GMAT Club

The Red Pen Admissions Consulting Reviews

Established in 2011, The Red Pen provides high-quality MBA consulting to candidates around the world.

 

Team

Our international team of consultants hold MBAs from top international programs such as Columbia, Wharton, INSEAD, Booth, NYU Stern, Cornell and Oxford Saïd. We draw on years of experience helping high-caliber students showcase the best versions of themselves in their applications. We pride ourselves on staying informed on the evolving MBA admissions space and, as members of the Association of International Graduate Admissions Consultants (AIGAC), hold ourselves to the highest ethical standards when serving clients.

 

Click here to know more about our standalone services

4.9 /5 Average Rating
5 star
67
4 star
2
3 star
0
2 star
1
1 star
1
Based on 71 reviews

AI Super-Summary of Customer Reviews for The Red Pen Admissions Consulting*

The Red Pen (TRP) has been highly praised for its expert guidance and personalized support in MBA admissions, contributing to numerous successful applications to top schools including Stanford, Wharton, Kellogg, and Yale. The team-based approach allows for comprehensive scrutiny and iteration of application components such as essays, resumes, and interviews, ensuring applicants present their strongest profiles. Despite a few negative experiences citing delays and communication issues, the majority of clients commend TRP consultants for their dedication, strategic insights, and ability to adapt to individual applicant needs. Many reviews highlight significant achievements, from gaining admissions to prestigious programs to securing scholarships, underscoring TRP's effectiveness in the competitive admissions landscape.
9 users mention "Interview Prep"
  • "fared well at business school interviews due to the mock interviews conducted by the team..." Read more
  • "preparing for interviews..." Read more
  • "multiple mock interviews..." Read more
  • "perfecting my essays and preparing for interviews..." Read more
  • "mentoring me and leading me across the line..." Read more
  • "guidance with the interview preparation..." Read more
  • "multiple updates for the admissions committee..." Read more
  • "assisting me with developing a waitlist strategy..." Read more
  • "mock interviews..." Read more
8 users mention "Supportive"
  • "Learn from their team of experts who excel at all they do..." Read more
  • "supportive and encouraging throughout the Waitlist process..." Read more
  • "very comfortable working with all the team members..." Read more
  • "guide me through every step..." Read more
  • "Manan was incredibly patient, kind, and genuinely helpful..." Read more
  • "felt supported and confident throughout the application process..." Read more
  • "dedicated support..." Read more
  • "unwavering support..." Read more
8 users mention "Full Service"
  • "multiple perspectives I received throughout my application journey..." Read more
  • "personalized advice and insights that proved invaluable..." Read more
  • "well prepared in my applications..." Read more
  • "guidance, and mentorship of the entire team..." Read more
  • "prompting deep reflection on various aspects of my life..." Read more
  • "their support and guidance..." Read more
  • "amazing depth across all components and stages of the application process..." Read more
  • "refining my application, CV, LinkedIn profile, etc...." Read more
4 users mention "Career Transition"
  • "they really prepare you to take on other colleges yourself..." Read more
  • "stand out from other applicants..." Read more
  • "extremely stressed and kind of clueless before starting with my applications..." Read more
  • "Dhiraj personally took time out to help out..." Read more
3 users mention "Scholarship Awarded"
3 users mention "Admitted"
  • "got off the Fuqua Waitlist with a merit scholarship..." Read more
  • "I received an acceptance letter from my Yale and ISB..." Read more
  • "resulted in me getting interviews at every school..." Read more
3 users mention "Responsive"
  • "has always been quick in responding..." Read more
  • "very approachable and willing to help anytime I reached out..." Read more
  • "WhatsApp group for communication, which made discussions prompt..." Read more
3 users mention "Non-traditional Backgrounds"
  • "multiple perspectives I received..." Read more
  • "had an extremely unconventional profile..." Read more
  • "my circumstances were unique..." Read more
3 users mention "Top-Tier School Focus"
  • "top business schools in the US..." Read more
  • "Booth, Kellogg, Ross, Anderson, and Stern..." Read more
  • "admissions consultant for me..." Read more
2 users mention "Essay Editing"
  • "Pradyot ensured that I put my best foot forward with the essays..." Read more
  • "tailor-made to fit each school..." Read more
2 users mention "Time Management"
  • "extremely punctual..." Read more
  • "submitting my applications on the very last day..." Read more
2 users mention "Detail-Oriented"
  • "requires a whole lot of self work as well..." Read more
  • "detailed feedback that allowed for much greater clarity..." Read more
1 users mention "Value for Money"
  • "The personalized care and advice..." Read more
1 users mention "Global Expertise"
  • "cultural insights, adding depth to our relationship..." Read more
1 users mention "Industry Specialist"
  • "excel at providing correct guidance..." Read more
1 users mention "Resume Review"
  • "work with me on my Resume (which was a LOT of work)..." Read more
1 users mention "Inexperienced"
  • "I came into the applications process with limited knowledge..." Read more
1 users mention "Unsuccessful"
  • "While I did not get in the college we worked together on..." Read more
1 users mention "No Improvement"
1 users mention "Impersonal"
  • "the consultants came across as rude or dismissive..." Read more
*Review summaries are AI generated from 25 latest reviews in the past 2 years.
April 12, 2025
samyak1929

Joined: Jul 24, 2020

Posts: 9

Kudos: 0

Personalized Team Help

REVIEWER IDENTITY VERIFIED by membership [?]

Applying for an MBA was quite stressful, especially while balancing work alongside the application process. However, the Red Pen team really helped to make it a smooth, step-by-step experience. They have a dedicated team, with each member specializing in a specific aspect of the application process. The lead specialist made sure I met all my deadlines and regularly followed up with me, ensuring that I made steady progress throughout the entire process. They are extremely patient throughout the process; I lost count on the number of revisions that were done throughout the process.

I would highly recommend them for the personalized approach they provide.

Read More

April 10, 2025
anuj2708

Joined: Aug 24, 2020

Posts: 0

Kudos: 0

Verified GMAT Focus score:
715 Q84 V90 DI83

MBA Admissions Journey with The Red Pen

REVIEWER IDENTITY VERIFIED by score report [?]

Working with The Red Pen has been one of the best rewarding decisions of my MBA admissions journey. From the very beginning, the team demonstrated a remarkable level of professionalism, insight, and most importantly, personalization that truly set them apart.

What stood out the most was how deeply invested the consultants were in understanding me—not just as an applicant, but as a person. They took the time to conduct detailed brainstorming sessions that went far beyond the surface. With their guidance, I was able to uncover powerful, authentic stories from my background that I might never have considered highlighting. These stories ultimately became the backbone of a compelling and cohesive application.

The support I received was prompt, thoughtful, and consistently above and beyond expectations. Whether it was refining my goals, perfecting my essays, or navigating the nuances of school-specific requirements, the team was there every step of the way. Their insights into what top schools are really looking for were incredibly valuable and helped me craft a narrative that was not only strong on paper but also genuinely reflective of who I am.

A special shoutout goes to Gunjan, my lead consultant, whose strategic guidance and unwavering support were instrumental throughout the process. Her clarity of thought, honest feedback, and meticulous attention to detail made a huge difference in shaping my application. I always felt heard and supported, and her commitment to excellence pushed me to bring out my very best.

Another huge thanks to Manan, my LOR consultant, whose sharp eye and thoughtful suggestions helped transform my recommenders’ inputs into polished, impactful letters. He was incredibly responsive and brought a lot of value to a part of the application that is often underestimated.

Thanks to The Red Pen, I not only secured admission to a top-tier MBA program but also walked away with greater self-awareness and confidence in my professional story. I wholeheartedly recommend them to anyone looking for a strategic, insightful, and genuinely supportive admissions partner.

Read More

April 09, 2025
Yashpbajaj

Joined: Apr 02, 2025

Posts: 0

Kudos: 0

Verified GMAT Focus score:
725 Q90 V85 DI83

Exceptional Admission Consulting Services

REVIEWER IDENTITY VERIFIED by score report [?]

Working with The Red Pen was truly one of the best decisions I made during my admissions journey. I had the chance to work closely with Shreya Bajaj, Natasha Mankikar, and the rest of the team, and I genuinely couldn’t have asked for better support during such a high-stakes and often overwhelming process.

From the very beginning, they took the time to understand my background, goals, and what I hoped to convey through my applications. Their guidance was structured and thoughtful, and they consistently pushed me to dig deeper and tell my story in a way that felt both strategic and authentic.

What I appreciated most was how involved and responsive the team was throughout — especially when I decided to apply to one of the programs at the last minute. They immediately stepped in to help map out a clear plan and worked with me closely to meet tight deadlines, all while maintaining a very high standard of quality.

Shreya, Natasha, and the rest of the team brought a perfect balance of professionalism, empathy, and honest feedback. It truly felt like they were in my corner every step of the way — and I’m thrilled to say that I got into my top-choice school due to their incredible support. I’m incredibly grateful and would highly recommend The Red Pen to anyone navigating the admissions process.

Read More

April 09, 2025
Sanya0698

Joined: Mar 21, 2024

Posts: 1

Kudos: 0

MBA application experience with The Red Pen

REVIEWER IDENTITY VERIFIED by gmat club tests [?]

Strengths:

Structured approach
Experienced team
Honest, constructive feedback

I worked with Gunjan Jhunjhunwala for essays and Manan Maheshwari for resume and LORs at The Red Pen for my MBA applications. They’re both incredibly experienced, and the entire process was super structured, which made things feel clear from the start.

Gunjan really helped me challenge myself. She encouraged me to think more deeply about my experiences and goals, and made sure every part of my story came across as genuine and well structured. Her input was always constructive, specific, and honest in a way that felt supportive. That process pushed me to reflect more and helped me arrive at essays that felt truly personal.

Manan was amazing with the resume and LORs. His suggestions were clear and thoughtful. He helped me refine things without overcomplicating anything, and his approach was always calm and clear throughout.

Overall, the process can definitely feel challenging at times, but TRP really helps you stay focused, brings out your best, and pushes you in a way that makes your story stronger and more authentic. Would absolutely recommend them.

Read More

April 08, 2025
ArijitSarkar

Joined: Mar 06, 2023

Posts: 0

Kudos: 0

Overall Experience

REVIEWER IDENTITY VERIFIED by score report [?]

Strengths:

The one on one sessions, feedback sessions, brainstorming and the promptness of their response.
Additionally, the consultants cater to your availability and will provide you good advise provided you do your due diligence.

Would make the product better:

The free interview session was helpful but not enough. Although they gave personalized feedback on the interview, having a second session helps to know one's improvement. I feel it's upto the candidate to do what he wants without a check on him. This was totally unlike the normal application process where they help with everything.

Overall, i would rate their service a good 4.5/5. Having a personal lead consultant and a resume expert helps a lot and they always made sure to be available for me. They didn't rush me unnecessarily, and it was a good process overall. I have learned significantly and working with them was a good experience. They were candid in helping me set clear expectations based on my profile and I couldn't think of any reason why i wouldn't recommend them.
If money is tight, it can be a problem as their services don't come cheap but I thought of them as an investment and that landed me a full time position at HEC Paris with a scholarship.

Read More

April 08, 2025
SikandarSSekhon

Joined: Dec 12, 2024

Posts: 1

Kudos: 1

Admit to Bschools with $$ with help of The Red Pen consultancy

REVIEWER IDENTITY VERIFIED by school email address [?]

Strengths:

The services provided are customised and highly flexible. They go above and beyond their responsibilities to ensure maximum output by engaging and resolving issues proactively

Would make the product better:

Pricing is little on higher scale

The Red Pen team has been my one stop solution in my Bschool application journey. They have team of highly skilled professionals for resume building, essays and mock interviews. They take time to assign you a lead consultant with matching background. I was assisted by Shreya throughout the process. She had been proactive and extemely understanding throughout the journey. Her advice helped me not only with essays but also with my interviews. Always available to assist and hop on a call to resolve any blockers. The attention to detail was cherry on top. Her assistance with frameworks helped me in going through interviews very smoothly. A huge shout out to entire TRP team for keeping process extremely organized yet flexible. I have admit to CMU tepper, UNC KF and Darden with scholarships.

Read More

April 06, 2025
holamigo

Joined: Feb 26, 2024

Posts: 13

Kudos: 14

Verified GMAT Focus score:
715 Q90 V85 DI81

Commercialised Services - no personal touch or guidance

REVIEWER IDENTITY VERIFIED by score report [?]

Strengths:

They talk about access to their metis platform - 0 utility apart from tracking docs

Would make the product better:

-> Be invested in the candidate, improve work ethic. They currently treat it like a job.
-> At one point, when I asked followup questions on the WA group - I felt like I was being bullied by their resume consultant. They need some soft skills/empathy building workshops.
-> Resume consultant - hygiene tips, no recommendation of improving content. If my current role had much more impact then my precious role, they still made me have 3 points for each so it would *seem* both roles had similar impact. This is a wrong tactic, more impact should have more importance than optics of resume.
->Lead consultant was not good as well, it did seem that she lacked subject depth. She gave 0 inputs on optional essays, only covered the 2/3 compulsory essays. She also kept on pushing for selecting schools which had easier essays.
-> Their STAR stories format for experiences was also not followed, the essay writing process was fully unstructured.

Would not recommend. At this price point (2L for 1 school) - I expect much better quality. Their promises in the ad-copy were not followed. There are much better consultants out there. Like i said before, it did seem that my lead consultant lacked subject depth. She gave 0 inputs on optional essays, only covered the 2/3 compulsory essays. She also kept on pushing for selecting schools which had easier essays. I believe experiences depend upon the consultant one gets from the team, so you might hear conflicting reviews about this consultant-company. At one point, when I asked followup questions on the WA group - I felt like I was being bullied by their resume consultant. They need some soft skills/empathy building workshops.

Read More

April 10, 2025
TheRedPen

Thank you for sharing your feedback. We strive to offer a structured and supportive experience, with internal processes to ensure client satisfaction and concern redressal. We note that these channels were not utilized during your engagement and would like to understand your experience better. Reach out to us at team.mba@theredpen.in

March 29, 2025
shmora

Joined: Mar 29, 2025

Posts: 0

Kudos: 0

Highly recommend using The Red Pen

REVIEWER IDENTITY VERIFIED by score report [?]

Strengths:

- Highly responsive team
- Quick turnaround times with edits
- Supportive and clear communication

Would make the product better:

- Include more than one mock interview in the 1-school package.

I had a great experience with TRP who played a crucial role in my acceptance into my first-choice MBA program.

Initially, I spoke with Natasha, whose guidance immediately stood out. Unlike other consulting firms that insisted I needed a higher GRE score, Natasha reassured me and provided actionable insights on strengthening my profile in other impactful ways. This approach convinced me to choose TRP.

I worked closely with Shyam, my lead consultant and Manan, my Letter of Recommendation consultant, both of whom were excellent. Shyam was incredibly skilled at brainstorming compelling stories from my background and provided me with a clear framework to structure my essays effectively. He was always available to chat which I found impressive, especially given the significant time difference.

Manan assisted me greatly with my letters of recommendation. His guidance on selecting and shaping stories aligned perfectly with what admissions committees seek. Notably, when one of my recommenders unexpectedly dropped out just days before the deadline, Manan quickly helped me secure and develop a strong third recommendation. I really appreciated his patience and kindness throughout this process.

Finally, Anju conducted my mock interview, offering valuable feedback that highlighted areas where my responses could improve and helped me convey my enthusiasm for the school more effectively.

I opted for a single-school package, but the comprehensive support I received from TRP significantly eased the process for my other MBA applications as well. Overall, my experience with TRP was exceptional, and I wholeheartedly recommend their services. I really enjoyed working with the entire team who was assigned to me.

Read More

January 12, 2025
Girinath

Joined: Jan 11, 2023

Posts: 0

Kudos: 2

Great experience working with The Red Pen

REVIEWER IDENTITY VERIFIED by score report [?]

I worked with The Red Pen for my applications to 6 schools and got into Kellogg, Stern, and UCLA, and was waitlisted at Haas and Cornell. I’m really happy with the outcome and would attribute a large part of this to Shreya Bajaj, my lead consultant, Kshitij Malhotra, content specialist, and Anju Goela, my LoR specialist. For every question I had, they provided great advice promptly, and the service was personalized from start to finish. Their methodical approach, combined with strong domain knowledge, made the application process much simpler for me. Shreya’s honest feedback on my interview prep helped me convert all the interviews I was called for. Her background in tech also made the brainstorming process much more relatable and easier. Since I applied to several schools, I had less time to prepare quality applications, but the team worked hard to ensure everything was submitted on time without compromising much on quality, helping me get into great schools.

Read More

January 03, 2025
kabirbajaj

Joined: Nov 12, 2022

Posts: 0

Kudos: 0

Verified GMAT Focus score:
695 Q84 V86 DI83

Strengths:

The MBA package offered by Anju and The Red Pen team stands out for its exceptional personalized services. They take the time to truly understand your background, goals, and aspirations, ensuring every part of your application reflects your best self. One of the biggest strengths of their approach is their persistence in crafting the perfect essays—they meticulously work through multiple iterations to magnify the strengths of your narrative and make your story compelling. Additionally, their attention to detail goes beyond just essays; they thoroughly review every aspect of your application, including the form, to ensure consistency and alignment with your overall profile. This comprehensive, tailored support makes the entire process feel seamless and significantly boosts your confidence as an applicant.

Would make the product better:

One area where I feel the process could improve is the interview preparation. The package included just one mock interview, which felt a bit limiting for someone like me who needed more practice and candid feedback to refine my responses.

Working with Anju was one of the best decisions I made during my MBA application journey. From day one, she took the time to understand me—my background, my goals, and what I wanted to achieve with an MBA. She guided me through the entire process, from choosing schools to perfecting my essays and preparing for interviews.

What really stood out was her dedication. She went through countless drafts with me, and her feedback always helped me get closer to the perfect version of my application. It wasn’t always easy—there were definitely moments when I felt overwhelmed—but her encouragement and belief in me made all the difference.

In the end, I got into my top-choice MBA program out of the four schools I applied to in Round 1, and I couldn’t have done it without her. If you’re looking for someone who will be your biggest cheerleader while also giving you honest, actionable advice, Anju is the one.

Read More