If x ≠ 0 is xy 0 ? (1) x 0 (2) x/y 1

Question

If  x ≠ 0  is   xy > 0  ?

(1)    x > 0  
(2)    x/y > 1

Thelegend2631 · Answer

I thought answer should be B.
Since

Statement 2 will be
\((x-y) /y > 0\)

Taking \(x-y > 0 \)and \(y > 0\)

\(X > y\) and \(y > 0\) then both x and y will ne positive.
Taking x-y<0 and y< 0

\(x < y\)
\(y < 0\)

That means both x and y will be negative.

Manhattan prep says statement 2 is not sufficient but i don't see why it isn't sufficient.

Avengers.. Assemble!

Posted from my mobile device

Rahul3193 · Answer

I think we need both statement to answer

Posted from my mobile device

Thelegend2631 · Answer

Yeah the OA is mentioned as C. But want to know how statement 2 is insufficient. Want to know your my explanation above doesn't serve its purpose

Bunuel · Answer

Can you please post a screenshot of the questions from Manhattan guide? Thank you!

Thelegend2631 · Answer

If x ≠ 0, is xy > 0 ?
The question is actually asking whether x and y have the same sign.
(1) INSUFFICIENT: This indicates nothing about the sign of y.
In evaluating statement (2), you might be tempted to assume that x must
be positive.

2) INSUFFICIENT: Consider the possibility that x is negative. In this case, it
is necessary to flip the sign of the inequality when you cross-multiply. That
is, if x < 0, then means that 1 > xy, and the answer to the question
is MAYBE.
(1) & (2) SUFFICIENT: If x is positive, then statement (2) says that 1 < xy (do
not flip the sign when cross-multiplying). Thus, xy > 0.

Attachments

File comment: Screenshot

GCQ.jpg [ 213.86 KiB | Viewed 4277 times ]

Bunuel · Answer

Yes, their solution does not make sense. Correct answer is B.

If x is not equal to 0 is xy > 0 ?

(1) x > 0. Clearly insufficient.

(2) x/y > 1 --> this means that x/y is positive --> x/y is positive means that x and y have the same sign --> x and y have the same sign means that xy is positive. Sufficient.

Answer: B.

Hope it helps.

chetan2u · Answer

Statement II, looking at the way the solution is written, seems to be suggesting the inequality to be \frac{1}{x}xy. Maybe the solution has been written erroneously thinking they are dealing with 1/x1>0 means x and y have same sign.

Bunuel · Answer

You might be right. Here is that GMAT question: https://gmatclub.com/forum/if-x-0-is-xy-200160.html

IanStewart · Answer

Another way to look at Statement 2: multiply by y^2 on both sides (which we can safely do, because y^2 is never negative). Then you get xy > y^2, and if xy is greater than a square, xy is definitely positive.

bumpbot · Answer

Automated notice from GMAT Club BumpBot: 

A member just gave Kudos to this thread, showing it’s still useful. I’ve bumped it to the top so more people can benefit. Feel free to add your own questions or solutions.

 This post was generated automatically.

If x ≠ 0 is xy > 0 ? (1) x > 0 (2) x/y > 1

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards