For reasons that I can't fully articulate, my heart was dead-set on going to Booth. The hopes of attending this school were the primary reason I moved to Chicago in the first place, I have colleagues and friends that are Booth alumns and have praised Booth for years, and the facilities are top notch. I attended a Launch event with a buddy in the program, and really felt at home. For personal goals, I feel like Booth would be more of a fulfillment, in part because of their prestige and rank.
At the same time, I recognize that my feelings are primarily emotional and this may not be entirely logical. Would I be crazy to consider trying to defer Kellogg until the fall and reapply at Booth? I would take a couple classes at Graham (Booth's affiliate), and perhaps retake the GMAT (although I would dread this). I am also due for a promotion at work.
Profile:
GMAT: 660 (44Q/37V)
Undergrad cumulative GPA between 2 schools: 3.0
WE: 7 years in financial services, currently hold 2 roles, 1 as a Manager of Business Intelligence, 2 as a Business Process Outsourcing Manager.
Goals: become VP of BI at my current company (a PE backed company). Long term: move up to our parent company at PE fund level, overhaul multiple company's BI platforms simultaneously.