aritrar4
hi
AndrewN , could you please help me with choices B and E here? I'm confused as to why the usage of present perfect would be incorrect here. I feel that a person's creations can continue to inspire several generations after that person's time and so the "fellow citizens" could actually mean citizens across generations as opposed to only Lincoln's contemporaries.
So "have been inspirational" sounds correct to me. Choice E however has a mix of the past and the present tense, which I know isn't incorrect in context of the sentence, but I just couldn't find a way to eliminate B. Would really appreciate your help on this, thanks !
B. were as inspirational to his fellow citizens as they are
E. have been as inspirational to his fellow citizens as
Praveenksinha
I am having doubt between B and E, can anyone please explain why E is wrong?
In idiom " as X as Y " is X and Y must be parallel?
What do you know? Back-to-back questions about the same two answer choices. (Lucky me.) If you break down choice (E), it falls apart in its expressed meaning. Consider what (E) would be saying, in light of the fact that
to ours is a parallel element to
to his. First, the sentence, with (E) inserted:
Abraham Lincoln's simple writing style and enduring themes—the spirit of the common man, the importance of hard work, and the necessity of cooperation—have been as inspirational to his fellow citizens as to ours.I can appreciate the point that words and themes can reach across time, but
citizens cannot. Abraham Lincoln died in 1865, and the comparison between
his fellow citizens and
our fellow citizens necessitates a clean break between past and present. In other words, the writing and themes
were as inspirational to people living at that time, in the mid-1800s, as those same words
are to us in the present. If the sentence were comparing the citizens of two different countries
now, then the present perfect tense would be fitting.
I hope that helps. Thank you,
aritrar4, for thinking to ask me about the question. I had not seen it before.
- Andrew