If x and z are positive integers, is at least one of them a prime numb

Question

If x and z are positive integers, is at least one of them a prime number?

(1) x^2 = 15 + z^2
(2) (x − z) is a prime number

GMATinsight · Answer

Question : is at least one of x and z a prime number?

Statement 1 :x^2 = 15 + z^2 
i.e.  x^2-z^2 =15 
i.e.  (x-z)*(x+z) =15 
i.e.  (x-z)*(x+z) =3*5  OR
i.e.  (x-z)*(x+z) =1*15  
If x-z = 3 the x and z may be 5 and 2 both prime OR x and z may be 9 and 6 both NON Prime
NOT SUFFICIENT

Statement 2 : (x − z) is a prime number 
x-z = 5-3=2 i.e. Both prime OR
x-z = 6-4=2 i.e. None prime
NOT SUFFICIENT

Combining both statements  
 (x-z)*(x+z) =15  and  x-z  is prime i.e. either 3 or 5
If x-z = 3 the x and z may be 5 and 2 both prime OR x and z may be 9 and 6 both NON Prime
NOT SUFFICIENT

Answer: Option E

sahilkak · Answer

Lets deal with Statement 1 first using plugin approach:

1 x^2 = 15 +z^2

2 we can write above statement as
 
x^2-Z^2=15 or (x+z)(x-z)=15

3. x+z= 3 means- 1 + 2=3 and x-z means- 4-1

4. so (1,2) and (4,1) -leads to insufficent we have 2 answers

A insufficient

II. Lets move on to 2nd statement

1. x-z is prime number 
2. put x=4 , z=1 , none are prime , 4-1=3 , which is prime, so we got 1 no answer
3. put x=5 , y=2, both are prime, 5-2=3, which is prime, so we got 1 yes answer

So clearly B is insufficent

III. combining Statement 1 and statement 2

a)x^2-z^2=15
b) x-z =prime

if you plug values (4,1), both satisfies statement a and b, 
if you try value like(5,2) , or any other combination, it wont satisfy both

hence A and B combined are sufficnet

Correct answer: C

Bunuel , please correct my approach if i m wrong

harsha3699 · Answer

Given that x and z are positive integers.
We need to find out is that whether one of those number or numbers is a prime number.
Statement 1 says that 
x^2 = 15+ z^2
This could happen in 2 of the most nearest cases, nearest in the sense smaller numbers.
if x = 4 , then x^2 = 16, then 
16 = 15 + z^2
Implies, z^2 = 1,
Implies, z= 1(since z is a positive integer)
So , x = 4, z = 1, neither of them are prime numbers.
Case 2 , if x = 8, then x^2 = 64, 
Implies, 64 = 15 + z^2
Implies, z^2 = 49
Implies, z =7 (since z is a positive integer)
So, x = 8, z = 7 (one of them is a prime number)
Since we have no unique solution of one of the or both of them to be prime numbers. Statement 1 is insufficient.
Statement 2 says that x-z is a prime number.
Now, if both x and z are odd, then the only even prime number would be 2; and x should be equal to z+2, ie, x=z+2
 Or if one of them is even then x-z will yield any odd prime number.
Per say this statement falls too short in providing data to find the solution, because, x-z could be 3-1(one of them prime), 7-5 (both of them prime), 
So, statement 2 is insufficient. 
Combining both statements we get that neither of them are supposed to be prime to arrive at the solution.
So the correct answer is C.

If x and z are positive integers, is at least one of them a prime numb

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

GMAT Data Sufficiency (DS) Questions

If x and z are positive integers, is at least one of them a prime numb

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards