I can definitely relate to some of the points raised. I had a hard time arriving at the interview place and the 'basement' wasn't that attractive at all, specially compared to the state-of-the-art facilities at other b-schools.
And yes, it was China town meets little India. But, that could be said of the whole of Penn and not just Wharton. I was also the only one interviewing on my timeslot that wasn't in finance or consulting. And most hailed from NYC.
My interview was short and felt mechanical since the poor 2nd year student had probably been asking and hearing about the same topics for a while. But it wasn't unpleasant. I'm very outgoing and my interviewer was more reserved and shy but I'm not sure that's necessarily a bad thing.
I didn't interact with other students at events because I had been to Penn in the past and some of my close friends went to Wharton. I know what the students are like already and I just wanted to be done with my interview to fly back home.
My opinion is that nor Wharton or Penn are places that 'wows' you at first sight as HBS, for example, does.
However, I'd say my experience was simply neutral. Wharton is a strong school and I'd choose to go there over any other except for HBS and maybe S.
Fit might be very important when looking at smaller programs but I think there's a place for everyone at Wharton and it's somewhat natural not to fall in love with the school or Philly at first sight.
Posted from my mobile device