MBAUncle
Many who were defferred had been accepted on other schools later.
This doesn't make a ton of sense to me for a few reasons-
1. Per their own policy, Tuck doesn't accept deferrals unless students submit a deposit and then request a deferral (see the website- I can't post the link). So, these 50 students essentially chose to attend Tuck and submitted a deposit before attempting to defer. It should seem like they have at least some commitment to Tuck/actually want to go there.
2. If you look at last year's forum, Tuck didn't start offering incentives to defer until June or so. By then, it seems like 99% of acceptances at other schools would have already been granted. Sure, maybe a student or two deferred at Tuck, got off of a late summer waitlist somewhere and opted to go elsewhere, but that doesn't seem likely for very many applicants.
3. If students who deferred decided to apply again this year, they wouldn't know about admissions results yet and most likely won't renege on their Tuck offer without an offer somewhere else. Therefore, Tuck probably won't know for sure that deferrals aren't coming until at least the R1 results come out at other schools.
I just have a hard time seeing how 50 deferrals (combined with the biggest pool of EA apps ever!)
doesn't impact chances this year- both in 50 spots in the class already being reserved and that Tuck most likely wants to avoid this situation in the future. I would guess we'll see a lower # of admits and a higher # of waitlisters (and acceptances off of the waitlist) to help them manage the yield.