: Does not give any information about z. Hence this is insufficient.

zanaik89 · Answer

Request u to pls explain this in detail

niks18 · Answer

Statement 1 : implies that  z=y!+1  &  y!  are consecutive and hence co-prime. Two consecutive integers are co-prime, which means that only common factor is  1 .

For example  2  and  3 ,  40  &  41  etc. are consecutive integers, thus only common factor they share is  1 .

so  z  will have  1  as a common factor with any number less than  y!  and since  x<y , so  z  will have only one common factor with  x  i.e  1

you can test this through some examples. for ex.  x=2  &  y=3  then  z=3!+1=7 . between  x  &  z  only  1  is the common factor

another one,  x=3  &  y=5 ,  z=5!+1=120+1=121=11^2 . only  1  is the common factor here.

Sufficient

Statement 2 : Nothing mentioned about  z .  Insufficient

Option  A

chetan2u · Answer

It is a tough Q and the solution would go like this...
(1)  z = y! + 1  
z=y!+1...
 first thing first - All the numbers below y are factors of y! as   y! = 1*2*3*....(y-1)*y ,  so when we add 1 to y!, y!+1 will be co-prime to all the numbers below y 
this is what the Q is asking...  y!+1 is NOTHING but z, and any value < y is NOTHING but x, so x and z are coprime.. 
Only common factor between x and z is 1
sufficient

(2)  x = 11  and  y = 12 
Nothing about z
Insufficient

A

zanaik89 · Answer

Thanks a lot for the reply

What does this mean?

so z will have 1 as a common factor with any number less than y!

niks18 · Answer

Hi  zanaik89 ,

The important concept to note here is that   Two consecutive numbers are Co-Prime  , that is between themselves they will not have any common factor except 1.
So let's take an example of 24 & 25, 24 has factors 1,2,3,4,6,8,12,24 and 25 has factors 1,5,25. As you can see only 1 is the common factor between 24 & 25 because both are consecutive integers and hence co-prime.

In this question z and y! are consecutive, hence z and y! will be co-prime so we can say that any factor of y! except 1 will not be present in z. Since x<y and as y! has all integers that are less than y as a factor so x must be a factor of y! so x cannot be a factor of y!+1 i.e.z. For eg. if x=2, y=3 then y! = 3*  2  *1, as you can see x is a factor of y!

bumpbot · Answer

Automated notice from GMAT Club BumpBot: 

A member just gave Kudos to this thread, showing it’s still useful. I’ve bumped it to the top so more people can benefit. Feel free to add your own questions or solutions.

 This post was generated automatically.

If x, y and z are positive integers and x < y, what are the number of

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

GMAT Data Sufficiency (DS) Questions