GMAT Club

Premium Service Reviews

If you work with us, prepare to work harder and spend more time on your applications than you will if you work with any other firm. Why? Because of the rigor and hands-on care we bring to partnerships. We understand that could be all you need to read to decide that we aren’t the right partner for you. If so, no worries. We wish you well with your applications.

For those of you still reading, know that our rigor and care are just a natural part of the bespoke experience your 4-person Square One team will give you. You’ll build applications that secure offers, while developing confidence and clarity that transcends them. With three services – Premium, Premium Need-based, and Premium Essential – we hope one meets your needs and budget. We’re excited to get to know, challenge, and guide you!
5.0 /5 Average Rating
5 star
597
4 star
20
3 star
0
2 star
0
1 star
2
Based on 619 reviews

AI Super-Summary of Customer Reviews for Premium Service*

Square One Prep (SOP) is highly praised by clients for its meticulous, personalized approach to MBA application consulting. The team, led by Kathryn, provides structured guidance, emotional support, and helps clients create authentic and powerful applications. SOP advisors like Amalia, Kelsey, and Horatiu are noted for their detailed feedback and career narrative exercises, which aid in self-discovery and application clarity. Clients commend the team's dedication, knowledge, and ability to turn challenges into strengths, leading to successful admissions to top schools and scholarships. SOP's empathetic engagement and strategic planning alleviate the stresses of the application process, making it a valuable investment for prospective MBA students.
13 users mention "Supportive"
  • "Amalia not only supported me through those moments of self-discovery..." Read more
  • "They also helped me grow personally...." Read more
  • "Kelsey W was a mentor who challenges me to perform my best..." Read more
  • "Their empathy and support..." Read more
  • "unwavering support..." Read more
  • "the entire team at SOP was...supportive..." Read more
  • "encouraged me to not discount my unique experiences..." Read more
  • "Their emotional support was a significant factor..." Read more
  • "provided a built-in support system..." Read more
  • "provided unwavering support..." Read more
  • "extremely helpful..." Read more
  • "Their genuine investment in my success..." Read more
  • "attention to detail and empathy..." Read more
8 users mention "Full Service"
  • "Square One Prep s approach to the application process is highly effective and helpful..." Read more
  • "support extends beyond just application and essay work..." Read more
  • "Square One Prep as a resource for anyone applying to business school..." Read more
  • "phenomenal job helping me navigate the MBA admissions process..." Read more
  • "amazing experience with Square One..." Read more
  • "comprehensive and effective guidance..." Read more
  • "their services, gaining admission to M7 schools..." Read more
  • "free consultation that they offer..." Read more
7 users mention "Admitted"
  • "I managed to do it!..." Read more
  • "Got Into Every One of My Dream Schools..." Read more
  • "all my interviews went well and resulted in acceptances..." Read more
  • "both used Square One to apply to our dream school of Stanford GSB and were both admitted..." Read more
  • "Their collective dedication and expertise turned my waitlist status into acceptance..." Read more
  • "I am thrilled to be heading to HBS this fall..." Read more
  • "admits from my dream MBA programs..." Read more
7 users mention "Detail-Oriented"
  • "structured and easy to follow planning tool..." Read more
  • "Kelsey was also super responsive throughout the whole process..." Read more
  • "attention to detail was unmatched..." Read more
  • "decisive in her resume and essay edits..." Read more
  • "Once I finished the career narrative, Allison helped me write amazing essays..." Read more
  • "kept me accountable with reminders..." Read more
  • "attention to the smallest detail..." Read more
5 users mention "Non-traditional Backgrounds"
  • "As a non-traditional applicant..." Read more
  • "nearly therapy-like sessions, Amalia and I talked through my life trajectory and future goals..." Read more
  • "Square One instilled a belief in me that changed the trajectory of my life..." Read more
  • "my advisor did an impeccable job at convincing me this personal story..." Read more
  • "an applicant with a unique background..." Read more
5 users mention "Scholarship Awarded"
  • "maximize my chances of acceptance and scholarship...." Read more
  • "service paid for itself with the scholarship..." Read more
  • "I'm excited to attend Chicago Booth next fall on a full ride scholarship..." Read more
  • "Harvard Kennedy School on a full-ride scholarship..." Read more
  • "unexpected merit scholarships that I was awarded..." Read more
4 users mention "Responsive"
  • "responding quickly with sage advice..." Read more
  • "hop on a call during the work day with less than an hour notice..." Read more
  • "Her prompt responses were a lifesaver..." Read more
  • "flexible to work with my chaotic schedule and varied time zones..." Read more
1 users mention "Essay Editing"
  • "Both my HBS and Stanford essays were complimented..." Read more
1 users mention "Value for Money"
  • "I highly recommend her as an advisor...." Read more
1 users mention "Career Transition"
  • "the career narrative process at SOP is important..." Read more
*Review summaries are AI generated from 25 latest reviews in the past 2 years.
December 29, 2025
mbagirlie2002

Joined: Jan 03, 2021

Posts: 0

Kudos: 0

Got into 4 M7 Schools!! with scholarship!!

REVIEWER IDENTITY VERIFIED by score report [?]

Strengths:

Comprehensive, thorough, personalized admissions prep

Would make the product better:

n/a

It has been a dream for me attend business school and I knew I had a very high risk appetite going in: applying to only m7 schools. No one in my family had gotten their MBA from a top business school and I wanted to ensure that I put my best foot forward. A friend of a friend had recommended Square One Prep, so I decided to book a free consultation with Kathryn. The meeting lasted well over the allotted time and it felt like such a natural conversation where she was trying to get to know me: my goals, my hobbies, what drives me, what my passions are, and why I wanted to pursue an MBA at this time. I got to know more about how thorough and personalized Square One’s process was as well. I then was able to have conversations with a couple different consultants and decided to work with Catherine. She is incredibly diligent, empathetic, and a wonderful person to work with! She has a quick turn around time for edits on deliverables, kept me accountable for resume, LOR, career narrative, and essay deadlines, and truly created a safe space for me to be vulnerable and share my voice through my writing. I was incredibly impressed by how involved the team was with each step of the application process, not once did I feel overwhelmed or like I was going through this process alone. Catherine and the Square One team were my biggest cheerleaders even after I submitted my apps R1 and helped me prep for interviews, pre-interview assignments, and cheered me on throughout all my acceptances. I got into MIT Sloan(with $$), U Chicago Booth, Kellogg(with $$), and Columbia because of the Square One team and I cannot thank them enough for their support throughout.

Read More

December 23, 2025
csim96

Joined: Apr 10, 2025

Posts: 3

Kudos: 2

Thank you, Square One Prep!

REVIEWER IDENTITY VERIFIED by score report [?]

There is absolutely no way I could have achieved the results I did without Square One Prep’s help.

I started the MBA application process feeling overwhelmed by the number of essays and variables involved. I was also anxious about my non-traditional background and winding career path. Kathryn, Amalia, Horatiu, and the rest of the Square One Prep team immediately put me at ease and gave me immense confidence throughout the process. They were incredibly responsive, insightful, and supportive—helping me connect the disparate dots of my career and craft a story that was genuine to me on paper and in interviews.

Thank you Square One Prep!

Read More

December 21, 2025
Ranciola

Joined: Sep 16, 2021

Posts: 0

Kudos: 0

Cannot recommend SOP enough

REVIEWER IDENTITY VERIFIED by score report [?]

Strengths:

Detailed process, hands-on approach, personalized consultation.

I cannot recommend Square One Prep enough. Square One Prep came to my attention after one of my close West Point friends was admitted to Wharton after leveraging Square One, and could not stop raving about his MBA application experience.

Given I had applied to business school in the past (R1 of 2022 cycle) and was not offered any interviews, I decided to take the intro call. What was supposed to be a 30 minute chat with Kathrine turned into an hour plus conversation full of value and transparency that left me energized to start the process.

What set Square One apart was their intentional process and ability to go beyond the surface level. Wilson and team challenged my original application framework (Why MBA, SL/LT goals, my story) and opened my eyes to a level of detail that I was not keen to. Everything from the initial assessment, to the career narrative, to resume build, and essay work is truly top tier. It's a phenomenal process that enables you to put your best foot forward.

As a result of our work, I received interviews from Tepper, Tuck, Columbia and ultimately was admitted to Tepper and CBS.

I would especially recommend SOP to applicants to anyone, especially transitioning military members who want a coach that will push them to think deeper—not just write better.

Read More

December 19, 2025
explicaboeveniet

Joined: Nov 24, 2025

Posts: 0

Kudos: 0

Thank You, Square One Prep!

REVIEWER IDENTITY VERIFIED by score report [?]

Strengths:

-Free consultation
-School selection assistance
-Career goals assistance
-Knowledge about the MBA application/adcom space
-Responsiveness
-Resume building
-Interview prep

Would make the product better:

N/A

Working with Wilson and the Square One Prep (SOP) team was an incredible experience. I came into the MBA application process feeling insecure about several aspects of my candidacy-my test scores, GPA, and work experience-and unsure how I would measure up against other applicants to top-20 programs.

What truly sets Wilson and SOP apart is their emphasis on seeing candidates as more than just numbers. Before charging for anything, they take the time to genuinely get to know you-why you want an MBA, your career and personal goals, and which schools make the most sense for your profile. This stood in stark contrast to other consulting firms that charge simply for an initial conversation.

SOP offers a deep bench of strong consultants, and with the help of Kathryn Lucas (Founder & CEO), who thoughtfully matched me with several potential advisors, I ultimately chose to work with Wilson after speaking with each of them.

What stood out most about Wilson was his consistently upbeat and positive attitude-which was invaluable during a stressful process-combined with his experience working with admissions committees and his impressive track record helping candidates build compelling applications for their dream schools.

As we began building my profile, Wilson and I met across several calls to refine my resume, clearly articulate my career goals, and strategically select my recommenders. From there, we moved into essays, working closely together on each one to fine-tune my story. With every step, my confidence in my candidacy continued to grow.

Beyond the core deliverables, Wilson and the broader SOP team consistently went above and beyond-responding quickly to emails and texts and answering every question I had along the way. Having access to trusted, expert guidance rather than turning to anonymous online forums made a huge difference.

Overall, if you’re looking for a truly comprehensive and supportive MBA admissions consulting experience, I can’t recommend Square One Prep and Wilson highly enough. I genuinely wouldn’t be in the position I’m in today without their support.

Read More

December 16, 2025
ihlai

Joined: Dec 15, 2025

Posts: 0

Kudos: 0

Verified GMAT Classic score:
720 Q49 V40

I had the pleasure of working directly with Kathryn as my advisor throughout the full-time MBA application process. While I was somewhat familiar with the application process, having independently applied to several 2+2 programs during college, I knew I needed to seek guidance from an experienced MBA consultant to help me get into my dream school.

Like many prospective applicants, I was initially overwhelmed by the options available. Working with a consultant is a significant investment, and I was mindful of the risks of working with someone who lacked experience, did not understand my background, or did not align with my working style. As such, I did countless consultation intro calls with consultants (independent and those part of a bigger organization) to narrow my options.

I walked away from my call with Kathryn feeling very positive, not only because she was quick to respond to my consultation request or that she was actively engaging and learning about me, but also because of her extensive experience working with clients across the spectrum and how she encouraged me to embrace my identity. I felt comfortable sharing personal aspects of my life with her, which added depth and authenticity to my essays. I also appreciated her firm’s unique, structured process, which provided clarity and peace of mind.

For example, their approach to helping me define my career vision and steps to get there, led by Horatiu, my career narrative expert, and Kathryn was particularly valuable, as the research I did to make my case and get their support enabled me to build a differentiated narrative that truly reflects what I want to do. It took hard work with work sessions and lots of homework, but was worth the effort.

To be clear, Kathryn will push you to work hard throughout your experience with her. I spent a lot of time and effort researching schools, brainstorming, and drafting essays – she was with me in the trenches every step of the way, even when I hit some unexpected challenges with my LORs. I especially appreciated Kathryn’s quick turnaround times even though I knew she was also running a firm. She always made herself available (even during weekends!) whenever I had questions or grew anxious about the application process.

In hindsight, as much as the goal was for me to get into my dream school (which I’m happy to share that I did), I also developed a deeper understanding of the school, my career goals, and how to maximize my MBA experience, thanks to Kathryn’s guidance. I’m very glad to have worked with Kathryn and her team throughout the MBA application process and would enthusiastically recommend her to everyone!

Read More

verify-zero-posts
This reviewer has not participated on GMAT Club but it is a REAL person and a REAL review. GMAT Club has verified this test-taker's identity through GMAC/Pearson Vue Score Reporting system and confirmed that this reviewer indeed took the GMAT, is unique, and has not submitted multiple reviews.
December 16, 2025
iheartpapaya

Joined: Feb 02, 2023

Posts: 9

Kudos: 2

Verified GMAT Focus score:
705 Q84 V87 DI84

Square One Prep is the Best Out There!

REVIEWER IDENTITY VERIFIED by score report [?]

Strengths:

Personalized coaching with the support of an entire team, responsive, and experienced

Would make the product better:

NA

Square One Prep was the best decision regarding I made regarding my business school application! I originally thought I’d be able to tackle the application process myself, but I found out very quickly that the process is very nuanced and a even an outstanding applicant can thwart their chances by putting together a lackluster application. I had consultations with some of the biggest MBA consulting firms and independent consultants, but Square One stood out to me as the best fit, as I was getting the dedication of a single consultant, but my application was being supported by a team of experts. My advisor was constantly by my side to push my best application forward, and Kelsey’s final reviews and comments helped me nail my essays and post-interview reflection. Kathryn was always in touch to answer any questions I had throughout the process. I couldn’t recommend Square One enough and I am happy to have been admitted to the two schools I applied to (Wharton and Harvard). I will be attending HBS in the fall! I couldn’t have done it without the team :)

Read More

December 15, 2025
avalanche11

Joined: Jul 08, 2024

Posts: 0

Kudos: 0

Strengths:

I wouldn't have been able to have a successful MBA application process without the help of SOP; the carefully selected team truly invested in supporting and developing me to achieve my best. Top-notch professionals who take their role seriously and truly care about you and your journey.

From the moment I was recommended to SOP by a friend, I was amazed at the professionalism and expertise of the entire team, and knew working with them would be integral to my success in the process. From the initial introduction call with Kathryn to discuss their unique, highly effective process, to having the chance to meet several different coaches, their approach felt meaningful and impactful since the beginning. After they helped me craft my resume, working with Horatiu opened my eyes to career possibilities while developing a career narrative.

Kelsey was a constant source of inspiration and guidance available around the clock for any question. I received tailored guidance to approach my GRE/GMAT testing shortfalls, and help from Pat supported me in structuring a solid plan around my constant travels around the world for work.

I really enjoyed the structure and guidance the program provided to ensure that I could effectively manage my full-time career while applying to 6 schools simultaneously all in Round 1, and was fortunate enough to receive acceptance offers from several M10 programs, to include Stanford, Harvard, Wharton, and Booth.

You are in good hands if you opt to utilize SOP!

Read More

August 13, 2025
doloreseos

Joined: Aug 13, 2025

Posts: 0

Kudos: 0

Highly recommend Square One!

REVIEWER IDENTITY VERIFIED by school email address [?]

I had an excellent experience working with Lara, Kathryn, and the rest of the Square One team. From our very first interaction they were very honest with me about my strengths, weaknesses, and expected outcomes. I was not interested in working with a team who would coddle me, and
the Square One team certainly challenged me. I am highly confident that working with their team improved the quality of my applications significantly. I started out working with Square One for only my top 2 schools, but ultimately chose to work with them for the remainder of my applications as well, due to how helpful they were. Without their help I'm not sure if I would have received an acceptance to my dream school, and I am positive I would not have received the large scholarship I was awarded. Would highly recommend working with the Square One team, and specifically Lara, to anyone working on MBA applications.

Read More

verify-zero-posts
This reviewer has not participated on GMAT Club but it is a REAL person and a REAL review. GMAT Club has verified this test-taker's identity through GMAC/Pearson Vue Score Reporting system or .edu email address and confirmed that this reviewer indeed took the GMAT, is unique, and has not submitted multiple reviews.
August 03, 2025
KM33

Joined: May 26, 2025

Posts: 0

Kudos: 0

Amazing experience with Square One Prep! 6 Acceptances and scholarships!!

REVIEWER IDENTITY VERIFIED by school email address [?]

Strengths:

Team that really cares about you- they push you to be better.

I cannot recommend Square One Prep enough!!!
I was coming from a non-traditional healthcare background, and like many applicants, I had doubts about how competitive my profile really was. But Kathryn, my advisor, and Horatiu never wavered — they believed in me even when I was unsure, and they helped me bring clarity, structure, and confidence to my story.

Kathryn and my advisor pushed me to refine my narrative, think critically about my goals, and elevate my applications with intention and precision. They were willing to work around my late shifts at the hospital and were always available for a quick phone call. They truly cared about getting to know you to help discover your story. Horatiu was instrumental in helping me develop a thoughtful career narrative that felt both ambitious and deeply personal. He empowered my voice and helped me connect the dots between my past experiences and future aspirations.

With their support, I was admitted to six top MBA programs, including Kellogg, Columbia, and Stern, and received generous scholarships. What stood out most was how hands-on and tailored the process was. This was not cookie-cutter consulting — it was a true partnership that helped me become a stronger, more self-aware applicant.

If you’re looking for a team that challenges you, believes in your potential, and brings out your best, Square One Prep is that team. I’m so grateful to all of you!

Read More

verify-zero-posts
This reviewer has not participated on GMAT Club but it is a REAL person and a REAL review. GMAT Club has verified this test-taker's identity through GMAC/Pearson Vue Score Reporting system or .edu email address and confirmed that this reviewer indeed took the GMAT, is unique, and has not submitted multiple reviews.
June 17, 2025
FuquaMBAAdmit

Joined: May 14, 2024

Posts: 0

Kudos: 0

Square 1 Prep Experience

REVIEWER IDENTITY VERIFIED by score report [?]

Strengths:

Communication
Always Available to answer questions

Would make the product better:

NA

Working with Square1Prep was one of the best decisions I made during my MBA journey. At the beginning of the process, I really had no idea where to apply or how to approach the applications strategically. Square1Prep guided me in identifying the right programs to target and pushed me to reflect deeply on my motivations for pursuing an MBA (something every applicant will absolutely need to articulate). Through that process, I was able to refine my "why MBA" and craft a clear and compelling narrative that connected my goals and past experiences.
As decisions started coming in, I was waitlisted at several programs. This is where Square1Prep's support was invaluable. They helped me build a thoughtful and actionable waitlist strategy, connected me with current students, and kept me focused and optimistic. In the end, I not only got off the waitlists but also received a scholarship to my top choice program.
Throughout the entire process, it never felt like I was just a client. Square1Prep genuinely cared about my success and was fully invested in helping me reach my goals. I highly recommend their services to anyone pursuing an MBA because the application process is far more than just a strong GMAT score and a few AI-generated essays.

Read More


77 Older and Non-Verified Reviews for Square One Prep