mailolo
Hi,
MartyMurray . Request help with Q5.
Here's an explanation for Question 5.
5. The author would be most likely to agree with which one of the following statements?(A) Because the Indus Valley region is prone to earthquakes, it is most likely that an earthquake destroyed the Indus Valley civilization.Scanning the passage for "earthquakes," we see that it says the following:
Or, a massive earthquake in this seismically volatile region may have changed the course of rivers and disrupted many cities, spurring a migration of refugees to the countryside.
We see that the author mentions earthquakes as one possible cause of the disappearance of the Indus Valley civilization, not as the "most likely" cause.
So, in saying "it is most likely," this choice goes beyond what's supported by the passage.
Eliminate
(B) Only a disaster as catastrophic as an earthquake would have caused the demise of a civilization as sophisticated as the Indus Valley civilization.The author says that evidence "suggests" that a major disaster caused the demise of the Indus Valley civilization but does not generalize that statement to one about "a civilization as sophisticated as the Indus Valley civilization." In other words the author does not suggest that the demise of any such civilization would be caused only by "a disaster as catastrophic as an earthquake."
So, this choice is not supported by the passage.
Eliminate.
(C) Archaeologists' understanding of the decline of the Indus Valley civilization would benefit from a search for signs of earthquake damage in its cities.The author says the following about "understanding of the decline of the Indus Valley civilization."
The causes of the civilization's decline, however, are not certain
Then, later in the passage the author suggests the following:
Or, a massive earthquake in this seismically volatile region may have changed the course of rivers and disrupted many cities, spurring a migration of refugees to the countryside.
Given that the author says that the causes of the decline are "not certain" and indicates that one possible cause of the decline is "a massive earthquake," it makes sense that the author "would agree" that "Archaeologists' understanding of the decline of the Indus Valley civilization would benefit from a search for signs of earthquake damage in its cities." After all, such a search would likely help archeologists to determine whether a massive earthquake was indeed the cause of the decline.
Now, since the passage mentions that an earthquake may have spurred a "migration" whereas this choice mentions "the decline," some people may be reluctant to choose this choice because a "migration" may be different from a "decline." Here's the thing though.
The discussion of an earthquake causing migration appears in the context of the author's discussion of "the causes of the civilization's decline." Also, the author says that a disaster could have caused "the large empire disintegrating into many regional cultures," which would be a type of decline. So, we can presume that the author considers "migration of refugees to the countryside" a decline in the Indus Valley civilization, particularly since the author uses the word "refugees," which has connotations of a decline in circumstances associated with forced fleeing from a disaster.
So, this choice is supported by the passage.
Keep.
(D) The cities of the Indus Valley civilization should have been better prepared for the possibility of a major earthquake.The author neither says or implies anything about the level of preparation for an earthquake of the cities of the Indus Valley civilization or what the cities "should" have done.
Also, the author doesn't even conclude that earthquakes caused the demise of the Indus Valley civilization.
Eliminate.
(E) The demise of the Indus Valley civilization was most likely caused by the catastrophic alteration of the courses of its major rivers.Scanning the passage for information on "alteration of the courses of its major rivers," we see the following:
a massive earthquake in this seismically volatile region may have changed the course of rivers and disrupted many cities
We see that the author mentions "alteration," or change of the courses of rivers as one possible cause of the disappearance of the Indus Valley civilization, not as the "most likely" cause.
So, in saying "was most likely caused," this choice goes beyond what the passage supports.
Eliminate.
The correct answer is (C).