leo125
Experts...plz help with Q1..??
Here's the question again:
Quote:
1. The author of the passage would be most likely to agree with which of the following statements about the explanation outlined in highlighted text?
And here's the relevant portion of the passage:
Quote:
The Hopis’ retention of their distinctive socio-cultural system has been attributed to the Hopi religious elite’s determined efforts to preserve their religion and way of life, and also to a geographical isolation greater than that of many other Native American groups, an isolation that limited both cultural contact and exposure to European diseases.
The highlighted text itself presents two factors to explain why the Hopis retained their distinctive socio-cultural system: the efforts of Hopi religious elites and the group's geographical isolation. Moving on from this highlighted text, the author presents a third factor: the flexibility of that system. The author brings this up to stress that this third factor was equally important to the retention of the Hopi's system.
As we evaluate answer choices, remember that "it" always refers to the highlighted text.
Quote:
(A)It fails to take into account the effect of geographical circumstances on Hopi culture.
This completely contradicts the highlighted text, which plainly states that geographical circumstances were one of the key factors contributing to retention of the Hopi socio-cultural system. Eliminate (A).
Quote:
(B)It correctly emphasizes the role of the religious elite in maintaining the system of matrilineal clans.
The phrase "matrilineal clans" stops us from accepting this answer choice. The consideration of these clans is not part of the highlighted text. It comes later, in support of the author's consideration of social flexibility. Eliminate (C).
Quote:
(C)It represents a misreading of Hopi culture because it fails to take into account the actual differences that existed among the various Hopi clans.
This is totally off the mark. The highlighted text may leave out the third factor of flexibility, but the author never indicates that accepting these other two factors is a
misreading of Hopi culture. Rather, the author agrees with the highlighted text and wishes to add a third piece of the puzzle to complete this picture. Eliminate (C).
Quote:
(D)It underestimates the effect on Hopi cultural development of contact with other cultural groups.
The author wrote this passage to explain why contact with outside groups did
not lead to significant changes in Hopi society. This choice goes in a totally different direction, which doesn't reflect the highlighted text and runs completely counter to why the author writes those highlighted statements. Eliminate (D).
Quote:
(E)It is correct but may be insufficient in itself to explain Hopi sociocultural persistence.
This is the correct choice we've been looking for! It perfectly matches why the author is bringing up the highlighted text: the author believes that these statements are true, but also believes there is a third, equally important factor that must be considered.
(E) is the best choice, and every other choice can be eliminated confidently. I hope this helps!
AdityaHongunti
pikolo2510
hello GMATNinja
Can you explain Q2 in this passage?
I'll volunteer.
2. Which of the following can be inferred from the passage about the Hopis' geographic situation between 1680 and 1880?
(A)
It prevented the Hopis from experiencing a diminution in population.- the choice implies that the Geo location helpedin preventing hopis from diminution -para 1( often characterize Hopi society between 1680 and 1880 as surprisingly stable, considering that it was a period of diminution in population and pressure from contact with outside groups, factors that might be expected to cause significant changes in Hopi social arrangements. ) the anthropologists say that the hopis society was surprisingly stable . why was it surprising? read the next part after surprisingly stable. The diminution of Pop has been cited as a contast just to weigh in on the surprising stability.Nowhere is it related to Geo Loc.
(B)
It helped to promote flexibility within their social system. - Entirely goes against the given facts. In fact not the GL but the society's inherent flexibilty helped the retention of culture.
(C) It limited but did not eliminate contact with other cultural groups.- para 2 (a geographical isolation greater than that of many other Native American groups, an isolation that limited both cultural contact and exposure to European diseases). Now the passage states that the GL limited the cultural contact. it did not eliminate it! how do we know this? read the later part of the para 2. evidently other cultural groups(clans) did come into their contact and even were a part of the culture.
(D)
It reinforced the religious elite's determination to resist cultural change.- para 2. (Hopis’
retention of their distinctive sociocultural system has been attributed to the Hopi religious elite’s determined efforts to preserve their religion and way of life, and also to a geographical isolation )note here that the passage states that the retention was attributed to 2 things. nowhere is it mentioned that the elite's stance was strengthed by the GL.
(E)
It tended to limit contact between certain Hopi clans.- certain hopi clans? nowhere is it mentioned that there were particular clans the hopis's tried to stay away from. " certain" is the culprit here
Great work,
AdityaHongunti!