A basket contains 3 blue, 3 red and 3 yellow marbles. If 3

Question

A basket contains 3 blue, 3 red and 3 yellow marbles. If 3 marbles are extracted from the basket at random, what is the probability that a marble of each color is among the extracted?

A. 2/21
B. 3/25
C. 1/6
D. 9/28
E. 11/24

Bunuel · Accepted Answer

Mathematically the probability of picking 3 marbles simultaneously, or picking them one at a time (without replacement) is the same.

A basket contains 3 blue, 3 red and 3 yellow marbles. If 3 marbles are extracted from the basket at random, what is the probability that a marble of each color is among the extracted? 
A. 2/21
B. 3/25
C. 1/6
D. 9/28
E. 11/24

We need to find the probability of BRY (a marble of each color).

Probability approach:

P(BRY)=\frac{3}{9}*\frac{3}{8}*\frac{3}{7}*3!=\frac{9}{28} , we are multiplying by 3! since BRY scenario can occur in several different ways: BRY, RYB, RBY (# of permutations of 3 distinct letters BRY is 3!).

Combination approach:

P(BRY)=\frac{C^1_3*C^1_3*C^1_3}{C^3_9}=\frac{9}{28} .

Answer: D.

Hope it's clear.

KillerSquirrel · Answer

9/9*6/8*3/7 = 9/28 the answer is (D)

sevenplus · Answer

Probability of getting each color marble = (3C1*3C1*3C1)/9C3
 = (3*3*3)/84
 = 27/84 = 9/28
So answer is D

GK_Gmat · Answer

KS, can you please explain how you get 3/7? 

I'm assuming you did the following:
The 1st chosen can be any color and it doesn't really matter so let's say the first chosen is Blue. 

The probability that the 2nd chosen is not blue = 1-2/8 = 6/8

Now what?? How do I proceed? Thanks!

KillerSquirrel · Answer

You are right about the first marble , you can choose any marble out of nine = 9/9 = 1 (nine out of nine). For the second marble you are also correct - since you removed one marble from the basket you now have eight left but you can't choose the color already been choosen so 6/8 (six out of eight - three for one color and three for the other color). For the third marble the logic is the same - you can choose one of the three marbles from the color not already choosen and you have seven mables to choose from meaning 3/7 (three out seven). All of this is true only when the marbles taken out are not returned to the basket - if they were the probability then was ?? - can you solve this ?

GMAT TIGER · Answer

alternatively:

= (3c1 x 3c1 x 3c1)/9c3
= 9/28

bmwhype2 · Answer

yep. most intuitive approach. 

desired/total

OA is D

jimmyjamesdonkey · Answer

For me it was easier to just write it out.

I need 3 different colors so, we'll say I wanted a red, blue, yellow.

So chance of picking a red = 3/9

On 2nd pick chance of picking a blue = 3/8

On 3rd pick chance of picking a yellow = 3/7.

Then I listed out the different 3 ball combos I could have.

BRY
BYR
RBY
RYB
YRB
YBR

So 6 different combos. So the prob of pick r,b,y is 3/9 * 3/8 * 3/7 = 3/56

Multiply that by 6 and you have 9/28 prob of picking three different colored balls.

srivas · Answer

A basket contains 3 blue, 3 red and 3 yellow marbles.
If 3 marbles are extracted from the basket at random, what is the probability that a marble of each color is among the extracted?

2/21
3/25
1/6
9/28
11/24

Soln:
= 3C1 * 3C1 * 3C1/9C3
= 27/(9 * 8 * 7/6)
= 27/84
= 9/28

144144 · Answer

Hey guys,

I understand the solution, but i need someone to explain me why the following is not working:

total groups of 3 - 9C3

total options of 3 different color:
abc
acb
bac
bca
cab
cba

so - 6 options to get 3 different colors.

6/84 is not the answer.

please help me find the mistake. thanks.

shahideh · Answer

We can choose 3 balls from 9 balls. Total possibilities:  C^9_3 
We should choose 1 ball from each color. Favorite possibilities:  C^3_1*C^3_1*C^3_1

p=\frac{C^3_1*C^3_1*C^3_1}{C^9_3}=\frac{9}{28} 
 D

malikshilpa · Answer

Is ' picking of 3 marbles at random' same as 'picking 3 marbles one by on without replacement' ? Although looking at the solution these two scenarios appear to be similar. However, when 3 marbles are picked up together (in one shot) then should the problem not be treated differently. Please clarify .

TheBookie · Answer

Just wanted to clarify here, as I feel like I'm looking at this wrong
n should be 3 (because this is the total set)
r should be 1 (this is the number of objects being extracted)

so shouldn't the combination formula be C 3 over 1? Instead of C 1 over 3?

Bunuel · Answer

C^1_3 ,  C^3_1 , 3C1, mean the same thing choosing 1 out of 3, just different ways to write. Can it be choosing 3 out of 1???

TheBookie · Answer

Agreed, but for the sake of consistency, I see the combination formula written as C n over r https://www.mathwords.com/c/combination_formula.htm Thanks

russ9 · Answer

Hi Bunuel,

I have a question with the methodology here -- I can follow the work you're doing but i'm having a hard time understanding why. Can you please clarify the reasoning?

a) In your statement below, can you please elaborate WHY we multiply by 3!? --    P=\frac{3}{9}*\frac{3}{8}*\frac{3}{7}*3!=\frac{9}{28}

If I reference the GMAT club book, I don't see it referencing the multiplication by a factorial(Page 109 of the book).

b) What is the difference between the method you used vs. doing the following? (9/9)(6/8)(3/7)

c) lastly, regarding your combinatorial approach, isn't that technically a reverse approach(pg 109 of the book)? Sorry if i'm being trivial here but i'm having a hard time connecting the dots hence the trivial questions. How can you use the 1C3 approach because don't you have 9 to begin with? Sorry - i'm going nuts here.

salonipatil · Answer

I'm trying to understand the basics, please excuse me if you find the question too silly:
Why don't we multiple by 3! in combinatorics method?
So first it's choosing i.e. 3C1 * 3C1* 3C1
Then why aren't the chosen balls arranged amongst themselves in 3! ways?

chetan2u · Answer

hi,
We are not doing so, because it will not effect the answer..
if you consider ORDER important, even the TOTAL ways will be multiplied by 3!..
ans =  p=\frac{C^3_1*C^3_1*C^3_1*3!}{C^9_3*3!}=\frac{9}{28}

hero_with_1000_faces · Answer

Hey  GMATBusters

can you please help me the query stated above

a) In your statement below, can you please elaborate WHY we multiply by 3!? --    P=\frac{3}{9}*\frac{3}{8}*\frac{3}{7}*3!=\frac{9}{28}

b) What is the difference between the method you used vs. doing the following? (9/9)(6/8)(3/7)
 
c) lastly, regarding your combinatorial approach, isn't that technically a reverse approach(pg 109 of the book)?

A basket contains 3 blue, 3 red and 3 yellow marbles. If 3

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

GMAT Problem Solving (PS) Questions

A basket contains 3 blue, 3 red and 3 yellow marbles. If 3

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards